All poems

当代 当代 · 诗 Poem

团泊洼的秋天

Autumn at Tuanpo Wa

郭小川

Guo Xiaochuan

秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼;
秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒。
高粱好似一队队的"红领巾",悄悄地把周围的道路观察;
向日葵摇头微笑着,望不尽太阳起处的红色天涯。
矮小而年高的垂柳,用苍绿的叶子抚摸着快熟的庄稼;
密集的芦苇,细心地护卫着脚下偷偷开放的野花。
蝉声消退了,多嘴的麻雀已不在房顶上吱喳;
蛙声停息了,野性的独流减河也不再喧哗。

Show full original poem

秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼;
秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒。
高粱好似一队队的"红领巾",悄悄地把周围的道路观察;
向日葵摇头微笑着,望不尽太阳起处的红色天涯。
矮小而年高的垂柳,用苍绿的叶子抚摸着快熟的庄稼;
密集的芦苇,细心地护卫着脚下偷偷开放的野花。
蝉声消退了,多嘴的麻雀已不在房顶上吱喳;
蛙声停息了,野性的独流减河也不再喧哗。
大雁即将南去,水上默默浮动着白净的野鸭;
秋凉刚刚在这里落脚,暑热还藏在好客的人家。
秋天的团泊洼啊,好像在香甜的梦中睡傻;
团泊洼的秋天啊,犹如少女一样羞羞答答。
团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗?
全世界都在喧腾,哪里没有雷霆怒吼,风去云变化!
是的,团泊洼是静静的,但时时都会轰轰爆炸!
是的,团泊洼是喧腾的,这首诗篇里就充满着嘈杂。
不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽。
……

Autumn is like a resilient comb, combing the quiet Tuanpo Wa;
autumn light is like a bead of sweat, shed bright and scattering over the flat shoal.
The sorghum stand like teams of young red scouts, quietly observing the roads about them;
the sunflowers shake and smile, and the red horizon where the sun rises has no end.
The low, aged willow strokes the nearly ripe grain with its dark green leaves;
dense reeds carefully guard the wild flowers that have quietly opened below.
The cicadas have gone, and the garrulous sparrows no longer chatter on the tiled roof;
the frogs are silent, and the wild Duliushu river no longer makes its noise.
The wild geese are about to go south, and white, clean ducks float in silence on the water;
the autumn chill has just set foot here, while the summer heat still hides in hospitable houses.
Autumn at Tuanpo Wa seems to have fallen asleep in a sweet dream;
autumn at Tuanpo Wa is like a shy young girl.
Tuanpo Wa, Tuanpo Wa - are you really this quiet?
All the world is in ferment. Where is there no thunder, no wind and cloud in tumult?
Yes, Tuanpo Wa is quiet - but every moment it may thunder and explode!
Yes, Tuanpo Wa is loud - this very poem is full of noise.
Still, let this poem of contradictions be buried beneath the dam;
it may not suit your autumn, but next spring it will take root and sprout.
Listen

Meaning

The poem describes the extreme quiet of a wetland in autumn, quiet as though asleep, or as a shy girl: sorghum watching the roads, sunflowers smiling at the red horizon, an aged willow stroking the ripening grain, reeds guarding wild flowers, the last cicadas gone, the frog and the river silent, geese about to fly south. Then the speaker interrupts this catalogue with two questions and two answers: yes, it is quiet, but it may thunder and explode at any moment; yes, it is loud, for this very poem is full of noise. The poem closes by asking that the contradictory lines be buried under the dam - unfitting for autumn, but certain, by next spring, to take root.

秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼;秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒。高粱好似一队队的「红领巾」,悄悄地把周围的道路观察;向日葵摇头微笑着,望不尽太阳起处的红色天涯。矮小而年高的垂柳,用苍绿的叶子抚摸着快熟的庄稼;密集的芦苇,细心地护卫着脚下偷偷开放的野花。蝉声消退了,多嘴的麻雀已不在房顶上吱喳;蛙声停息了,野性的独流减河也不再喧哗。大雁即将南去,水上默默浮动着白净的野鸭;秋凉刚刚在这里落脚,暑热还藏在好客的人家。秋天的团泊洼啊,好像在香甜的梦中睡傻;团泊洼的秋天啊,犹如少女一样羞羞答答。团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗?全世界都在喧腾,哪里没有雷霆怒吼,风去云变化!是的,团泊洼是静静的,但时时都会轰轰爆炸!是的,团泊洼是喧腾的,这首诗篇里就充满着嘈杂。不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽。……

Appreciation

[Plain Paraphrase] The first twelve lines are a catalogue of autumn noises gone quiet. [Structure] The poem is built as two halves: a long, patient description, and then a short dialectic of four lines in which the speaker contradicts himself twice and ends by proposing to bury the poem. [Imagery] The opening simile is the poem's key: autumn is a comb, and Tuanpo Wa is hair being combed - and it is repeated and varied: the light is a bead of sweat, the sorghum are red scouts, the sunflowers smile, the willow strokes the grain, the reeds guard flowers. Personification does the poem's work, and it is unusually consistent: everything in the landscape has a hand or a role. [Technique] The poem's central contrast is between the stillness outside and the storms within, and the speaker refuses to resolve it - 'quiet, but it may explode'. [Comment] The ending is the poem's real subject: the poet asks that his contradictory verses be buried like seed, on the argument that what does not suit the autumn will nonetheless sprout in spring.

【白话串讲】 郭小川写《团泊洼的秋天》:“秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼”——“秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒”——他写团泊洼的秋天——秋天像柔韧的梳子。 【意象与手法】 “秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼”以拟人比喻写秋景;“秋光如同发亮的汗珠”以通感写秋光;“高粱好似一队队的红领巾”写物象;“团泊洼团泊洼、你真是这样静静的吗”以反复诘问点出“静中有动”;结以“到明春准会生根发芽”寄寓希望。深沉含蓄、节奏舒展。 【情感与主旨】 写团泊洼的秋景,于“静”的表象下暗含激荡的心潮与对未来的信念。诗人身处逆境而心怀希望,将自然秋景与时代情怀结合,是郭小川“战士诗人”风格的体现。 【名句点睛】 常考“秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼”以梳子拟秋天;“它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽”以明春发芽写希望。

Background

Guo Xiaochuan (1919-1976), original name Guo Enda, was born in Fengning, Hebei, and became one of the most widely read poets of the People's Republic, remembered as much for his plain, workaday style as for his public role. In the middle of the 1970s, when this poem was written, he was sent to a labour school in Tuanpo Wa, a tract of lowland marsh near Tianjin, where much of his late verse was written. The poem's mixture of close observation of the marsh with a defiant public voice is characteristic of this late period: he writes as a citizen who has been told to be quiet, and answers with a description of quietness that will not stay quiet.

《团泊洼的秋天》为当代诗人郭小川所作诗。郭小川(1919—1976),原名郭恩大,河北丰宁人,当代诗人。此诗写景抒情,为咏团泊洼之秋之作。诗中「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼」写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼;「秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」写秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒;「高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察」写高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察;「团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗」写团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗;「不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽」写不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽。郭小川此诗以写景抒情、它也许不合你秋天的季节写其抒情之情,深沉含蓄,是郭小川诗中的名篇。

Art

The poem's chief device is the extended metaphor of the comb, which is introduced in the opening line and then abandoned in favour of a long run of humanised details - each of which continues the same idea that the land has a hand and a task. Four techniques follow from this. First, personification on a large scale: the willow 'strokes' the grain, the reeds 'guard' the flowers, the sparrows are 'garrulous'. Second, the accumulation of endings - cicadas gone, sparrows gone, frogs silent, the river hushed, the geese about to leave - so that emptiness is built up by subtraction rather than declared. Third, the refrain and the rhetorical question: 'Tuanpo Wa, Tuanpo Wa - are you really this quiet?' breaks the catalogue and converts description into argument. Fourth, the closing gesture of burial and rebirth, which turns the poem itself into a seed. The last device is the most striking, and the poem's whole optimism is concentrated there.

此诗艺术上以「深沉含蓄、以景写情」见长。全诗共十八行,由秋天像一把柔韧的梳子而秋光如同发亮的汗珠而高粱好似一队队的红领巾。起「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼」写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子:秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼;「秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」写秋光如同发亮的汗珠:秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒;「高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察」写高粱好似一队队的红领巾:高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察;「团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗」写团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗:团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗;结「不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽」写它也许不合你秋天的季节:不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽。全诗以景写情,由秋天像一把柔韧的梳子而它也许不合你秋天的季节,深沉含蓄,是郭小川诗中的名篇。

Allusions

There are no allusions in the classical sense; the poem's references are to its own decade. 红领巾, red scouts, is the uniform of the Young Pioneers and supplies both the colour of the sorghum and the image of watchers, so the landscape becomes a school parade. 雷霆, thunder, and 轰轰爆炸, roaring explosions, are the vocabulary of the political weather of the period, and the poem's point is precisely to set them against the marsh. 独流减河 is the local name of a river near the marsh, and the poet uses it as a real detail against which the grander words are heard. The closing image of a buried poem that will sprout is the one place where the poem moves into legend - it recalls the fable of seed buried in the ground, and the line reads as the poet's own creed.

诗中「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子梳理着静静的团泊洼」「秋光如同发亮的汗珠飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」「高粱好似一队队的红领巾悄悄地把周围的道路观察」「向日葵摇头微笑着望不尽太阳起处的红色天涯」「矮小而年高的垂柳用苍绿的叶子抚摸着快熟的庄稼」「密集的芦苇细心地护卫着脚下偷偷开放的野花」「蝉声消退了多嘴的麻雀已不在房顶上吱喳」「蛙声停息了野性的独流减河也不再喧哗」「大雁即将南去水上默默浮动着白净的野鸭」「秋凉刚刚在这里落脚暑热还藏在好客的人家」「秋天的团泊洼啊好像在香甜的梦中睡傻」「团泊洼的秋天啊犹如少女一样羞羞答答」「团泊洼团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗」「全世界都在喧腾哪里没有雷霆怒吼风去云变化」「是的团泊洼是静静的但时时都会轰轰爆炸」「是的团泊洼是喧腾的这首诗篇里就充满着嘈杂」「不管怎样且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下」「它也许不合你秋天的季节但到明春准会生根发芽」等语,皆含典故故实。「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子梳理着静静的团泊洼」写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子梳理着静静的团泊洼;「秋光如同发亮的汗珠飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」写秋光如同发亮的汗珠飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒;「高粱好似一队队的红领巾悄悄地把周围的道路观察」写高粱好似一队队的红领巾悄悄地把周围的道路观察;「向日葵摇头微笑着望不尽太阳起处的红色天涯」写向日葵摇头微笑着望不尽太阳起处的红色天涯;「矮小而年高的垂柳用苍绿的叶子抚摸着快熟的庄稼」写矮小而年高的垂柳用苍绿的叶子抚摸着快熟的庄稼;「密集的芦苇细心地护卫着脚下偷偷开放的野花」写密集的芦苇细心地护卫着脚下偷偷开放的野花;「蝉声消退了多嘴的麻雀已不在房顶上吱喳」写蝉声消退了多嘴的麻雀已不在房顶上吱喳;「蛙声停息了野性的独流减河也不再喧哗」写蛙声停息了野性的独流减河也不再喧哗;「大雁即将南去水上默默浮动着白净的野鸭」写大雁即将南去水上默默浮动着白净的野鸭;「秋凉刚刚在这里落脚暑热还藏在好客的人家」写秋凉刚刚在这里落脚暑热还藏在好客的人家;「秋天的团泊洼啊好像在香甜的梦中睡傻」写秋天的团泊洼啊好像在香甜的梦中睡傻;「团泊洼的秋天啊犹如少女一样羞羞答答」写团泊洼的秋天啊犹如少女一样羞羞答答;「团泊洼团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗」写团泊洼团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗;「全世界都在喧腾哪里没有雷霆怒吼风去云变化」写全世界都在喧腾哪里没有雷霆怒吼风去云变化;「是的团泊洼是静静的但时时都会轰轰爆炸」写是的团泊洼是静静的但时时都会轰轰爆炸;「是的团泊洼是喧腾的这首诗篇里就充满着嘈杂」写是的团泊洼是喧腾的这首诗篇里就充满着嘈杂;「不管怎样且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下」写不管怎样且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下;「它也许不合你秋天的季节但到明春准会生根发芽」写它也许不合你秋天的季节但到明春准会生根发芽。诗人以红领巾、雷霆等语入诗,不着痕迹,而把写景抒情之情写得真切可感,是善于熔铸典故的体现。

Commentary

The poem is among the best known of Guo Xiaochuan's late work and is valued for exactly the quality its title advertises: an autumn that will not be swallowed whole. Critical reception has generally taken it as a document of its decade and as a proof of the poet's nerve - the way it describes outward calm and then insists, twice, that the calm is armed. Its ending is the part most often quoted: the poet asks that his contradictions be buried under the dam, on faith that they will sprout next spring. For readers looking for the continuity of Guo's career, the poem is characteristic in another way as well - it is a poem that describes a place exhaustively and then uses that place to argue about the nation.

这首《团泊洼的秋天》,是郭小川写写景抒情之作,写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子、秋光如同发亮的汗珠、高粱好似一队队的红领巾、团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗、它也许不合你秋天的季节之情,深沉含蓄。起「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼」——秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼。写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子:秋天像一把柔韧的梳子、梳理着静静的团泊洼——柔韧的梳子、团泊洼;「秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」——秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒。写秋光如同发亮的汗珠:秋光如同发亮的汗珠、飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒——发亮的汗珠、平滩上挥洒;「高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察」——高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察。写高粱好似一队队的红领巾:高粱好似一队队的红领巾、悄悄地把周围的道路观察——红领巾、观察;「团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗」——团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗。写团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗:团泊洼团泊洼、你真是这样静静的吗——静静的吗;结「不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽」——不管怎样,且把这矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下,它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽。写它也许不合你秋天的季节:矛盾重重的诗篇埋在坝下、它也许不合你秋天的季节、但到明春准会生根发芽——埋在坝下、生根发芽。这「它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽」,是全诗之结:以它也许不合你秋天的季节写其抒情。全诗深沉含蓄,以景写情,正是郭小川诗中的名篇。

Prosody

Form Free verse (modern Chinese poem, eighteen lines)诗(新诗·自由体)
Rhyme Unrhymed free verse, but the poem is scored on a long chain of near-rhymes in the rounded -a range - wa (洼), sa (洒), cha (察), ya (涯), jia (稼), hua (花), zha (喳), hua (哗), ya (鸭), jia (家), sha (傻), da (答), ma (吗), hua (化), zha (炸), za (杂), xia (下), ya (芽) - which give the poem its heavy, falling close.此诗为新诗自由体,共十八行。押韵:「洼」「洒」「察」「涯」「稼」「花」「喳」「哗」「鸭」「家」「傻」「答」「吗」「化」「炸」「杂」「下」「芽」押麻家部韵。诗体依自由体而定,句式长短错落,音节随情起伏,正与写写景抒情的深沉含蓄相称,也见其以自由体写秋的深沉。
Tone pattern The voice begins slow and unhurried, speeds through the catalogue, breaks twice on a repeated name, and stops at the end. Because the near-rhymes are all in the same vowel, the whole poem sounds like one continuous exclamation in the same key.句式上,「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼」写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,音节舒缓;「秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」写秋光如同发亮的汗珠,音节悠扬;「高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察」写高粱好似一队队的红领巾,音节深沉;「团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗」写团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗,音节低回;结「它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽」写它也许不合你秋天的季节,音节含蓄。全诗音节随情起伏,由舒缓而悠扬、由深沉而低回、由低回而含蓄,正合自由体「深沉」之妙,读来如写景抒情、它也许不合你秋天的季节之音,深沉而动人。
Reading note The poem is a free verse of the ordinary modern Chinese kind: no fixed line length, no fixed rhyme, and line lengths that follow the breath. Its music is made in three ways. First, the near-rhymes: although most of the lines do not rhyme exactly, they all end on the same rounded vowel, so the poem sounds rhymed even though it is not. Second, the refrain 'Tuanpo Wa, Tuanpo Wa', which appears at the poem's centre and returns the reader to the same two syllables. Third, the line lengths themselves, which are long and even through the catalogue and then break short at the argument - 'Yes, Tuanpo Wa is quiet - but every moment it may thunder and explode!' In reading aloud the catalogue should be delivered fast and flat, and the final four lines slowly, so that the contrast between marsh and thunder lands.此诗为新诗自由体,是郭小川写写景抒情之作,也是其诗中的名篇。全诗的艺术特色在于「深沉含蓄、以景写情」:「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼」写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子、「秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」写秋光如同发亮的汗珠、「高粱好似一队队的红领巾,悄悄地把周围的道路观察」写高粱好似一队队的红领巾、「团泊洼,团泊洼,你真是这样静静的吗」写团泊洼你真是这样静静的吗、「它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽」写它也许不合你秋天的季节。全诗深沉含蓄,以景写情。尤为精妙者,是「高粱好似一队队的红领巾」写尽红领巾之队;而「但到明春准会生根发芽」写尽生根发芽之情,正是郭小川诗「深沉含蓄」的典范,为历代选本所常收。

Line by line

秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼;

Autumn is like a resilient comb, combing the quiet Tuanpo Wa;

秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼;

Autumn is like a supple comb, combing the silent Tuanbo Marsh;

起句写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,起笔即见其秋。「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子」写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,「秋天」写秋天、「像一把柔韧的梳子」写像一把柔韧的梳子;「梳理着静静的团泊洼」写梳理着静静的团泊洼,「梳理着」写梳理着、「静静的团泊洼」写静静的团泊洼。一句写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子梳理着静静的团泊洼,以秋天像一把柔韧的梳子写柔韧的梳子、以梳理着静静的团泊洼写团泊洼,写尽秋天像一把柔韧的梳子、梳理着静静的团泊洼之情。以秋起兴,深沉而含蓄,是「以秋起兴」的妙笔。

The poem's opening domesticates a harsh place. Autumn is like a supple comb, combing the silent Tuanbo Marsh. The marsh, a desolate labor camp where the poet was confined, is groomed as if by a gentle hand; the comb is flexible, the marsh silent. The homely metaphor is the poet's defiance, finding tenderness in imprisonment. To have described the autumn marsh would be reportage; the supple comb combing it is the tenderness.

秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒。

autumn light is like a bead of sweat, shed bright and scattering over the flat shoal.

秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒。

The autumn light is like shining sweat-drops, drifting and scattering over the flat flats.

此句写秋光如同发亮的汗珠,是全诗写秋光之态的关键。「秋光如同发亮的汗珠」写秋光如同发亮的汗珠,「秋光」写秋光、「如同发亮的汗珠」写如同发亮的汗珠;「飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」写飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒,「飘飘扬扬地」写飘飘扬扬地、「在平滩上挥洒」写在平滩上挥洒。一句写秋光如同发亮的汗珠飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒,以秋光如同发亮的汗珠写发亮的汗珠、以飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒写平滩挥洒,写尽秋光如同发亮的汗珠、飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒之情。以光写景,深沉而含蓄,是「以光写景」的点睛之笔。

The autumn light is like shining sweat-drops, drifting and scattering over the flat flats. The comparison is bodily rather than scenic: sunlight becomes the sweat of men working the land, bright and human. The drifting, scattering verbs carry the exhaustion. The poem insists on labor even in captivity. To have said the sunlight glittered on the flats would be a nature line; the shining sweat-drops are the labor.

是的,团泊洼是静静的,但时时都会轰轰爆炸!

Yes, Tuanpo Wa is quiet - but every moment it may thunder and explode!

是的,团泊洼是静静的,但时时都会轰轰爆炸!

Yes, Tuanbo Marsh is silent, but any moment it may thunder and explode!

此句写团泊洼是静静的,是全诗写静中之态的关键。「是的,团泊洼是静静的」写是的,团泊洼是静静的,「是的」写是的、「团泊洼是静静的」写团泊洼是静静的;「但时时都会轰轰爆炸」写但时时都会轰轰爆炸,「但时时都会」写但时时都会、「轰轰爆炸」写轰轰爆炸。一句写是的团泊洼是静静的但时时都会轰轰爆炸,以团泊洼是静静的写静静、以时时都会轰轰爆炸写爆炸,写尽是的团泊洼是静静的、但时时都会轰轰爆炸之情。以静写情,深沉而含蓄,是「以静写情」的点睛之笔。

The reversal is the poem's center. Yes, Tuanbo Marsh is silent—but any moment it may thunder and explode. The concession yes sets up the contradiction: the stillness is not peace but pressure. The explosion, unspoken except as a possibility, is the poet's suppressed rage and hope. The exclamation after the long quiet is the whole tension of the poem. To have said the quiet place was about to erupt would be a statement; the concession followed by the explosion is the eruption.

它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽。……

it may not suit your autumn, but next spring it will take root and sprout. ...

它也许不合你秋天的季节,但到明春准会生根发芽。……

It may not suit your autumn season, but by next spring it will surely take root and sprout. ...

结句写它也许不合你秋天的季节,是全诗立意的落点。「它也许不合你秋天的季节」写它也许不合你秋天的季节,「它也许」写它也许、「不合你秋天的季节」写不合你秋天的季节;「但到明春准会生根发芽」写但到明春准会生根发芽,「但到明春」写但到明春、「准会生根发芽」写准会生根发芽。一句写它也许不合你秋天的季节但到明春准会生根发芽,以它也许不合你秋天的季节写秋天的季节、以但到明春准会生根发芽写生根发芽,写尽它也许不合你秋天的季节、但到明春准会生根发芽之情。以芽写情,深沉而含蓄,是全诗最动人处,也是「以芽写情」的点睛之笔。

The closing addresses a seed. It may not suit your autumn season, but by next spring it will surely take root and sprout. The plant, refused a place in autumn, is the poet himself, exiled in a frozen time; the certainty of next spring is the unbreakable hope. The trailing dots after the sprout leave the future open and continuing. To have said things would get better in spring would be optimism; the seed that will root by next spring is the hope.

Study

Word focus

柔韧 In 'a resilient comb', the compound 柔韧 means supple and unbreakable. It is chosen rather than 坚 (hard) or 软 (soft): the poet wants a comb that will not snap, so that the season pressing on the marsh also survives it, which is the poem's attitude to quietness. 「柔韧」写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,是写柔韧之态的关键。「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子」着一「柔韧」,写柔韧——着一「柔韧」,写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,见其韧之柔。两字写尽柔韧之态,是「以词写韧」的妙笔。「柔韧」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
团泊洼 Tuanpo Wa, the marsh near Tianjin where the poet was sent in the mid-1970s; it is the real place of the poem, and the poet uses its name as a refrain to bring the whole landscape back to one spot whenever the description drifts. 「团泊洼」写梳理着静静的团泊洼,是写团泊洼之态的关键。「梳理着静静的团泊洼」着一「团泊洼」,写团泊洼——着一「团泊洼」,写梳理着静静的团泊洼,见其洼之团泊。三字写尽团泊洼之态,是「以词写洼」的点睛之词。「团泊洼」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
汗珠 In 'autumn light is like a bead of sweat', the noun 汗珠 is a single drop of sweat, and the image makes the light both bright and effortful - the light is work being shed. It is one of the poem's unusually concrete similes, and it keeps the human touch that runs through the whole catalogue. 「汗珠」写秋光如同发亮的汗珠,是写汗珠之态的关键。「秋光如同发亮的汗珠」着一「汗珠」,写汗珠——着一「汗珠」,写秋光如同发亮的汗珠,见其珠之汗。两字写尽汗珠之态,是「以词写珠」的点睛之词。「汗珠」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
生根 In 'next spring it will take root and sprout', the verb-compound 生根 means to grow roots. The poet's poem is buried and then given a future, and the word that begins its revival is the one that belongs to seeds rather than to verses. 「生根」写但到明春准会生根发芽,是写生根之态的关键。「但到明春准会生根发芽」着一「生根」,写生根——着一「生根」,写但到明春准会生根发芽,见其根之生。两字写尽生根之态,是「以词写根」的点睛之词。「生根」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。

Related Reading

水调歌头·明月几时有 Shuidiaogeho · How Long Have the Spring Flowers and Autumn Moon Been Here? 苏轼 · 同写秋景感怀、深沉旷达,一写人有悲欢离合、一写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子梳理着静静的团泊洼,皆于秋景之中见深沉 Both write autumn and detect the passing of the seasons; a philosopher's acceptance against a poet's defiance

Su Shi's long tune turns on the consoling claim that joys and sorrows, moon and parting, have been joined since of old, and asks only that the reader be content with a long night. Guo Xiaochuan's poem turns on the opposite observation - that the seasons arrive while the political weather does not, or arrives too quietly - and answers not with acceptance but with a threat of thunder and a promise of spring. The two share the autumn and the structure of consolation; they differ entirely in what the speaker decides to do with the year.

苏轼《水调歌头·明月几时有》「人有悲欢离合,月有阴晴圆缺,此事古难全」,写秋景感怀、深沉旷达,是宋词长调的名篇;郭小川《团泊洼的秋天》则以「秋天像一把柔韧的梳子,梳理着静静的团泊洼」「是的,团泊洼是静静的,但时时都会轰轰爆炸」写柔韧的梳子、静静的团泊洼。两诗同写秋景感怀、深沉旷达:一写人有悲欢离合、以悲欢写离合,一写秋天像一把柔韧的梳子梳理着静静的团泊洼、以秋景写深沉;一为苏轼之旷达、一为郭小川之深沉,并读正可见诗写「秋景感怀」的两种笔法,皆于秋景之中见深沉。

八声甘州·对潇潇暮雨洒江天 Eight Beats of the Gansu · Against the Drizzling Rain Splashing the Sky 柳永 · 同写秋景凝望、清丽深婉,一写对潇潇暮雨洒江天、一写秋光如同发亮的汗珠飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒,皆于秋景之中见凝望 Autumn held at the water's edge; a traveller's sorrow against a marsh described from inside

Liu Yong's long tune opens with the drizzling rain washing the autumn clear and puts the speaker on the river, leaning over water homeward-bound and thinking of a city of pearls and jade. Guo's poem is also set at water's edge in autumn, but its speaker is not travelling; she or he is already at the place and has no road. Where Liu Yong's秋天 is a landscape that causes grief, Guo's is a landscape that the speaker has to be warned out of - the poem insists twice that beneath the marsh an explosion is possible. The two are the two ways modern Chinese poetry learned from the ci: to describe autumn as loss, and to describe it as a hold.

柳永《八声甘州·对潇潇暮雨洒江天》「对潇潇暮雨洒江天,一番洗清秋」,写秋景凝望、清丽深婉,是宋词写羁旅的名篇;郭小川《团泊洼的秋天》则以「秋光如同发亮的汗珠,飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒」「密集的芦苇,细心地护卫着脚下偷偷开放的野花」写发亮的汗珠、护卫野花。两诗同写秋景凝望、清丽深婉:一写对潇潇暮雨洒江天、以暮雨写清秋,一写秋光如同发亮的汗珠飘飘扬扬地在平滩上挥洒、以秋光写团泊洼;一为柳永之清丽、一为郭小川之深沉,并读正可见诗写「秋景凝望」的两种笔法,皆于秋景之中见凝望。