All poems

宋 Song · 词 Ci lyric

霓裳中序第一

Nishang Zhongxu Diyi (Rainbow-Skirt Prelude, No. 1)

姜夔

Jiang Kui

亭皋正望极。
乱落江莲归未得。
多病却无气力。
况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦。
流光过隙。
叹杏梁、双燕如客。
人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色。
幽寂。
乱蛩吟壁。
动庾信、清愁似织。
沈思年少浪迹。
笛里关山,柳下坊陌。
坠红无信息。
漫暗水,涓涓溜碧。
漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧。

On the riverbank mound I gaze to the far end.
Lotus blossoms scatter on the water, and I cannot find my way home.
Sick and ailing, I have no strength left.
Worse still: the silk fan is gradually laid aside, the gauze robe newly wrapped against the cold.
Time flows like a white colt through a crack.
I sigh — in the apricot-beam hall the pair of swallows seem like passing guests.
Where is she now? Through one curtain of pale moonlight her face seems still to shine.
All is hushed.
Crickets chirp on the walls.
Yu Xin's sorrow, woven like damask, stirs within me.
I brood on my wandering youth —
passes and mountains in the flute, willow lanes and city quarters.
No word comes from the fallen petals.
Dark water glides on, a thin current slipping green.
Long have I drifted rootless; what zest is left? I lie drunk beside the wine-seller's post.
Listen

Meaning

The poem is a traveler's song of longing for an absent beloved. Standing on a riverbank mound, the speaker is sick, weak, and unable to return home; the laid-aside fan and newly wrapped robe mark autumn's approach and the cooling of favor. Time races like a white colt through a crack, the swallows in the carved beams are mere guests, and in the cricket-chirring silence his sorrow is woven as tight as Yu Xin's. Remembering his wandering youth, he finds no word from the fallen blossoms; long rootless and stripped of all zest, he ends lying drunk beside a wine stall.

亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得。多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦。流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客。人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色。幽寂。乱蛩吟壁。动庾信、清愁似织。沈思年少浪迹。笛里关山,柳下坊陌。坠红无信息。漫暗水,涓涓溜碧。漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧。

Appreciation

[Plain Paraphrase] Standing on a riverbank mound, the speaker gazes to the horizon, where scattered lotus blossoms remind him he cannot return. Weak with illness, he feels autumn approach as the silk fan is set aside and the gauze robe wrapped against the cold. Time races past like a white colt through a crack; the swallows nesting in the carved beams of his lodging seem like passing guests. Where is his beloved? Only a curtain of pale moonlight seems to illumine her face. [Structure] The upper stanza moves from outward gaze to inward confession, the lower stanza from memory to dissolution: thoughts of youth's wanderings — mountain passes in the flute, willow lanes — end in a night of wine. [Imagery] Jiang Kui's images are cool and translucent — pale moon, dark water, crickets on the wall, petals without news — the classic qingkong (ethereal) texture, in which feeling is never stated directly but hovers in the light.

【白话串讲】 姜夔写《霓裳中序第一》:“亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得”——“多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦”——“流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客”——“人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色”——他写怀人——一帘淡月。 【意象与手法】 “亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得”写望归未得;“多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦”写多病;“流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客”以流光过隙写时光;“人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色”以淡月写怀人;结以“漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧”写漂零。含蓄空灵。 【情感与主旨】 姜夔写羁旅怀人之作,写望归未得、多病漂零与对故人的思念,以“一帘淡月”写相思,是白石词中清空骚雅的代表。 【名句点睛】 常考“人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色”以淡月写怀人;“流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客”以流光过隙写时光。

Background

Jiang Kui (c. 1155–c. 1221), courtesy name Yaozhang and sobriquet Baishi Daoren, came from Poyang in Raozhou (modern Poyang, Jiangxi). The greatest ci poet and musician of the Southern Song, he never held office and lived by his art; his style is summed up as qingkong saoya — clear and ethereal, pure and elegant — founding an 'elegant school' of ci writing. The tune title preserves a musical treasure: according to Jiang's own preface, in 1186, while staying in Changsha, he found among an old musician's books eighteen sections of the Nishang melody in the shang mode, written as empty tablature without words, and identified the middle prelude (zhongxu) of the Tang banquet masterpiece 'Rainbow and Feather Garment Melody' (Nishang Yuyi Qu), filling it with new words. The poem survives in his collection Baishi Daoren Gequ.

《霓裳中序第一》为南宋词人姜夔所作词。姜夔(约1155—约1221),字尧章,号白石道人,饶州鄱阳(今江西鄱阳)人,南宋词人、音乐家,词风清空骚雅,开「清雅词派」之先。此词写羁旅怀人。词中「亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得」写亭皋望极;「多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦」写纨扇罗衣;「流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客」写流光过隙;「人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色」写仿佛照颜色;「幽寂。乱蛩吟壁。动庾信、清愁似织」写清愁似织;「沈思年少浪迹。笛里关山,柳下坊陌」写笛里关山;「坠红无信息。漫暗水,涓涓溜碧」写坠红无信息;「漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧」写醉卧酒垆侧。姜夔此词以羁旅怀人、醉卧酒垆侧写其羁旅之情,含蓄空灵,是姜夔词中的名篇。此篇《霓裳中序第一》在历代选本中多被收录,其艺术价值与流传之广,正可见此诗在同类题材中的重要地位。诗人以匠心独运之笔写寻常之情事,遂使此作历千载而犹有生气,为后人所称赏不绝。

Art

The lyric's craft lies in restraint and in turning scenery into feeling. Jiang builds the upper stanza as a slow turn from outer world to inner state: the riverbank gaze, the falling lotuses, the sick body, the fan and robe, the galloping time, the swallows like guests — each image thins the speaker's hold on life, until the beloved appears only as an effect of pale moonlight. The lower stanza darkens further: crickets on the wall, Yu Xin's woven sorrow, memories of youth's wanderings, petals with no news, a dark stream slipping green — until all resolves in drunkenness by the wine stall. Two devices deserve note: the sustained oblique-tone rhyme gives the whole a muffled, sighing music, and person-to-object fusions ('the swallows are like guests') merge landscape with the speaker's homelessness. No exclamation, no direct cry — sorrow is everywhere and nowhere, the signature of the qingkong manner.

此词艺术上以「含蓄空灵、以景写情」见长。全词上片写亭皋望极与流光过隙,下片写清愁似织与醉卧酒垆侧。上片「亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得」写亭皋望极:亭皋正望极,乱落江莲归未得;「多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦」写纨扇罗衣:多病却无气力,况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦;「流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客」写流光过隙:流光过隙,叹杏梁、双燕如客;「人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色」写仿佛照颜色:人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色。下片「幽寂。乱蛩吟壁。动庾信、清愁似织」写清愁似织:幽寂,乱蛩吟壁,动庾信、清愁似织;「沈思年少浪迹。笛里关山,柳下坊陌」写笛里关山:沈思年少浪迹,笛里关山,柳下坊陌;「坠红无信息。漫暗水,涓涓溜碧」写坠红无信息:坠红无信息,漫暗水,涓涓溜碧;「漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧」写醉卧酒垆侧:漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧。全词含蓄空灵,以景写情,是姜夔词中的名篇。

Allusions

The poem is dense with inherited echoes. 'The silk fan is gradually laid aside' recalls Ban Jieyu, the abandoned consort of Emperor Cheng of Han, whose 'Fan Poem' compared herself to a silk fan discarded in autumn. 'Time flows like a white colt through a crack' adapts the Zhuangzi: human life between heaven and earth is like a white colt passing a crevice. 'Apricot beams' quotes Sima Xiangru's 'Tall Gate Palace Fu,' which gilds apricot wood for its beams, here marking a borrowed lodging. 'Yu Xin's sorrow as if woven' invokes the sixth-century poet Yu Xin, detained in the north, whose 'Lament for the South' became the classic voice of exile sorrow. 'Lying drunk beside the wine stall' alludes to Ruan Ji, who slept drunk beside his neighbor's wine vat, and to Wang Rong's later visit to the old wine shop of Huang Gong, mourning lost friends. Jiang fuses these allusions so smoothly they read as natural speech.

词中「亭皋望极」「乱落江莲」「归未得」「多病却无气力」「纨扇渐疏」「罗衣初萦」「流光过隙」「杏梁」「双燕如客」「一帘淡月」「仿佛照颜色」「幽寂」「乱蛩吟壁」「庾信清愁似织」「沈思年少浪迹」「笛里关山」「柳下坊陌」「坠红无信息」「暗水涓涓溜碧」「漂零久」「醉卧酒垆侧」等语,皆含典故故实。「亭皋望极」写水边高地望尽(亭皋为水边高地);「乱落江莲」写江莲乱落;「归未得」写不得归;「多病却无气力」写多病无力;「纨扇渐疏」用班婕妤团扇之典(纨扇秋来渐疏);「罗衣初萦」写罗衣初萦;「流光过隙」用《庄子》「人生天地之间,若白驹之过隙」之意,写时光飞逝;「杏梁」用司马相如《长门赋》「饰文杏以为梁」之意,写杏梁;「双燕如客」写双燕如客;「一帘淡月」写一帘淡月;「仿佛照颜色」写仿佛照着其颜色;「幽寂」写幽寂;「乱蛩吟壁」写乱蛩吟壁;「庾信清愁似织」用庾信愁赋之典,写清愁如织;「沈思年少浪迹」写沉思年少浪迹;「笛里关山」用笛曲《关山月》之意,写笛里关山;「柳下坊陌」写柳下坊陌;「坠红无信息」写坠红无信息;「暗水涓涓溜碧」写暗水涓涓溜碧;「漂零久」写久经漂泊;「醉卧酒垆侧」用《世说新语》王戎「酒垆之侧」之典(兼用阮籍邻家酒垆醉卧之意),写醉卧酒垆侧。词人以团扇、白驹过隙、庾信愁赋、关山月、酒垆侧等典入词,不着痕迹,而把羁旅怀人之情写得真切可感,是善于熔铸典故的体现。

Commentary

This is one of Jiang Kui's most admired lyrics, prized as a model of the qingkong manner. Critics have especially singled out 'Where is she now — through one curtain of pale moonlight her face seems still to shine,' where the beloved is present only as an effect of light, and the closing drunken collapse, whose apparent self-abandonment conceals the deepest attachment. The poem was preserved in Baishi Daoren Gequ and widely anthologized; with its rediscovered musical score it also offers rare evidence of Tang banquet music surviving into the Southern Song. Later critics of the elegant school, Zhang Yan and Zhou Mi, treated Jiang as their fountainhead, and Wang Guowei in Renjian Cihua ranked his lyrics for their ethereal texture. It remains a touchstone for reading the lyric as music of feeling rather than declaration.

这首《霓裳中序第一》,是姜夔写羁旅怀人之作,写亭皋望极、流光过隙、醉卧酒垆侧之情,含蓄空灵。上片写亭皋望极与流光过隙:「亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得」——亭皋正望极,乱落江莲归未得。写亭皋望极:亭皋正望极、乱落江莲归未得——亭皋望尽、江莲乱落而不得归;「多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦」——多病却无气力,况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦。写纨扇罗衣:多病却无气力,况纨扇渐疏(用团扇之典)、罗衣初萦——多病无力、纨扇渐疏;「流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客」——流光过隙,叹杏梁、双燕如客。写流光过隙:流光过隙(用白驹过隙之意)、叹杏梁双燕如客——流光过隙、叹双燕如客;「人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色」——人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色。写仿佛照颜色:人何在、一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色——人何在、一帘淡月仿佛照其颜色。下片写清愁似织与醉卧酒垆侧:「幽寂。乱蛩吟壁。动庾信、清愁似织」——幽寂,乱蛩吟壁,动庾信、清愁似织。写清愁似织:幽寂、乱蛩吟壁,动庾信清愁似织(用庾信愁赋之典)——幽寂蛩吟、清愁似织;「沈思年少浪迹。笛里关山,柳下坊陌」——沈思年少浪迹,笛里关山,柳下坊陌。写笛里关山:沈思年少浪迹、笛里关山,柳下坊陌——沉思年少浪迹、笛里关山、柳下坊陌;「坠红无信息。漫暗水,涓涓溜碧」——坠红无信息,漫暗水,涓涓溜碧。写坠红无信息:坠红无信息、漫暗水涓涓溜碧——坠红无信、暗水溜碧;「漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧」——漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧。写醉卧酒垆侧:漂零久、而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧(用酒垆之典)——漂零已久、醉卧酒垆侧。这「漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧」,是全词之结:以醉卧酒垆侧写其漂泊之况。全词含蓄空灵,以景写情,正是姜夔词中的名篇。

Prosody

Form Ci (song lyric) in the tune Nishang Zhongxu Diyi, a long tune (changdiao) of 101 characters, with ten lines in each of the two stanzas.词(霓裳中序第一,长调)
Rhyme Rhymed in oblique (ze sheng) tones throughout; the fifteen rhyme words (pinyin: ji, de, li, ying, xi, ke, se, ji, bi, zhi, ji, mo, xi, bi, ce) all belong to the traditional oblique-tone rhyme group (the zhi-mo group), giving one muffled, sighing cadence from beginning to end.此词为《霓裳中序第一》调,长调一百零一字,上片下片各十句。押仄声韵:「极」「得」「力」「萦」「隙」「客」「色」「寂」「壁」「织」「迹」「陌」「息」「碧」「侧」押职陌部韵。词体依词谱而定,长调铺叙,句式长短错落,音节随情起伏,正与写羁旅怀人的含蓄空灵相称,也见其以长调写羁旅的自然。
Tone pattern Line lengths alternate between long and short: three-character lines ('duo bing que wu qi li') contract the breath, while seven-character lines ('ren he zai, yi lian dan yue...') open it; the overall movement runs from an expansive gaze to a low, folded cadence, the music tracking the emotion's ebb.句式上,上片「亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得」写亭皋望极,音节苍茫;「多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦」写纨扇罗衣,音节低回;「流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客」写流光过隙,音节感慨;「人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色」写仿佛照颜色,音节空灵;下片「幽寂。乱蛩吟壁。动庾信、清愁似织」写清愁似织,音节低回;「沈思年少浪迹。笛里关山,柳下坊陌」写笛里关山,音节怅惘;「坠红无信息。漫暗水,涓涓溜碧」写坠红无信息,音节清冷;「漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧」写醉卧酒垆侧,音节沉郁。全词音节随情起伏,由苍茫而低回、由空灵而沉郁,正合长调「铺叙」之妙,读来如羁旅怀人、醉卧酒垆侧之音,含蓄而动人。
Reading note The recovered melody of the Nishang Zhongxu Diyi prelude lends this poem historical interest, since Jiang Kui filled an old Tang score with new words. In performance the long tune unfolds slowly, its oblique rhymes and alternating line lengths suiting the leisured, restrained narration of a traveler's homesickness; prosody and qingkong aesthetic reinforce one another.此词为《霓裳中序第一》调,是姜夔写羁旅怀人之作,也是其词中的名篇。全词的艺术特色在于「含蓄空灵、以景写情」:上片「亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得」写亭皋望极、「多病却无气力。况纨扇渐疏,罗衣初萦」写纨扇罗衣、「流光过隙。叹杏梁、双燕如客」写流光过隙、「人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色」写仿佛照颜色;下片「幽寂。乱蛩吟壁。动庾信、清愁似织」写清愁似织、「沈思年少浪迹。笛里关山,柳下坊陌」写笛里关山、「坠红无信息。漫暗水,涓涓溜碧」写坠红无信息、「漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧」写醉卧酒垆侧。全词含蓄空灵,以景写情。尤为精妙者,是「流光过隙」用白驹过隙之典写时光;而「漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧」以醉卧酒垆侧写其漂泊,正是姜夔词「清空骚雅」的典范,为历代词选所常收。

Line by line

亭皋正望极。

On the riverbank mound I gaze to the far end.

亭皋正望极。

From the waterside terrace, I gaze to the farthest limit.

首句写亭皋望极,起笔即见其境。「亭皋正望极」写亭皋正望极,「亭皋」写水边高地、「正望极」写正望尽远方。一句以「亭皋」写其地、以「正望极」写其望尽,写尽亭皋之上正望极之景——水边高地、望断天涯。以景起兴,含蓄而苍茫,是「以景起兴」的妙笔。此句以寥寥数语写尽深意,情韵兼胜,正是全诗点睛之笔。其于字句之间暗藏波澜,于平易之中寄寓曲折,尤当反复涵泳,方能得其三昧。

The opening writes the waterside terrace's farthest gaze, the realm present at the first stroke. From the waterside terrace, I gaze to the farthest limit writes the waterside height and the gaze to the limit. One line, the place and the gaze, writing the terrace above and the horizon's end, exhausting the waterside height and the broken-horizon. Rising on scene, restrained and vast, precisely the wondrous brush of rising on scene. This line in the few words exhausts the deep meaning, feeling and charm both supreme, precisely the poem's telling stroke. Its hidden waves between the words, the turns within the plainness, require the repeated savouring to grasp its heart.

流光过隙。

Time flows like a white colt through a crack.

流光过隙。

The floating light passes through a crack.

此句写流光过隙,是全词写时光飞逝的关键。「流光过隙」写流光过隙,「流光」用白驹过隙之意写时光、「过隙」写穿过缝隙。一句以「流光」写时光之逝、以「过隙」用庄子白驹过隙之典写其速,写尽流光飞逝如白驹过隙之情。以典写时,含蓄而深挚,是「以典写时」的点睛之笔。此句以寥寥数语写尽深意,情韵兼胜,正是全诗点睛之笔。其于字句之间暗藏波澜,于平易之中寄寓曲折,尤当反复涵泳,方能得其三昧。

This line writes the floating light passing through a crack, the ci's key of the time's flight. The floating light passes through a crack writes the floating light (using the white-foal-passing-the-crack meaning for the time) and the crack's passing. One line, the time's flight and the crack's speed (using Zhuangzi's white-foal allusion for the speed), exhausting the light's flight like the foal through the crack. Writing time through allusion, restrained and deep, precisely the telling stroke of time writing through allusion. This line in the few words exhausts the deep meaning, feeling and charm both supreme, precisely the poem's telling stroke. Its hidden waves between the words, the turns within the plainness, require the repeated savouring to grasp its heart.

人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色。

Where is she now? Through one curtain of pale moonlight her face seems still to shine.

人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色。

Where is the person? Through the curtain, the pale moon, as if shining on her face.

此三句写仿佛照颜色,是全词写怀人的关键。「人何在」写人何在,「人何在」写其人如今何在;「一帘淡月」写一帘淡月,「一帘」写一帘、「淡月」写清淡之月;「仿佛照颜色」写仿佛照颜色,「仿佛」写仿佛、「照颜色」写照着其容色。三句一写人何在、一写一帘淡月、一写仿佛照颜色,以人何在写其渺茫、以一帘淡月写月之淡、以仿佛照颜色写月如照其颜色,写尽人何在、一帘淡月仿佛照其颜色之情。以月写忆,含蓄而空灵,是「以月写忆」的点睛之笔。

These three lines write the as-if-shining-on-her-face, the ci's key of the longing. Where is the person? writes the now-where; through the curtain, the pale moon writes the curtain and the pale moon; as if shining on her face writes the as-if and the face's shining. Three lines, one the where, one the pale moon, one the as-if face, writing the blur, the pale moon, the moon's as-if shining on her color, exhausting the where and the moon's as-if shining. Writing memory through the moon, restrained and ethereal, precisely the telling stroke of memory writing through the moon.

漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧。

Long have I drifted rootless; what zest is left? I lie drunk beside the wine-seller's post.

漂零久,而今何意,醉卧酒垆侧。

Drifting long, what feeling now? Drunk, I lie by the wine stall.

尾三句写醉卧酒垆侧,是全词立意的落点。「漂零久」写漂零久,「漂零」写漂泊零落、「久」写已久;「而今何意」写而今何意,「而今」写如今、「何意」写还有什么兴致;「醉卧酒垆侧」写醉卧酒垆侧,「醉卧」写醉而卧、「酒垆侧」用酒垆之典写酒垆之侧。三句一写漂零久、一写而今何意、一写醉卧酒垆侧,以漂零久写漂泊之深、以而今何意写其无兴、以醉卧酒垆侧写其颓放,写尽漂零已久、醉卧酒垆侧之情。以醉写愁,含蓄而深挚,是全词最动人处,也是「以醉写愁」的点睛之笔。

The last three lines write the drunk lying by the wine stall, the landing of the ci's theme. Drifting long writes the drifting-and-fallen and the long; what feeling now writes the now and the remaining zest; drunk, I lie by the wine stall writes the drunk lying and the wine stall (using the wine-stall allusion). Three lines, one the long drift, one the now's feeling, one the wine-stall side, writing the drift's depth, the zestlessness, the abandon, exhausting the long drift and the drunk lying. Writing grief through the drunk, restrained and deep, the ci's most moving place, and the telling stroke of grief writing through the drunk.

Study

Word focus

望极 'Gaze to the far end': the opening words set the poem's distance — from a riverbank mound the speaker looks to the horizon, a gaze with nothing to rest on that opens the whole lyric's homesickness. 「望极」写亭皋正望极,是写望尽天涯的关键。「亭皋正望极」着一「望极」,写望尽——着一「望极」,写亭皋之上望尽远方,见其望之远。两字写尽望极之远,是「以词写望」的妙笔。「望极」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
似织 'As if woven': the measure of sorrow. Grief is not called deep or heavy but as dense as damask on the loom; 'woven' makes the sorrow fine, even, and endless, with the cricket's chirr as the shuttle. 「似织」写清愁似织,是写愁之密的关键。「清愁似织」着一「似织」,写如织——着一「似织」,写清愁如织,见愁之密。两字写尽愁之似织,是「以词写愁」的点睛之词。「似织」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
仿佛 'Seemingly': the haze of memory. The beloved is not seen, only 'seemingly' lit by pale moonlight — one adverb makes her present and absent at once, the ethereal quality in miniature. 「仿佛」写仿佛照颜色,是写月照之恍惚的关键。「仿佛照颜色」着一「仿佛」,写仿佛——着一「仿佛」,写淡月仿佛照其颜色,见其忆之恍惚。两字写尽照之仿佛,是「以词写忆」的点睛之词。「仿佛」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
何意 'What zest': the question at the end. After long drifting, the speaker asks what desire remains — a rhetorical question that is really an answer of exhaustion, letting the drunken collapse fall into place. 「何意」写而今何意,是写其无兴的关键。「而今何意」着一「何意」,写还有什么兴致——着一「何意」,写漂零久后已无兴致,见其颓放。两字写尽其无兴,是「以词写情」的点睛之词。「何意」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。

Related Reading

晏殊·蝶恋花·槛菊愁烟兰泣露 Dielianhua (To the Tune 'Butterflies Love Flowers') 晏殊 · 同写秋夜怀人、望尽天涯,一写独上高楼望尽天涯路、一写亭皋正望极人何在,皆于登高望极之中见怀人之情 Both write of autumn-night longing and gazing to the horizon — one from a tower, one from a riverbank mound

Yan Shu's 'alone I climb the high tower and gaze to the end of the sky's road' writes the autumn sights until the green verge is lost, the classic Song lyric of longing. Jiang Kui answers with 'on the riverbank mound I gaze to the far end' and 'where is she now? through one curtain of pale moonlight her face seems still to shine' — one poet gazes from a tower, the other from a riverbank; Yan Shu's tone is warm and broad, Jiang Kui's clear and ethereal. Read together, the two show the Song lyric's two brushes for writing 'gazing to the end of the sky,' both finding the beloved beyond the horizon.

晏殊《蝶恋花·槛菊愁烟兰泣露》「独上高楼,望尽天涯路」,写登高望远、望尽天涯,是宋词写离愁的名篇;姜夔《霓裳中序第一》则以「亭皋正望极。乱落江莲归未得」「人何在,一帘淡月,仿佛照颜色」写亭皋望极、人何在。两词同写秋夜怀人、望尽天涯:一写独上高楼望尽天涯路、以高楼写望,一写亭皋正望极人何在、以亭皋写望;一为晏殊之温润、一为姜夔之清空,并读正可见宋词写「望尽天涯」的两种笔法,皆于登高望极之中见怀人之情。

虞美人·春花秋月何时了 Yumeiren (To the Tune 'Lord Yu'): 'When will the spring flowers and autumn moon end?' 李煜 · 同写故人难寻、愁如春水,一写问君能有几多愁恰似一江春水向东流、一写动庾信清愁似织,皆于愁水之中见故人之思 Both write sorrow for a lost person — one as an endless river, one as woven damask

Li Yu's 'I ask you how much sorrow can there be? Just like a whole river of spring water flowing east' makes grief an endless river, the most famous sorrow-line in Chinese poetry. Jiang Kui writes 'Yu Xin's sorrow, woven like damask, stirs within me' — grief is not a river but fabric woven tight, fine and suffocating. One is a captive king's blood-tears, the other a wanderer's muffled sigh; one writes sorrow's flood, the other its texture. Read together, they show two ways of measuring grief — by its volume and by its density.

李煜《虞美人·春花秋月何时了》「问君能有几多愁?恰似一江春水向东流」,写愁如春水,是写愁的千古名篇;姜夔《霓裳中序第一》则以「动庾信、清愁似织」「坠红无信息。漫暗水,涓涓溜碧」写清愁似织、坠红无信。两词同写故人难寻、愁如春水:一写问君能有几多愁恰似一江春水向东流、以春水写愁,一写动庾信清愁似织、以织写愁;一为帝王之血泪、一为姜夔之清空,并读正可见词写「故人之愁」的两种情致,皆于愁水之中见故人之思。