宋 Song · 词 Ci lyric
浣溪沙·堤上游人逐画船
Huanxisha: Strollers on the Bank Chase the Painted Boat
堤上游人逐画船。
拍堤春水四垂天。
绿杨楼外出秋千。
白发戴花君莫笑,六么催拍盏频传。
人生何处似尊前。
Spring waters lap the dike; the sky bends down on every side.
Bamboo swings drift out beyond the green willow tower.
White-haired, with flowers in my hair—laugh not at me; the Liuyao tune beats quick, cups passed again and again.
Where in life is it like before the wine cup?
Meaning
On a spring day by the Yingzhou West Lake, crowds on the bank chase the painted boats, spring water laps the dike beneath an all-encompassing sky, and a swing drifts out beyond the green willow tower. An old man with flowers in his hair laughs off mockery as the Liuyao tune quickens and cups pass; he asks where in life one is as happy as before the wine. The lyric pairs spring merriment with a faint, autumn note of life's brevity.
堤岸上游人追逐着水中的画船。春水拍打着堤岸,水天相接,四面垂落。绿杨掩映的楼外,有秋千荡出。白发老人头戴鲜花,你们不要笑我,听那六么乐曲催动节拍,酒杯频频传递。人生何处能像在这酒杯之前这般畅快呢。
Appreciation
This is a famous lyric on spring outing at the Yingzhou West Lake, written in Ouyang Xiu's late years. The upper stanza paints three bright scenes—strollers chasing boats, water meeting sky, the swing beyond the willows—with the verbs 'chase,' 'lap,' and 'drift out' giving vivid motion. The lower turns to the white-haired old man with flowers in his hair, feasting and singing, and closes with the famous question 'where in life is it like before the wine cup,' lifting present pleasure into a meditation on life. It is Ouyang Xiu's rare bright, joyful lyric, with a trace of autumn beneath the spring.
【白话串讲】 欧阳修写浣溪沙:“堤上游人逐画船。拍堤春水四垂天。绿杨楼外出秋千”。“白发戴花君莫笑,六么催拍盏频传”——“人生何处似尊前”——他写春日的欢聚。 【意象与手法】 此词为欧阳修咏颍州西湖春日游乐的名篇,写堤上游春的欢快场景。上片三句写景:「堤上游人逐画船」写人船相逐的热闹,「拍堤春水四垂天」写春水拍岸、水天一色的开阔,「绿杨楼外出秋千」写楼外秋千荡出的生机,一句一景,画面灵动;其中「逐」「拍」「出」三字下得极精,动感十足。下片写人:「白发戴花君莫笑」写老翁簪花的风趣,「六么催拍盏频传」写宴饮歌舞之乐,末句「人生何处似尊前」以问收束,点出及时行乐的主旨。全词语言明快,色彩鲜明,把春日堤上的热闹与人生的旷达写得淋漓尽致,是欧阳修词中少见的欢快之作。 【情感与主旨】 此词写春日游春之乐,末句「人生何处似尊前」是全词主旨:人生在世,何处能像举杯畅饮之时这般快乐呢?其中既有及时行乐的旷达,亦暗含人生苦短的感慨——欧阳修晚年官场倾轧、屡遭贬谪,故于春光明媚中尤觉行乐之可贵;「白发戴花」的自嘲里,透出不服老、且尽欢的达观。全词表面写游乐,骨子里是历经宦海沉浮后的生命感悟,欢乐之中带一丝苍凉,是欧阳修「以乐写哀」的深婉笔法。 【名句点睛】 「人生何处似尊前」为千古名句:以问句作结,把游春之乐提升为对人生的追问,语浅而味深,历来被视为及时行乐主题的经典表达,也是欧阳修旷达情怀的写照。
Background
Ouyang Xiu (1007–1072), courtesy name Yong-shu, art name Drunken Old Man, later Liu Yi Ju-shi, was a leader of Northern Song letters and one of the 'Eight Great Prose Masters of Tang and Song.' He served three reigns and rose to disgraced-exile and back, retiring late at Yingzhou (today's Fuyang, Anhui). This lyric was written during that retirement. The Yingzhou West Lake was lovely; he built a home there and wrote many lake lyrics, of which this is famous. It writes the joy of a spring outing: water lapping the dike, crowds, boats, swings, an old man with flowers, passing cups—a vibrant spring scene. Ouyang Xiu, already white-haired, looking back on a career of three rises and falls, especially felt the truth of 'where in life is it like before the wine cup'—life is brief, meetings rare, so enjoy the moment. The lyric seems to write merriment but holds deep life-feeling—joy with a touch of desolation, his 'writing sorrow through joy' subtlety.
欧阳修(一零零七—一零七二),字永叔,号醉翁,晚号六一居士,北宋文坛领袖,「唐宋八大家」之一。他一生历仕仁宗、英宗、神宗三朝,官至参知政事,然宦海浮沉,屡遭贬谪,晚年退居颍州(今安徽阜阳)。此词即作于欧阳修晚年退居颍州期间。颍州西湖景色秀丽,欧阳修晚年于此筑室定居,写下了多首咏西湖的词,《浣溪沙·堤上游人逐画船》即为其中名篇。词写春日堤上游春之乐:春水拍堤,游人如织,画船往来,秋千荡漾,老翁簪花,宴饮传杯,一幅生机盎然的春游图。欧阳修此时已白发苍苍,回首一生,三起三落,饱经宦海风波,故于春日欢乐中尤能体会「人生何处似尊前」的况味——人生短暂,欢会难再,不如趁此良辰美景,尽醉樽前。此词看似写游乐之欢,实则寓含深沉的人生感慨,是欧阳修晚年词「于豪放中见沉著、于欢乐中见苍凉」的典型,亦是宋代文人「以词写人生感悟」的名篇,其「白发戴花」的自我写照,尤为后人传诵。
Art
The lyric excels at 'bright scenery, interplay of motion and stillness, joy setting off feeling.' Upper stanza, three lines, three scenes, moving and still mixed: 'strollers chase the painted boat'—'chase' gives the lively motion of crowd chasing boat, a moving scene; 'spring waters lap the dike; the sky bends down on every side'—'lap' writes water sound and force, 'bends down on every side' writes the open water-and-sky, a big scene moving-within-still; 'bamboo swings drift out beyond the green willow tower'—'drift out' writes the swing's moment emerging from the tower, a stroke Wang Guowei praised as 'with one 'drift out' the whole realm appears.' Lower writes the man: 'white-haired, with flowers in my hair—laugh not at me' self-mockingly writes the old man with flowers, full of charm; 'the Liuyao tune beats quick, cups passed again and again' writes the feast's music and wine; the closing 'where in life is it like before the wine cup' lifts present joy into life's thought. The whole moves from scene to man, from joy to thought—bright, lively, with a faint life-feeling at the joy's end, the subtlety of Ouyang Xiu's 'deep and gentle' style.
此词在艺术上以「写景明快、动静相生、以乐衬情」见长。上片三句写景,一句一画,动静交错:「堤上游人逐画船」写人船相逐,「逐」字写出游人追逐画船的热闹动感,是动景;「拍堤春水四垂天」写春水拍岸、水天相接,「拍」字写水声水势,「四垂天」写水面开阔如天垂四野,是动中有静的大景;「绿杨楼外出秋千」写楼外秋千荡出,「出」字写秋千自绿杨楼头荡出的瞬间,画龙点睛,历来为词家激赏——王国维《人间词话》曾赞此句「着一『出』字,境界全出」。下片写人:「白发戴花君莫笑」以自嘲口吻写老翁簪花,风趣横生;「六么催拍盏频传」写宴饮之乐,乐曲催拍、传杯不止,声情并茂;末句「人生何处似尊前」以问句收束,把眼前之乐提升为对人生的思考。全词由景及人、由乐及思,语言明快流畅,画面生动活泼,而于欢乐的尽头暗藏一丝人生感慨,正是欧阳修「深婉」词风的体现,也是其晚年词中情与景、乐与思交融的代表作。
Allusions
The lyric uses few allusions but rich imagery. First, 'painted boat': ornate pleasure boats, a common amusement image in Tang-Song poetry (Bai Juyi 'small boat with song, painted boat to sleep through rain'), becoming a symbol of Jiangnan leisure; 'strollers chase the painted boat' writes the lively spring-water amusement. Second, 'the sky bends down on every side': from Wen Tingyun's 'South Lake' describing water meeting sky; Ouyang Xiu uses it for the open spring-water dike, adapting with new meaning. Third, 'swing': a typical spring play image in Tang-Song (Du Fu 'ten years of football with my child far, ten thousand li of swing custom the same'); 'bamboo swings drift out beyond the green willow tower' writes the tower's spring with the swing, restrained and vivid. Fourth, 'Liuyao' (also Green Waist, Recorded Essentials), a great Tang-Song tune; Bai Juyi's 'Pipa Xing' has 'first the Neon Robe, then the Liuyao'—Ouyang Xiu's 'the Liuyao tune beats quick, cups passed again and again' writes the feast with tune urging wine, hinting 'enjoy the moment.' Fifth, 'before the cup' (zun): the wine cup; Tang-Song poetry often writes feast-joy and life-feeling with 'before the cup' (Niu Sengru 'say nothing of the world's rise and fall, but contend in the cup before me'); 'where in life is it like before the wine cup' inherits this, asking with a question the complex mix of pleasure and feeling.
此词用典不多而意象含蕴深厚。其一,「画船」:装饰华美的游船,唐宋诗词中常见的游乐意象,白居易有「小舫携歌,画船听雨眠」,画船遂成江南游乐生活的象征;「游人逐画船」写堤上游人追看画船的热闹,正是春日水乡游乐的典型场景。其二,「四垂天」:语本温庭筠《南湖》「湖上微风入槛凉,翻翻菱荇满回塘……野船著岸偎春草,水鸟带波飞夕阳。芦叶有声疑雾雨,浪花无际似潇湘。飘然篷艇东归客,尽日相看忆楚乡」,其「四垂天」写水天相接、天垂四面的景象,欧阳修用以写春水拍堤的开阔,化用而自出新意。其三,「秋千」:秋千是唐宋春日嬉游的典型意象,杜甫有「十年蹴踘将雏远,万里秋千习俗同」,唐宋词中尤多「秋千」意象,写少女春游之乐;「绿杨楼外出秋千」以秋千荡出写楼内春意,含蓄而生动。其四,「六么」:《六么》(又称绿腰、录要)为唐宋大曲名,白居易《琵琶行》有「初为霓裳后六么」,欧阳修「六么催拍盏频传」写宴饮中奏曲催酒的欢乐场景,暗含「及时行乐」之意。其五,「尊前」:尊即酒杯,「尊前」指酒席之前,唐宋诗词中常以「尊前」写宴饮之乐与人生感慨,如牛僧孺「休论世上升沉事,且斗尊前见在身」;「人生何处似尊前」正承此传统,以问句写尽行乐与感慨交织的复杂况味。
Commentary
This lyric is a famous late work of Ouyang Xiu; critics especially prize 'bamboo swings drift out beyond the green willow tower.' Wang Guowei's Ren Jian Ci Hua said 'this one line alone is enough to make Ouyang Xiu immortal,' praising 'with one 'drift out' the whole realm appears'; Ming critic Yang Shen also admired it. Compared with the upper stanza's scenery, the lower's 'white-haired, with flowers in my hair... the Liuyao tune beats quick, cups passed again and again' writes the old man with flowers and the feast, charm within detachment; the closing 'where in life is it like before the wine cup' asks, lifting present pleasure into life's feeling—like Su Shi's 'life is a dream, a cup to the river moon,' one bright one desolate. The lyric's value is writing very deep insight with very bright brush: on the surface a cheerful spring outing, at bottom an old man who weathered court storms recognizing 'life is brief, enjoy the moment'; the self-mockery of 'white-haired with flowers' holds both stubborn youth and see-through detachment. The language is plain as talk, the scenes vivid, yet the feeling long—a model of 'autumn within joy' in Song lyric, and a vivid portrait of Ouyang Xiu's late broad-mindedness.
此词是欧阳修晚年词中的名篇,历代评家极赏其「绿杨楼外出秋千」一句。清代王国维《人间词话》谓「『绿杨楼外出秋千』,欧公仅此一句,便足传世」,称其「着一『出』字,境界全出」;明代杨慎《词品》亦赏此句,以为「出」字写秋千荡出之态,妙绝千古。与上片写景相比,下片「白发戴花君莫笑,六么催拍盏频传」写老翁簪花、宴饮传杯,风趣之中见旷达;末句「人生何处似尊前」以问作结,把眼前行乐升华为人生感慨,与苏轼「人生如梦,一尊还酹江月」之问异曲同工,而一明快一苍凉。此词的价值,在于以极明快的笔触写极深沉的感悟:表面是春日游春的欢快小词,骨子里却是历尽宦海风波的老者对「人生苦短、行乐须及时」的体认;「白发戴花」的自嘲里,有不服老的倔强,也有看透世事的达观。全词语言明白如话,画面生动鲜明,而情味深长,是宋词中「于欢乐处见苍凉」的典范,亦是欧阳修晚年旷达襟怀的生动写照。
Prosody
Line by line
堤上游人逐画船。
On the bank, strollers chase the painted boat. (The opening line sets the lively spring-outing tone. 'On the bank' places it on the West Lake dike in spring; 'strollers chase the painted boat' writes the crowd-and-boat chase—the boat moves and the people follow, a water-and-bank, boat-and-man mutual pursuit, bustling. The word 'chase' is the line's eye, stirring the joy at once; 'painted boat' hints the opulent leisure. Ouyang Xiu is a master of animating with one word; 'chase' writes the strollers' high spirits and the tempting spring scene—his 'plain language, deep feeling, motion for joy' manner.)
堤岸上游人追逐着水中的画船。
Along the embankment, sightseers follow the painted barge.
起句写堤上游春的热闹景象,是全词欢乐基调的奠定。「堤上」点明地点——春日西湖之堤,正是游人如织之所;「游人逐画船」写人船相逐的动态,「逐」字是全句之眼:游人沿堤追逐着水中的画船,画船行则人追,船止则人观,一水一岸,一船一人,相逐相望,热闹非凡。此句以「逐」写动,把春日游春的欢快气氛一下子烘托出来,画面感极强。同时,「画船」二字点出船之华美,暗含游乐的富贵闲适气息。起句便见热闹,为下文的春水、秋千、宴饮层层蓄势。欧阳修写景善于以一字传神,「逐」字写尽游人兴致之高、春景之诱人,正是其词「语浅情深、以动写乐」的本色。
The opening writes the bustle of the embankment outing, laying the ci's joyful tone. Along the embankment names the spring lake shore, the thronged place; sightseers follow the painted barge writes the motion of people and boat, the word follow the eye of the line: sightseers along the dyke chasing the painted boat on the water, boat moving and men chasing, boat stopping and men watching, water and shore, boat and man, chasing and gazing, the bustle lively. The word follow writes motion, bringing the spring outing's gaiety at once, the picture vivid; the painted barge names the boat's splendor, carrying the wealth and leisure of the pleasure. The opening already busy, storing force for the spring water, the swing, the feast below. Ouyang Xiu writes scene through one telling word; the follow exhausts the sightseers' delight and the spring's lure, the essence of his shallow words and deep feeling.
绿杨楼外出秋千。
Bamboo swings drift out beyond the green willow tower. (The most celebrated line of the lyric, admired for ages. 'Beyond the green willow tower' first sets the scene—green willows and tower, full of spring; 'swings drift out' writes the swing emerging from beyond the tower—not the swing hanging still, but someone swinging, the swing drifting out beyond the tower, revealing the tower's spring and its people. Wang Guowei praised 'with one 'drift out' the whole realm appears'—the word writes motion and restraint: the swing emerges, and the reader imagines the swinger, the tower's spring, the daughter's laughter, all beyond the words. If written 'beyond the willow tower a swing' or 'the swing sways beyond the tower' it would lack this 'drift out' magic—'drift out' moves from inside to outside, drawing the tower's life into the spring light, restrained and full of realm. This line writes motion through stillness, reveals through concealment—a classic of Song lyric diction and the concentrated expression of Ouyang Xiu's 'deep and gentle' style.)
绿杨掩映的楼外,有秋千荡出。
Beyond the green willows and the houses, a swing swings into view.
此句是全词最负盛名的句子,历代词家叹赏不置。「绿杨楼外」先写景:绿杨与楼阁相映,春意盎然;「出秋千」写秋千荡出,「出」字是全句之眼,写秋千自绿杨楼头荡出的那一瞬间——不是秋千静悬,而是人荡秋千,秋千荡出楼外,露出楼内的春意与人影。王国维《人间词话》评此句「着一『出』字,境界全出」,正指此字写出动态、写出含蓄:秋千荡出,读者自可想见荡秋千之人,楼内春色、女儿笑语,尽在言外。若作「秋千外绿杨楼」「楼外秋千荡」皆不及此「出」字之妙——「出」字由内而外,把楼内的生机引向楼外的春光,含蓄蕴藉,境界全出。此句以静写动、以藏写露,是宋词炼字的经典范例,亦是欧阳修词「深婉」风格的集中体现。
This is the ci's most celebrated line, admired through the ages. Beyond the green willows and the houses first sets the scene: green willows against pavilions, spring abundant; a swing swings into view writes the swing appearing, the word out the eye of the line — the instant the swing flies out beyond the willowed eaves, not hanging still, but ridden, swinging out beyond the roof to reveal the spring within and the figure. Wang Guowei in his remarks on poetry said that with this one word out the whole realm appears, meaning the word writes motion and restraint: the swing swings out, and the reader imagines the rider, the spring within the pavilion, the girls' laughter, all beyond the words. Any other arrangement loses the out — the out moves from within to without, drawing the life inside out into the spring light, restrained and suggestive, the whole realm appearing. The line writes motion through stillness, disclosure through concealment, the classic example of Song ci's word-craft, the concentrated showing of Ouyang Xiu's deep grace.
白发戴花君莫笑,六么催拍盏频传。
White-haired, with flowers in my hair—laugh not at me; the Liuyao tune beats quick, cups passed again and again. (These two lines write the feast's joy, the lyric's emotional peak. 'White-haired, with flowers in my hair—laugh not at me' self-mockingly writes the old man with flowers: an old man with flowers in his hair is laughable, yet he says frankly 'laugh not,' meaning he enjoys himself—writing Ouyang Xiu's detachment: old in years, young in spring heart, why not wear flowers and laugh? 'The Liuyao tune beats quick, cups passed again and again' writes the feast's abundance—the tune urges, song quick, dance fast, cups passed among the company; 'urge' and 'again' write the fervor. The two lines, one mock one joy, make the white-haired old man's pleasure vivid. Yet 'white-haired' already hides a sigh: in the joy, the years are gone, hence enjoy the moment. These lines write sorrow through joy, laugh through sigh—Ouyang Xiu's 'deep and gentle' manner—and pave the way for the closing question.)
白发老人头戴鲜花,你们不要笑我,听那六么乐曲催动节拍,酒杯频频传递。
White-haired, I wear flowers in my hair — do not laugh; the Luyao tune drives the beat, and the cup passes often.
这两句写宴饮之乐,是全词情感的高潮。「白发戴花君莫笑」以自嘲口吻写老翁簪花:白发老人头戴鲜花,本是好笑之事,词人却坦然自嘲「君莫笑」——你们不要笑我,言外之意是我自得其乐。这一笔写出欧阳修的旷达:年岁虽老,春心不老,簪花行乐,何妨一笑。「六么催拍盏频传」写宴饮之盛:六么乐曲催动节拍,歌声急、舞步快,酒杯在众人间频频传递,「催」「频」二字写尽宴饮的热闹与酣畅。两句一动一静、一嘲一乐,把白发老人的行乐之态写得活灵活现。然而「白发」二字已暗藏感慨:欢乐之中,年华已逝,故须及时行乐。这两句以乐写哀、以笑写慨,正是欧阳修「深婉」词风的体现,也为末句「人生何处似尊前」的感慨作了铺垫。
These two lines write the feast's delight, the emotional peak of the ci. White-haired, I wear flowers in my hair — do not laugh: the old man in flowers, a sight for laughter, and the poet mocks himself with do not laugh — do not mock, the unspoken meaning being that I enjoy myself. The line shows Ouyang Xiu's equanimity: old in years, and the spring heart not old, wearing flowers for pleasure, why not a laugh? The Luyao tune drives the beat, and the cup passes often writes the feast's splendor: the Luyao rhythm driving the beat, the song urgent, the steps quick, the cup passing frequently among the guests, the words drive and frequent exhausting the bustle and the warmth. Two lines, one motion one stillness, one mockery one delight, drawing the old man's pleasure vividly. Yet the white hair already hides the sigh: amid the joy, the years have passed, hence the carpe diem. Writing grief through delight, sigh through laughter, the showing of Ouyang Xiu's deep grace, preparing the ground for the closing where is there anything like the moment before the cup.
人生何处似尊前。
Where in life is it like before the wine cup? (The closing question sums the lyric and lifts its feeling. 'Where in life is it like before the wine cup'—where in life is one as happy as before the wine? A rhetorical question, the answer clear: only before the cup. Its merit is threefold: it asks and lingers, lifting present pleasure into life's thought, giving the small lyric sudden weight; 'before the cup' carries both the detachment of 'enjoy the moment' and the sigh of 'life is brief,' joy and sorrow intertwined; asking 'where is it like' implies a negation of life's troubles—fame, wealth, honor, none like a cup's drunk. Plain yet deep, it is a classic line on enjoyment, akin to Li Bai's 'when life goes well, be sure to feast,' but more calm and desolate—the crystallized life-insight of Ouyang Xiu after court storms.)
人生何处能像在这酒杯之前这般畅快呢。
In all this life, where is there anything like the moment before the cup?
末句以问句收束全词,是点题之笔,亦是全词情感的升华。「人生何处似尊前」——人生在世,何处能像举杯畅饮之时这般畅快呢?这是一个设问,答案不言自明:唯有尊前。此句之妙有三:其一,以问作结,余味悠长,把眼前的行乐之欢提升为对人生的思考,使小词陡然有了分量;其二,「尊前」二字承上片宴饮而来,又兼含「及时行乐」的旷达与「人生苦短」的感慨,一乐一哀,交织其中;其三,以「何处似」发问,暗含对人生种种烦恼的否定——功名、富贵、荣辱,皆不如尊前一醉。此句语浅而味深,历来被视为行乐主题的经典表达,与李白「人生得意须尽欢」异曲同工,而更见沉静苍凉,是欧阳修历经宦海后的生命体悟的结晶。
The close ends the ci in the question, the stroke that points the theme and elevates the feeling. In all this life, where is there anything like the moment before the cup? — in all life, where is there the joy of the raised cup? A rhetorical question, the answer self-evident: only before the cup. The line's beauty is threefold: first, the question as close, the aftertone long, raising the present pleasure into the meditation on life, giving the small ci sudden weight; second, before the cup inherits the feast above, carrying both the carpe diem equanimity and the life-is-short sigh, joy and grief interwoven; third, the where-as-if question implies the negation of all life's troubles — rank, riches, glory, shame, none equals the cup's single drunkenness. The words shallow, the flavor deep, long held as the classic expression of the pleasure theme, akin to Li Bai's when life is satisfied, make merry to the full, and yet more subdued and somber, the crystallization of Ouyang Xiu's life understanding after the official storms.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
苏轼《浣溪沙·簌簌衣巾落枣花》「簌簌衣巾落枣花,村南村北响缫车……日高人渴漫思茶」与欧阳修此词同用《浣溪沙》词牌,同写春日田园之乐。差异在:苏词写徐州谢雨途中的乡村风情,枣花、缫车、卖瓜、思茶,是纯然的农家生活与民风民俗,境界质朴清新;欧词写颍州西湖的士人游乐,画船、秋千、六么、尊前,是文人的春游宴饮,境界明快富贵。一写田园之趣、一写游乐之欢,一朴一丽,恰见苏轼与欧阳修同是「以乐写生」而取向不同。两词并读,可见《浣溪沙》这一词牌既宜写田园风情,亦宜写都市游乐,其表现力之宽,正为两词所证。
江南春 Spring in Jiangnan · 同写春日水乡,一写景中带史一写乐中藏慨 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
杜牧《江南春》「千里莺啼绿映红,水村山郭酒旗风。南朝四百八十寺,多少楼台烟雨中」与欧阳修此词同写春日江南水乡之景,同以水、船、楼、春色为意象。差异在:杜诗写景明丽而暗藏历史兴亡之感,「南朝四百八十寺」一笔,把眼前春景与南朝旧事勾连,乐景之中寓沧桑;欧词写景明快而暗含人生行乐之慨,「人生何处似尊前」一问,把眼前游乐与人生短暂相连,欢乐之中藏苍凉。一以景写史、一以景写情,一宏阔一轻快,恰见唐诗与宋词在「春日水乡」题材上重史与重情的不同取向。两作并读,可见同一春景,在唐诗中是历史的背景,在宋词中是人生的舞台。