宋 Song · 词 Ci lyric
宝鼎现
The Precious Cauldron Appears (To the Tune of Baoding Xian)
红妆春骑。
踏月影、竿旗穿市。
望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底。
箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉。
甚辇路、喧阗且止。
听得念奴歌起。
父老犹记宣和事。
抱铜仙、清泪如水。
还转盼、沙河多丽。
滉漾明光连邸第。
帘影冻、散红光成绮。
月浸葡萄十里。
看往来、神仙才子。
肯把菱花扑碎。
肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指。
等多时春不归来,到春时欲睡。
又说向、灯前拥髻。
暗滴鲛珠坠。
便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里。
They tread the moonlight, banners and poles threading the marketplace.
Endless towers and pavilions of song and dance;
Fragrant dust stirs beneath lotus-light footsteps.
The flute's song breaks; she promises to return with the colorful phoenix,
Not fearing the gold-watch guard's rebuke of the drunken.
On the imperial carriage road the clamor falls still —
I hear the song of Nian begin.
The old folk still recall the days of Xuanhe,
Embracing the bronze immortal, their clear tears falling like water.
Glancing back, how lovely the Sha River,
Its glistening radiance spreading across the mansions.
Curtain shadows freeze; scattered red light weaves like brocade;
The moon steeps the grape-dark water for ten li.
Watch the passing to and fro of immortal talents and gifted scholars —
Who would shatter the bronze mirror?
Heartbroken, the children with bamboo horses
Vainly hear tell of three thousand musicians' fingers.
I have waited long; spring does not return,
And when spring comes I only want to sleep.
Again she tells it, her hair pinned up before the lamp,
Secretly dropping pearls of the flood-dragon.
Even that day when I saw the Rainbow Skirt dance with my own eyes —
Heaven above, the world below, and only in dreams.
Meaning
Beginning as a dazzling lantern-festival pageant — rouge-cheeked riders, banners, song and dance, moonlight on ten li of river — the lyric turns into an elegy when 'the old folk still recall the days of Xuanhe' and weep like the bronze immortal of Han. Liu Chenweng, a loyalist of the fallen Song, uses the festival's splendor to mourn the lost Northern Song: its music survives now only in memory and dreams.
红妆春骑。踏月影、竿旗穿市。望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底。箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉。甚辇路、喧阗且止。听得念奴歌起。父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水。还转盼、沙河多丽。滉漾明光连邸第。帘影冻、散红光成绮。月浸葡萄十里。看往来、神仙才子。肯把菱花扑碎。肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指。等多时春不归来,到春时欲睡。又说向、灯前拥髻。暗滴鲛珠坠。便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里。
Appreciation
[Plain Paraphrase] The lyric opens in full festival splendor: rouge-cheeked riders, banners threading the market, endless pavilions of song and dance, flutes, promises of return, and the famous singer Nian's song rising over the stilled imperial road. Then, abruptly, 'the old folk still recall the days of Xuanhe' — the Xuanhe era of the lost Northern Song — and the tears fall like those of the bronze immortal carried from Han. The second half turns to moonlight on ten li of river, gifted youths who would not shatter the mirror, children who only hear tell of three thousand musicians, and a woman by the lamp dropping tears like flood-dragon pearls. It ends: even the Rainbow Skirt dance the poet saw with his own eyes is now heaven, earth, and dream. [Structure] The poem is built on a double vision: within the same lantern night, the present festival and the remembered Xuanhe festival coexist. The turning point is the single line 'the old folk still recall the days of Xuanhe,' after which every image doubles — the same moon lights a living festival and a dead dynasty. [Allusion and Tone] Liu Chenweng, writing after the Song fell, loads the poem with dynastic echoes: the bronze immortal's tears, the broken mirror, the Rainbow Skirt. The tone is subtle and deep: no direct cry of grief, yet the whole pageant becomes a funeral rite for a lost world.
【白话串讲】 刘辰翁写《宝鼎现》:“红妆春骑。踏月影、竿旗穿市”——“望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底”——“父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水”——他写元夕与故国之思。 【意象与手法】 “红妆春骑。踏月影、竿旗穿市”以春骑红妆写元夕之盛;“望不尽、楼台歌舞”写歌舞升平;“父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水”以铜仙铅泪写故国之思;结以“便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里”以天上人间写盛衰。三叠铺叙、今昔对照。 【情感与主旨】 刘辰翁写元夕怀旧之作,追忆北宋汴京元夕之盛而叹南宋已衰,寄托故国之思,是宋末遗民词中以节序写亡国之痛的代表。 【名句点睛】 常考“父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水”以铜仙铅泪写故国之思;“便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里”以天上人间写盛衰之变。
Background
Liu Chenweng (1232–1297), styled Huimeng and known by his sobriquet Xuxi, was a native of Luling (modern Ji'an, Jiangxi) and a loyalist of the fallen Southern Song. After the Yuan conquest he lived in retirement, and his lyrics are steeped in sorrow for the lost dynasty. This lantern-festival lyric is his most famous: he writes the lanterns of the conquered south through the remembered Xuanhe-era (1119–1125) lanterns of the old capital Bianjing, so that a single night of festival lights becomes a requiem for a dynasty. It is regarded as the supreme example of using a seasonal festival to voice the grief of a fallen state.
《宝鼎现》为宋末元初词人刘辰翁所作词。刘辰翁(1232—1297),字会孟,号须溪,庐陵(今江西吉安)人,宋末词人,词多故国之思。此词写元夕怀旧,为元夕词。词中「红妆春骑。踏月影、竿旗穿市」写红妆春骑;「望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底」写楼台歌舞;「箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉」写约彩鸾;「甚辇路、喧阗且止。听得念奴歌起」写念奴歌起;「父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水」写父老犹记宣和事;「还转盼、沙河多丽。滉漾明光连邸第」写沙河多丽;「帘影冻、散红光成绮。月浸葡萄十里」写月浸葡萄十里;「看往来、神仙才子。肯把菱花扑碎」写神仙才子;「肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指」写三千乐指;「等多时春不归来,到春时欲睡。又说向、灯前拥髻」写灯前拥髻;「暗滴鲛珠坠。便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里」写天上人间梦里。刘辰翁此词以元夕怀旧、天上人间梦里写其故国之思,含蓄深婉,是刘辰翁词中的名篇。
Art
The lyric's power comes from its structure of superimposition: the splendor of the lantern night and the memory of Xuanhe are folded into one another line by line. The opening burst — rouge-cheeked riders, banners threading the marketplace, song and dance without end — is deliberately intoxicating, so that the single turn, 'the old folk still recall the days of Xuanhe,' detonates the whole upper stanza into elegy. Liu Chenweng's technique is to let spectacle itself carry mourning: the brighter the lanterns, the blacker the loss. The diction moves from movement and noise (treading moonlight, the clamor falling still) to frozen stillness (curtain shadows freeze, the moon steeping ten li), and finally to the triple collapse of 'heaven, earth, and dream.'
此词艺术上以「含蓄深婉、以典写情」见长。全词上片写红妆春骑与父老犹记宣和事,下片写月浸葡萄十里与天上人间梦里。上片「红妆春骑。踏月影、竿旗穿市」写红妆春骑:红妆春骑,踏月影、竿旗穿市;「望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底」写楼台歌舞:望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底;「箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉」写约彩鸾:箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉;「甚辇路、喧阗且止。听得念奴歌起」写念奴歌起:甚辇路、喧阗且止,听得念奴歌起;「父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水」写父老犹记宣和事:父老犹记宣和事,抱铜仙、清泪如水;「还转盼、沙河多丽。滉漾明光连邸第」写沙河多丽:还转盼、沙河多丽,滉漾明光连邸第。下片「帘影冻、散红光成绮。月浸葡萄十里」写月浸葡萄十里:帘影冻、散红光成绮,月浸葡萄十里;「看往来、神仙才子。肯把菱花扑碎」写神仙才子:看往来、神仙才子,肯把菱花扑碎;「肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指」写三千乐指:肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指;「等多时春不归来,到春时欲睡。又说向、灯前拥髻」写灯前拥髻:等多时春不归来,到春时欲睡,又说向、灯前拥髻;「暗滴鲛珠坠。便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里」写天上人间梦里:暗滴鲛珠坠,便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里。全词含蓄深婉,以典写情,是刘辰翁词中的名篇。
Allusions
'Nian' was the celebrated singing girl of Emperor Xuanzong's court, evoked through the famous line about her sullen, resentful singing. 'Xuanhe' was the last reign era of the Northern Song under Huizong, remembered as the capital's golden age. 'Embracing the bronze immortal' echoes Li He's lament that the golden bronze immortal wept as it was carried away from Han — by analogy, the fall of Bianjing. 'Shattering the bronze mirror' recalls Xu Deyan and Princess Lechang, who broke a mirror in halves at parting, each keeping one half. 'Three thousand musicians' fingers' recalls the imperial music bureau of the fallen capital. 'Hair pinned up before the lamp' borrows the story of Ling Xuan and his consort talking by lamplight from the Feiyan Waizhuan. 'Flood-dragon pearls' are the tears of the jiao dragon, i.e. human tears. 'Rainbow Skirt' is the famous Rainbow and Feathered Robe dance of Xuanzong's court, a byword for lost splendor.
词中「红妆春骑」「踏月影竿旗穿市」「望不尽楼台歌舞习习香尘莲步底」「箫声断约彩鸾归去未怕金吾呵醉」「甚辇路喧阗且止听得念奴歌起」「父老犹记宣和事抱铜仙清泪如水」「还转盼沙河多丽滉漾明光连邸第」「帘影冻散红光成绮月浸葡萄十里」「看往来神仙才子肯把菱花扑碎」「肠断竹马儿童空见说三千乐指」「等多时春不归来到春时欲睡又说向灯前拥髻」「暗滴鲛珠坠便当日亲见霓裳天上人间梦里」等语,皆含典故故实。「红妆春骑」写红妆春骑;「踏月影竿旗穿市」写踏月影竿旗穿市;「望不尽楼台歌舞习习香尘莲步底」写望不尽楼台歌舞习习香尘莲步底(莲步写女子足迹);「箫声断约彩鸾归去未怕金吾呵醉」写箫声断约彩鸾归去未怕金吾呵醉(金吾为京城禁卫,写元夕不禁夜);「甚辇路喧阗且止听得念奴歌起」写甚辇路喧阗且止听得念奴歌起(念奴为唐玄宗时歌者);「父老犹记宣和事抱铜仙清泪如水」用铜仙铅泪之典(金铜仙人辞汉清泪如水),写父老犹记宣和事抱铜仙清泪如水;「还转盼沙河多丽滉漾明光连邸第」写还转盼沙河多丽滉漾明光连邸第;「帘影冻散红光成绮月浸葡萄十里」写帘影冻散红光成绮月浸葡萄十里;「看往来神仙才子肯把菱花扑碎」写看往来神仙才子肯把菱花扑碎(菱花为镜);「肠断竹马儿童空见说三千乐指」写肠断竹马儿童空见说三千乐指(三千乐指写乐工之众);「等多时春不归来到春时欲睡又说向灯前拥髻」写等多时春不归来到春时欲睡又说向灯前拥髻(拥髻写灯前拥髻而谈,用《飞燕外传》伶玄买妾拥髻之典);「暗滴鲛珠坠便当日亲见霓裳天上人间梦里」写暗滴鲛珠坠便当日亲见霓裳天上人间梦里(鲛珠为泪、霓裳为霓裳羽衣曲)。词人以金吾不禁夜、铜仙铅泪、念奴、霓裳、灯前拥髻等典入词,不着痕迹,而把元夕怀旧之情写得真切可感,是善于熔铸典故的体现。
Commentary
This lyric has been read since the Yuan as the most concentrated expression of Song loyalist grief. Liu Chenweng's contemporaries and later critics praised the way a festival night is made to carry dynastic lament without a single direct outcry. It is frequently set beside Li Yu's 'Yu Meiren' as one of the two great 'heaven-and-earth' elegies of Chinese lyric poetry. Modern criticism values its double-vision technique and its restraint: grief is never announced but accumulated through allusion and image, so that the final 'heaven, earth, and dream' lands as the whole dynasty's epitaph.
这首《宝鼎现》,是刘辰翁写元夕怀旧之作,写红妆春骑、父老犹记宣和事、天上人间梦里之情,含蓄深婉。上片写红妆春骑与父老犹记宣和事:「红妆春骑。踏月影、竿旗穿市」——红妆春骑,踏月影、竿旗穿市。写红妆春骑:红妆春骑、踏月影竿旗穿市——红妆春骑、踏月穿市;「望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底」——望不尽、楼台歌舞,习习香尘莲步底。写楼台歌舞:望不尽楼台歌舞、习习香尘莲步底——楼台歌舞、香尘莲步底;「箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉」——箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉(写元夕不禁夜)。写约彩鸾:箫声断约彩鸾归去、未怕金吾呵醉——约彩鸾归去、不惧金吾呵醉;「甚辇路、喧阗且止。听得念奴歌起」——甚辇路、喧阗且止,听得念奴歌起(用念奴之典)。写念奴歌起:甚辇路喧阗且止、听得念奴歌起——辇路喧阗且止、念奴歌起;「父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水」——父老犹记宣和事,抱铜仙(用铜仙铅泪之典)、清泪如水。写父老犹记宣和事:父老犹记宣和事、抱铜仙清泪如水——父老犹记宣和事、铜仙清泪如水;「还转盼、沙河多丽。滉漾明光连邸第」——还转盼、沙河多丽,滉漾明光连邸第。写沙河多丽:还转盼沙河多丽、滉漾明光连邸第——沙河多丽、明光连邸第。下片写月浸葡萄十里与天上人间梦里:「帘影冻、散红光成绮。月浸葡萄十里」——帘影冻、散红光成绮,月浸葡萄十里。写月浸葡萄十里:帘影冻散红光成绮、月浸葡萄十里——红光成绮、月浸葡萄十里;「看往来、神仙才子。肯把菱花扑碎」——看往来、神仙才子,肯把菱花扑碎。写神仙才子:看往来神仙才子、肯把菱花扑碎——神仙才子、肯把菱花扑碎;「肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指」——肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指。写三千乐指:肠断竹马儿童、空见说三千乐指——竹马儿童、空见说三千乐指;「等多时春不归来,到春时欲睡。又说向、灯前拥髻」——等多时春不归来,到春时欲睡,又说向、灯前拥髻(用灯前拥髻之典)。写灯前拥髻:等多时春不归来、到春时欲睡,又说向灯前拥髻——春不归来、灯前拥髻;「暗滴鲛珠坠。便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里」——暗滴鲛珠坠,便当日、亲见霓裳(写霓裳羽衣曲),天上人间梦里。写天上人间梦里:暗滴鲛珠坠、便当日亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里——鲛珠暗滴、亲见霓裳、天上人间梦里。这「暗滴鲛珠坠。便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里」,是全词之结:以天上人间梦里写其故国之思。全词含蓄深婉,以典写情,正是刘辰翁词中的名篇。
Prosody
Line by line
红妆春骑。
Rouge-cheeked riders gallop in the spring.
红妆春骑。
Red cheeks, spring riders.
首句写红妆春骑,起笔即见其节。「红妆春骑」写红妆春骑,「红妆」写红妆之女、「春骑」写春游之骑。一句以「红妆」写女子、「春骑」写游骑,写尽红妆春骑之情——红妆与春骑满街。以节起兴,含蓄而明快,是「以节起兴」的妙笔。此句以寥寥数语写尽深意,情韵兼胜,正是全诗点睛之笔。其于字句之间暗藏波澜,于平易之中寄寓曲折,尤当反复涵泳,方能得其三昧。
The opening line writes the red cheeks and spring riders, the season at the first stroke. Red cheeks writes the women in red; spring riders the spring riders out riding. One line, red cheeks for the women, spring riders for the riders, exhausting the sight of the red cheeks and spring riders filling the streets. Beginning in the season, restrained and bright, the fine brush. The line writes the depth in scant words, the feeling and the flavor both fine, the pointed stroke of the whole. Its hidden undercurrents between the words, its turns within the plain, call for repeated brooding to grasp its truth.
箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉。
The flute's song breaks; she promises to return with the colorful phoenix, not fearing the gold-watch guard's rebuke of the drunken.
箫声断、约彩鸾归去,未怕金吾呵醉。
The flute's sound dies; I trysted with the colored luan to return, fearing not the guards' chiding of the drunk.
此二句写约彩鸾,是全词写元夕之乐的关键。「箫声断、约彩鸾归去」写箫声断约彩鸾归去,「箫声断」写箫声断、「约彩鸾归去」写约彩鸾归去;「未怕金吾呵醉」写未怕金吾呵醉,「未怕」写不怕、「金吾呵醉」写金吾呵斥醉者。两句一写箫声断约彩鸾归去、一写未怕金吾呵醉,以约彩鸾写约归、以未怕金吾呵醉写元夕不禁夜,写尽箫声断约彩鸾归去、未怕金吾呵醉之情。以典写节,含蓄而明快,是「以典写节」的点睛之笔。
The two lines write the tryst with the colored luan, the key of the ci's writing of the Lantern Festival joy. The flute's sound dies; I trysted with the colored luan to return writes the flute's ending and the trysted return; fearing not the guards' chiding of the drunk writes the no fear and the guards' chiding. Two lines, one the flute's dying and the trysted return, one the no fear of the guards' chiding, the tryst for the going-home, the no fear of the guards for the festival's curfew-free night, exhausting the scene. Writing the season through allusion, restrained and bright, the pointed brush.
父老犹记宣和事。
The old folk still recall the days of Xuanhe.
父老犹记宣和事。
The old folk still remember the Xuanhe days.
此句写父老犹记宣和事,是全词由今忆昔的关键。「父老犹记宣和事」写父老犹记宣和事,「父老」写父老、「犹记宣和事」写还记得宣和年间之事。一句以「父老」写老一辈、「犹记宣和事」写其忆宣和,写尽父老犹记宣和事之情——父老犹记宣和旧事。以忆转昔,含蓄而深挚,是「以忆转昔」的点睛之笔。此句以寥寥数语写尽深意,情韵兼胜,正是全诗点睛之笔。其于字句之间暗藏波澜,于平易之中寄寓曲折,尤当反复涵泳,方能得其三昧。
The line writes the old folk still remembering the Xuanhe days, the key of the ci's turning from the present to the past. The old folk writes the older generation; still remember the Xuanhe days writes their memory of the Xuanhe era. One line, the old folk for the elders, the still-remembering for the recalling of Xuanhe, exhausting the scene. Turning to the past through memory, restrained and deep, the pointed brush. The line writes the depth in scant words, the feeling and flavor both fine, the pointed stroke. Its hidden undercurrents between the words, its turns within the plain, call for repeated brooding.
肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指。
Heartbroken, the children with bamboo horses vainly hear tell of three thousand musicians' fingers.
肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指。
Heartbroken, the bamboo-horse children have only heard of the three thousand musicians' fingers.
此二句写三千乐指,是全词写其空忆的关键。「肠断竹马儿童」写肠断竹马儿童,「肠断」写肠断、「竹马儿童」写骑竹马之儿童;「空见说、三千乐指」写空见说三千乐指,「空见说」写只是听说、「三千乐指」写三千乐工之指。两句一写肠断竹马儿童、一写空见说三千乐指,以竹马儿童写儿童、以空见说三千乐指写只是听说,写尽肠断竹马儿童、空见说三千乐指之情。以听说写慨,含蓄而深挚,是「以听说写慨」的点睛之笔。
The two lines write the three thousand musicians' fingers, the key of the ci's writing of the vain memory. Heartbroken, the bamboo-horse children writes the heartbreak and the bamboo-horse children; have only heard of the three thousand musicians' fingers writes the only heard and the musicians' fingers. Two lines, one the heartbroken children, one the only-heard three thousand fingers, the children for the children, the only-heard for the hearsay, exhausting the scene. Writing the sigh through hearsay, restrained and deep, the pointed brush.
暗滴鲛珠坠。
Secretly dropping pearls of the flood-dragon.
暗滴鲛珠坠。
Silently the mermaid's pearls of tears fall.
此句写暗滴鲛珠坠,是全词写其泪落的关键。「暗滴鲛珠坠」写暗滴鲛珠坠,「暗滴」写暗暗滴下、「鲛珠坠」写鲛人之泪坠(鲛珠为泪)。一句以「暗滴」写暗滴、「鲛珠坠」写泪如鲛珠,写尽暗滴鲛珠坠之情——暗中滴泪如鲛珠。以泪写悲,含蓄而深挚,是「以泪写悲」的点睛之笔。此句以寥寥数语写尽深意,情韵兼胜,正是全诗点睛之笔。其于字句之间暗藏波澜,于平易之中寄寓曲折,尤当反复涵泳,方能得其三昧。
The line writes the silent falling of the mermaid pearls, the key of the ci's writing of the tears. Silently the mermaid's pearls of tears fall writes the silent dripping and the mermaid-pearl fall (the mermaid's tears). One line, the silently dripping for the hidden falling, the mermaid pearls for the tearlike pearls, exhausting the scene of the tears falling like pearls in secret. Writing grief through tears, restrained and deep, the pointed brush. The hidden undercurrents between the words, the turns within the plain, call for repeated brooding.
便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里。
Even that day when I saw the Rainbow Skirt dance with my own eyes — heaven, earth, and only in dreams.
便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里。
Even that day, I saw the Rainbow Skirts dance with my own eyes — heaven and the world, all in a dream.
尾三句写天上人间梦里,是全词立意的落点。「便当日、亲见霓裳」写便当日亲见霓裳,「便当日」写便在那日、「亲见霓裳」写亲见霓裳羽衣之舞;「天上人间梦里」写天上人间梦里,「天上人间」写天上人间、「梦里」写只在梦中。三句一写便当日亲见霓裳、一写天上人间梦里,以亲见霓裳写当年盛况、以天上人间梦里写今昔之隔,写尽当日亲见霓裳、天上人间梦里之情。以梦写悲,含蓄而深挚,是全词最动人处,也是「以梦写悲」的点睛之笔。
The closing three lines write heaven and world in the dream, the landing point of the ci's purpose. Even that day, I saw the Rainbow Skirts dance with my own eyes writes the that day and the seen Rainbow Skirts dance; heaven and the world, all in a dream writes the heaven and the world and the dream. Three lines, one the seen Rainbow Skirts, one the heaven-world-in-dream, the seen dance for the old glory, the dream for the present-past gulf, exhausting the scene. Writing grief through the dream, restrained and deep, the most moving place, the pointed brush.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Yan Shu's 'a new song over a cup of wine; last year's weather, the old pavilion' turns the sorrow of passing time into a philosophical sigh; Liu Chenweng's 'the old folk still recall the days of Xuanhe' turns it into dynastic grief. Both write nostalgia through seasonal scenes: Yan Shu keeps it personal and philosophical, Liu Chenweng makes it historical and political. Read together, they show two registers of Song nostalgia — private melancholy and loyalist lament — arising from the same structure of an unchanged scene.
晏殊《浣溪沙·一曲新词酒一杯》「一曲新词酒一杯。去年天气旧亭台」,写今昔之感、无可奈何,是宋词写惜时的名篇;刘辰翁《宝鼎现》则以「父老犹记宣和事。抱铜仙、清泪如水」「便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里」写父老犹记宣和事、天上人间梦里。两词同写元夕怀旧、今昔之感:一写去年天气旧亭台、以亭台写今昔,一写父老犹记宣和事、以宣和写今昔;一为晏殊之温润、一为刘辰翁之沉郁,并读正可见宋词写「节令今昔」的两种笔法,皆于节令之中见今昔之感。
虞美人·春花秋月何时了 Yumeiren: 'When will spring flowers and autumn moon end' 李煜 · 同写故国之感、天上人间,一写故国不堪回首月明中、一写便当日亲见霓裳天上人间梦里,皆于天上人间之中见故国之思 Both write grief for a lost homeland on the scale of 'heaven and earth,' one asking 'how could I bear to look back to my lost land in the moonlight,' the other ending 'heaven, earth, and only a dream'; each is a great elegy built on the same cosmic scale.Li Yu's 'the east wind in the small tower last night; I cannot bear to look back to my lost land in the moonlight' is the immortal cry of a captive king; Liu Chenweng's 'heaven, earth, and only a dream' is the loyalist's elegy after the dynasty's end. Both write loss of homeland on the scale of 'heaven and earth': Li Yu's is a personal, bleeding confession, Liu Chenweng's is accumulated through festival splendor and allusion. Read together, they form the twin summits of the Chinese lyric tradition of dynastic lament.
李煜《虞美人·春花秋月何时了》「小楼昨夜又东风,故国不堪回首月明中」,写故国之思、天上人间,是写愁的千古名篇;刘辰翁《宝鼎现》则以「肠断竹马儿童,空见说、三千乐指」「便当日、亲见霓裳,天上人间梦里」写三千乐指、天上人间梦里。两词同写故国之感、天上人间:一写故国不堪回首月明中、以明月写故国之思,一写便当日亲见霓裳天上人间梦里、以梦里写故国之思;一为帝王之血泪、一为刘辰翁之沉郁,并读正可见词写「故国天上人间」的两种情致,皆于天上人间之中见故国之思。