All poems

南北朝 Northern and Southern Dynasties · 诗 Poem

晚出西射堂

Leaving the West Archery Hall at Dusk

谢灵运

Xie Lingyun

步出西城门,遥望城西岑。
连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉。
晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴。
节往戚不浅,感来念已深。
羁雌恋旧侣,迷鸟怀故林。
含情尚劳爱,如何离赏心。
抚镜华缁鬓,揽带缓促衿。
安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴。

I step out of the west gate of the city,
far off I look toward the western hill-ridge.
Ranges of peaks overlap one another,
green and dim, deep out of sight.
By morning frost the maple leaves are red;
at evening glow the mists are dense.
The season has gone, and the grief does not lift;
feeling comes, and the memory is already deep.
A caged bird longs for its former mates;
a lost bird remembers its old forest.
To hold feeling is still to labour in love;
how can one leave what the heart prize?
I touch the mirror, and my fine hair is dimmed;
I gather my sash, and the collar is loose and slack.
To set one's place in order is only empty talk;
alone in solitude I lean on my zither.
Listen

Meaning

Xie Lingyun walks out of the city gate at dusk and looks toward the hills in the west, where layered ridges rise under a deep green that cannot be measured. Morning frost reddens the maple leaves and evening mists close in. The passing of the season awakens a grief that does not lift, and with it a memory of a home and of companions that cannot be recovered. He looks in a mirror and sees his fine hair grown dim, and finds his sash loosened with waiting; arranging one's affairs is only empty talk, and what is left is the solitude of the zither.

步出西城门,遥望城西岑。连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉。晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴。节往戚不浅,感来念已深。羁雌恋旧侣,迷鸟怀故林。含情尚劳爱,如何离赏心。抚镜华缁鬓,揽带缓促衿。安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴。

Appreciation

[Structure] The poem runs in two halves of eight lines each. The first half is landscape — the gate, the far ridge, the layered peaks, the frost and the mist — and closes at the line where feeling joins the scene. The second half turns to the self: two couplets on attachment, then two on the body's decay, then the conclusion in the zither. [Imagery] The landscape is drawn with unusual density: 连鄣叠巘崿, ranges and peaks piled on ranges, and 青翠杳深沉, a green that is dark and measureless. This density is the signature of the landscape poem of the period, and it is joined here to two small, precise garden images — the maple turning red and the mist at dusk — which give the vastness a scale a reader can stand in. [Turning] 节往戚不浅,感来念已深 is the hinge. Before it, the scene is only a scene; after it, every part of the scene is already charged. This is why the same hills that were described in the first lines are remembered differently by the end of the poem. [Feeling] The last couplet is the poem's admission. 安排徒空言, that arranging one's life is only empty talk, is a rejection of the whole official and philosophical programme of the age; what is left is 幽独, solitude, and 鸣琴, a zither. The poem's sadness is thus not about the hills but about the incompatibility of a life with a temperament.

【白话串讲】 谢灵运写《晚出西射堂》:“步出西城门,遥望城西岑”——“连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉”——“晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴”——“羁雌恋旧侣,迷鸟怀故林”——“抚镜华缁鬓,揽带缓促衿”——他晚出西射堂——羁雌恋旧侣。 【意象与手法】 “连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉”以叠嶂青翠写暮景;“晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴”以枫丹岚阴写节候;“羁雌恋旧侣,迷鸟怀故林”以羁雌迷鸟写思归;结以“安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴”写以琴遣怀。写景精细、借物抒怀。 【情感与主旨】 谢灵运谪守永嘉傍晚出城所作,写城外暮景与羁宦思归之情,借羁雌迷鸟自况,是山水诗鼻祖将山水与羁旅之情结合的典型。 【名句点睛】 常考“晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴”以枫丹岚阴写节候;“羁雌恋旧侣,迷鸟怀故林”以羁雌迷鸟写思归。

Background

This poem was written by Xie Lingyun (385–433), of Yangxia in Chen commandery, that is Tai kang in Henan, a poet of the Liu Song in the southern dynasties and the founder of the school of landscape poetry. Most of his writing comes from his years away from the capital, first on the coast and later on a mountain estate, and it was in the writing of that landscape that he developed the dense, careful manner seen here. He was a man of his age in other ways as well: a member of a great family who held office only intermittently, always awaiting a post that suited him, and given to a religious quest that led him to the Daoist masters of his time. This poem, of walking out at dusk and finding nothing arranged, is from the same period as his other landscape poems written on the road. It has been widely reprinted since the earliest anthologies, and its worth and popularity show its position among works of the same kind.

《晚出西射堂》为南朝宋诗人谢灵运所作诗。谢灵运(385—433),陈郡阳夏(今河南太康)人,南朝宋诗人,山水诗派的开创者。此诗写景感怀,为晚出西射堂之作。诗中「步出西城门,遥望城西岑」写步出西城门,遥望城西岑;「连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉」写连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉;「晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴」写晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴;「节往戚不浅,感来念已深」写节往戚不浅,感来念已深;「幽独赖鸣琴」写幽独赖鸣琴。谢灵运此诗以写景感怀、幽独赖鸣琴写其感怀之情,清丽幽远,是谢灵运诗中的名篇。此篇《晚出西射堂》在历代选本中多被收录,其艺术价值与流传之广,正可见此诗在同类题材中的重要地位。诗人以匠心独运之笔写寻常之情事,遂使此作历千载而犹有生气,为后人所称赏不绝。此篇《晚出西射堂》在历代选本中多被收录,其艺术价值与流传之广,正可见此诗在同类题材中的重要地位。诗人以匠心独运之笔写寻常之情事,遂使此作历千载而犹有生气,为后人所称赏不绝。

Art

The poem is valued for its clear and distant beauty, and for the way feeling is given through scenery. It is built on sixteen lines, and the movement is from the gate to the distant ridge, to the piled peaks, to the frost and the glow, and then to the speaker. The images of the first half are large and close-packed, and the images of the second half are small and exact — a bird, a mirror, a sash — so that the scale shifts exactly when the feeling does. The couplet 节往戚不浅,感来念已深 is the technical centre of the poem: it is written in the plainest possible language and yet it changes the meaning of everything that precedes it, because from that moment the hills are being looked at by someone who has already been moved. The lines that follow make this explicit by naming the two familiar instincts — the caged bird's love of its old companions, the lost bird's memory of its old forest — which are the poem's way of saying that the speaker is simply an animal missing its place. The closing couplet is the poem's real subject. 安排徒空言 — that placing one's affairs in order is only empty talk — is a rejection, in four characters, of the whole programme of settling one's affairs; 幽独赖鸣琴 offers nothing in its place but a zither and solitude. The rhyme on the 侵 sound, a close and enclosed vowel, sounded in 岑, 深, 阴, 林, 心, 衿 and 琴, suits this shutting-in beautifully; the poem ends on a narrow, darkened sound space.

此诗艺术上以「清丽幽远、以景写情」见长。全诗共十六句,由步出西城门而连鄣叠巘崿而晓霜枫叶丹。起「步出西城门,遥望城西岑」写步出西城门:步出西城门,遥望城西岑;「连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉」写连鄣叠巘崿:连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉;「晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴」写晓霜枫叶丹:晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴;「节往戚不浅,感来念已深」写节往戚不浅:节往戚不浅,感来念已深;结「安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴」写幽独赖鸣琴:安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴。全诗以景写情,由步出西城门而幽独赖鸣琴,清丽幽远,是谢灵运诗中的名篇。通篇以少总多之法出之,章法严谨而用意深曲,意象凝练而情韵悠长,读之愈久,愈觉其构思之精与笔力之健,堪称同类诗作中不可多得之佳篇,足见诗人炉火纯青的艺术功力。通篇以少总多之法出之,章法严谨而用意深曲,意象凝练而情韵悠长,读之愈久,愈觉其构思之精与笔力之健,堪称同类诗作中不可多得之佳篇,足见诗人炉火纯青的艺术功力。

Allusions

Several lines carry allusions. 羁雌恋旧侣, the caged bird longing for its old companions, and 迷鸟怀故林, the confused bird remembering its old forest, are two aspects of the same nostalgia, and their plainness is what makes them effective. 抚镜华缁鬓, touching the mirror where the hair has gone dim, is the gesture of a man measuring himself. 揽带缓促衿, gathering the sash so that the collar hangs loose, describes the same thing from the other side, in the clothing. 安排徒空言, that placing one's affairs in order is only empty talk, is the acknowledgment that the philosophical programme of the age cannot answer what is happening. 幽独赖鸣琴 leans on the old figure of the zither as the companion of a solitary man, the instrument of the recluse. The whole poem thus rests on two inherited ideas — that scenery can carry feeling, and that the unattached man keeps his music — used with no visible effort.

诗中「步出西城门遥望城西岑」「连鄣叠巘崿青翠杳深沉」「晓霜枫叶丹夕曛岚气阴」「节往戚不浅感来念已深」「羁雌恋旧侣迷鸟怀故林」「含情尚劳爱如何离赏心」「抚镜华缁鬓揽带缓促衿」「安排徒空言幽独赖鸣琴」等语,皆含典故故实。「步出西城门遥望城西岑」写步出西城门遥望城西岑;「连鄣叠巘崿青翠杳深沉」写连鄣叠巘崿青翠杳深沉;「晓霜枫叶丹夕曛岚气阴」写晓霜枫叶丹夕曛岚气阴;「节往戚不浅感来念已深」写节往戚不浅感来念已深;「羁雌恋旧侣迷鸟怀故林」写羁雌恋旧侣迷鸟怀故林;「含情尚劳爱如何离赏心」写含情尚劳爱如何离赏心;「抚镜华缁鬓揽带缓促衿」写抚镜华缁鬓揽带缓促衿;「安排徒空言幽独赖鸣琴」用鸣琴之典(鸣琴写伯牙鼓琴),写安排徒空言幽独赖鸣琴。诗人以鸣琴等典入诗,不着痕迹,而把写景感怀之情写得真切可感,是善于熔铸典故的体现。

Commentary

This poem of Xie Lingyun's is a work of writing on an occasion, and it selects the landscape and the feeling of farewell; it has been among the most reprinted of his poems since the earliest anthologies. Later readers have valued it for its clear and distant manner, and the couplet on morning frost reddening the maple leaves and evening glow making the mists dense is often named as the poem's best. Its worth may be taken in three directions. In theme, it joins the poetry of going out and looking, in which the landscape is not a background but an argument with the self. In language, the dense piling of peaks and the close rhyme on the 侵 sound are the manner of the landscape poetry of the southern dynasties, and the care of the wording is what gives the poem its depth. In feeling, the poem's honesty about not having arranged its life is what makes it modern; it is a poem of a man who finds that the consolations he was taught do not apply. For a reader today it remains one of the best doors onto the landscape poetry of the Liu Song.

这首《晚出西射堂》,是谢灵运写写景感怀之作,写步出西城门、连鄣叠巘崿、晓霜枫叶丹、节往戚不浅、幽独赖鸣琴之情,清丽幽远。起「步出西城门,遥望城西岑」——步出西城门,遥望城西岑。写步出西城门:步出西城门、遥望城西岑——出西城门、望城西岑;「连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉」——连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉。写连鄣叠巘崿:连鄣叠巘崿、青翠杳深沉——叠巘崿、杳深沉;「晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴」——晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴。写晓霜枫叶丹:晓霜枫叶丹、夕曛岚气阴——枫叶丹、岚气阴;「节往戚不浅,感来念已深」——节往戚不浅,感来念已深。写节往戚不浅:节往戚不浅、感来念已深——戚不浅、念已深;结「安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴」——安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴(用鸣琴之典)。写幽独赖鸣琴:安排徒空言、幽独赖鸣琴——徒空言、赖鸣琴。这「安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴」,是全诗之结:以幽独赖鸣琴写其感怀。全诗清丽幽远,以景写情,正是谢灵运诗中的名篇。

Prosody

Form Poem · five-character old verse (五言古诗)诗(五言古诗)
Rhyme A five-character old verse in sixteen lines. It rhymes 岑, 深, 阴, 深, 林, 心, 衿 and 琴 in the 侵 group.此诗为五言古诗,共十六句。押韵:「岑」「深」「阴」「深」「林」「心」「衿」「琴」押侵部韵。诗体依古诗而定,句式整齐,音节随情起伏,正与写写景感怀的清丽幽远相称,也见其以古诗写感怀的自然。
Tone pattern In sound, the opening line has a slow and unhurried cadence, the line on piled peaks a distant one, the line on frost and mist a clear and pretty one, the couplet on the season a lowered one, and the closing couplet a long and lingering one. The sound rises and falls with the feeling, from slow to distant, from clear to lowered, and at last to a long close, which is the manner of the old verse and suits the poem's plainness.句式上,「步出西城门,遥望城西岑」写步出西城门,音节舒缓;「连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉」写连鄣叠巘崿,音节幽远;「晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴」写晓霜枫叶丹,音节清丽;「节往戚不浅,感来念已深」写节往戚不浅,音节低回;结「安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴」写幽独赖鸣琴,音节悠长。全诗音节随情起伏,由舒缓而幽远、由清丽而低回、由低回而悠长,正合古诗「自然」之妙,读来如写景感怀、幽独赖鸣琴之音,清丽而动人。
Reading note This is a five-character old verse in sixteen lines, a poem of writing on an occasion, and a poem in the manner of the landscape poetry of the Liu Song. Its manner is clear and distant, and feeling is expressed through scenery. The most accomplished detail is the line on morning frost and evening mist; the lines on the caged bird and the lost bird give the poem its plain core; and the closing couplet on the zither is the poem's answer, plain and unhurried, in the manner of the old verse and one of the most frequently reprinted of the collection. The reason this poem sounds so full is that the poet matched the sound to the feeling and the rhythm to the scene; the length of the lines and the rise and fall of the tones agree with the sense, so that reading it is like listening to the scene itself. In this one may also see the beauty of the sound-system of classical Chinese poetry and the labour of its craft.此诗为五言古诗,是谢灵运写写景感怀之作,也是其诗中的名篇。全诗的艺术特色在于「清丽幽远、以景写情」:「步出西城门,遥望城西岑」写步出西城门、「连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉」写连鄣叠巘崿、「晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴」写晓霜枫叶丹、「节往戚不浅,感来念已深」写节往戚不浅、「安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴」写幽独赖鸣琴。全诗清丽幽远,以景写情。尤为精妙者,是「晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴」写尽枫丹之景;而「安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴」用鸣琴之典,正是谢灵运诗「清丽幽远」的典范,为历代选本所常收。《晚出西射堂》一诗之所以读来声情并茂,正在于诗人以声韵配合情思、以节奏烘托意境,音节之长短、平仄之起伏,皆与诗意相为表里,此亦可见中国古典诗歌声律之美与匠心之工。

Line by line

步出西城门,遥望城西岑。

I step out of the west gate of the city, far off I look toward the western hill-ridge.

步出西城门,遥望城西岑。

I step out the west city gate and gaze at the western hills.

首二句写步出西城门,起笔即见其行。「步出西城门」写步出西城门,「步出」写步出、「西城门」写西城门;「遥望城西岑」写遥望城西岑,「遥望」写遥望、「城西岑」写城西岑。两句一写步出西城门、一写遥望城西岑,以步出西城门写出西城门、以遥望城西岑写望城西岑,写尽步出西城门、遥望城西岑之情。以行起兴,清丽而幽远,是「以行起兴」的妙笔。

The gate. I step out the west city gate and gaze at the western hills. The stepped-out-west-gate and the gazed-western-hills are the opening. To have stepped out the gate would be a stepping-out; the i-step-out-the-west-city-gate-and-gaze-at-the-western-hills is the stepping-out.

连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉。

Ranges of peaks overlap one another; green and dim, deep out of sight.

连鄣叠巘崿,青翠杳深沉。

Range on range of piled crags, green and deep in the distance.

此二句写连鄣叠巘崿,是全诗写青山之态的关键。「连鄣叠巘崿」写连鄣叠巘崿,「连鄣」写连鄣、「叠巘崿」写叠巘崿;「青翠杳深沉」写青翠杳深沉,「青翠」写青翠、「杳深沉」写杳深沉。两句一写连鄣叠巘崿、一写青翠杳深沉,以连鄣叠巘崿写叠巘崿、以青翠杳深沉写杳深沉,写尽连鄣叠巘崿、青翠杳深沉之情。以山写景,清丽而幽远,是「以山写景」的点睛之笔。

The crags. Range on range of piled crags, green and deep in the distance. The piled crags and the deep green distance are the scene. To have piled would be a piling; the range-on-range-of-piled-crags-green-and-deep-in-the-distance is the piling.

晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴。

By morning frost the maple leaves are red; at evening glow the mists are dense.

晓霜枫叶丹,夕曛岚气阴。

Morning frost reddens the maple leaves; evening haze darkens the mountain mist.

此二句写晓霜枫叶丹,是全诗写枫叶之态的关键。「晓霜枫叶丹」写晓霜枫叶丹,「晓霜」写晓霜、「枫叶丹」写枫叶丹;「夕曛岚气阴」写夕曛岚气阴,「夕曛」写夕曛、「岚气阴」写岚气阴。两句一写晓霜枫叶丹、一写夕曛岚气阴,以晓霜枫叶丹写枫叶丹、以夕曛岚气阴写岚气阴,写尽晓霜枫叶丹、夕曛岚气阴之情。以霜写景,清丽而幽远,是「以霜写景」的点睛之笔。

The maple. Morning frost reddens the maple leaves; evening haze darkens the mountain mist. The morning-frost-reddened-maple and the evening-haze-darkened-mist are the couplet. To have reddened the maple would be a reddening; the morning-frost-reddens-the-maple-leaves-evening-haze-darkens-the-mountain-mist is the reddening.

安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴。

To set one's place in order is only empty talk; alone in solitude I lean on my zither.

安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴。

Such schemes are empty words; in my solitude I trust the sounding lute.

结句写幽独赖鸣琴,是全诗立意的落点。「安排徒空言」写安排徒空言,「安排」写安排、「徒空言」写徒空言;「幽独赖鸣琴」用鸣琴之典写幽独赖鸣琴,「幽独」写幽独、「赖鸣琴」写赖鸣琴。两句一写安排徒空言、一写幽独赖鸣琴,以安排徒空言写徒空言、以幽独赖鸣琴写赖鸣琴,写尽安排徒空言、幽独赖鸣琴之情。以琴写情,清丽而幽远,是全诗最动人处,也是「以琴写情」的点睛之笔。

The lute. Such schemes are empty words; in my solitude I trust the sounding lute. The empty-words schemes and the solitude-trusting-the-sounding-lute are the close. To have trusted the lute would be a trusting; the such-schemes-are-empty-words-in-my-solitude-i-trust-the-sounding-lute is the trusting.

Study

Word focus

西城门 The west gate of the city: it is the point from which the poem begins, and stepping through it is what makes the landscape beyond the wall visible, so the gate is the door of the whole poem. 「西城门」写步出西城门,是写西城之态的关键。「步出西城门」着一「西城门」,写西城门——着一「西城门」,写步出西城门,见其门之西。三字写尽西城门之态,是「以词写门」的妙笔。「西城门」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
青翠 Dark and lively green: in 青翠杳深沉 it describes a colour that is both vivid and bottomless, and it is this ambiguity that lets the hills be at once close and unmeasurable. 「青翠」写青翠杳深沉,是写青翠之态的关键。「青翠杳深沉」着一「青翠」,写青翠——着一「青翠」,写青翠杳深沉,见其山之青翠。两字写尽青翠之态,是「以词写翠」的点睛之词。「青翠」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
枫叶丹 The maple leaves turned red: 丹, vermilion, is the colour of the autumn leaf, so this phrase is the poem's one bright autumn image, set against the dim green and the dusk mist. 「枫叶丹」写晓霜枫叶丹,是写枫叶之态的关键。「晓霜枫叶丹」着一「枫叶丹」,写枫叶丹——着一「枫叶丹」,写晓霜枫叶丹,见其叶之丹。三字写尽枫叶丹之态,是「以词写叶」的点睛之词。「枫叶丹」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
幽独 Solitude and quiet alienation: it is the condition the poem arrives at, and the closing line admits that it can only be kept company by a zither. 「幽独」写幽独赖鸣琴,是写幽独之态的关键。「幽独赖鸣琴」着一「幽独」,写幽独——着一「幽独」,写幽独赖鸣琴,见其人之幽独。两字写尽幽独之态,是「以词写独」的点睛之词。「幽独」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。

Related Reading

八声甘州·对潇潇暮雨洒江天 Ba Sheng Gan Zhou · Over the plain and drizzling evening rain on the sky and river (八声甘州·对潇潇暮雨洒江天) 柳永 · 同写登高感怀、凝望天涯,一写对潇潇暮雨洒江天、一写步出西城门遥望城西岑,皆于登高之中见感怀 Both write of登高 and of looking toward the far edge of the world; one writes of the drizzle washing the autumn over the river, the other of stepping out of the west gate and looking toward the western ridge.

Liu Yong's《Ba Sheng Gan Zhou》opens "Over the plain and drizzling evening rain on the sky and river, one washing gives a clear autumn," and goes on to the long look toward the edge of the sky. Xie Lingyun's poem opens by stepping out of the city gate and looking toward the ridge in the west, and then turns from the landscape to his own sickness of heart. Both are poems of looking that turn into poems about being moved; where Liu Yong's look is horizontal, through weather and river, Xie's is vertical, from the gate to the far ridge and then down into the mirror. Read together, the two show the two hands of Chinese poetry on the same subject.

柳永《八声甘州·对潇潇暮雨洒江天》「对潇潇暮雨洒江天,一番洗清秋」,写登高感怀、凝望天涯,是宋词写羁旅的名篇;谢灵运《晚出西射堂》则以「步出西城门,遥望城西岑」「节往戚不浅,感来念已深」写遥望城西岑、节往戚不浅。两诗同写登高感怀、凝望天涯:一写对潇潇暮雨洒江天、以暮雨写清秋,一写步出西城门遥望城西岑、以望岑写感怀;一为柳永之清丽、一为谢灵运之幽远,并读正可见诗写「登高感怀」的两种笔法,皆于登高之中见感怀。

水调歌头·明月几时有 Shui Diao Ge Tou · When was the moon full (水调歌头·明月几时有) 苏轼 · 同写感怀旷达、超然物外,一写我欲乘风归去、一写安排徒空言幽独赖鸣琴,皆于感怀之中见旷达 Both write of feeling that rises above the world; one writes of riding the wind home, the other of empty talk about arranging one's affairs and solitude kept by a zither.

Su Shi's《Shui Diao Ge Tou》opens "When was the moon full? I ask the heaven of wine in my hand," and goes on "I wish to ride the wind and go home, but I fear the jade pavilion and the palace of pearl, too high, too cold." Xie Lingyun's poem, at the other end of the tradition, has no flight at all; he touches the mirror, gathers his sash, and ends on the admission that arranging one's affairs is only empty talk. Where Su Shi rises and then comes down to a human good, Xie never rises in the first place. Read together, the two show how far the Chinese poem could travel from landscape to resolution in the six centuries between them.

苏轼《水调歌头·明月几时有》「我欲乘风归去,又恐琼楼玉宇,高处不胜寒」,写感怀旷达、超然物外,是宋词长调的名篇;谢灵运《晚出西射堂》则以「安排徒空言,幽独赖鸣琴」「含情尚劳爱,如何离赏心」写幽独赖鸣琴、如何离赏心。两诗同写感怀旷达、超然物外:一写我欲乘风归去、以乘风写超然,一写安排徒空言幽独赖鸣琴、以鸣琴写旷达;一为苏轼之超然、一为谢灵运之幽远,并读正可见诗写「感怀旷达」的两种笔法,皆于感怀之中见旷达。