All poems

宋 Song · 词 Ci lyric

踏莎行

Treading on the Grass: The Swallows, Light and Airy

姜夔

Jiang Kui

宋词Theme 清空Theme 爱情Love 梦Theme 离魂Theme

燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软。
分明又向华胥见。
夜长争得薄情知,春初早被相思染。
别后书辞,别时针线。
离魂暗逐郎行远。
淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管。

The swallows, light and airy, the orioles, delicate and soft,
Clearly, again, seen, in, the dream of Huaxu.
The night, long, how, would, the heartless, know,
The spring, early, already, stained, by, the lovesickness.
After, the parting, the letters,
At, the parting, the needle and the thread,
The separated soul, secretly, chasing, the gentleman's, journey, far.
The bright moon of the Huainan, cold, a thousand, mountains,
The dim, returning, going, no, one, caring.
Listen

Meaning

A lyric of the dream and the lovesickness, written by Jiang Kui. The swallows light and airy with the orioles delicate and soft, clearly again seen in the dream of Huaxu — the dream of the opening. The night long with the heartless not knowing, the spring early with the lovesickness staining — the lovesickness of the poet. After the parting the letters, at the parting the needle and the thread, the separated soul secretly chasing the gentleman's journey far — the chasing of the soul. And the close's the bright moon of the Huainan cold a thousand mountains, the dim returning going no one caring — the close's returning. The lyric is the dream and the lovesickness: the dream, the chasing, and the close's bright moon.

那如燕如莺的她,身姿轻盈,语声娇软。清清楚楚地,又一次在梦中与她相见。别后她寄来的书信,别时她缝制的衣衫针线。淮南的明月照着寒冷的千万山峰,她的离魂在幽暗中归去,再无人照管。

Appreciation

[Plain Paraphrase] The swallows, light and airy, the orioles, delicate and soft, clearly, again, seen, in, the dream of Huaxu. The night, long, how, would, the heartless, know, the spring, early, already, stained, by, the lovesickness. After, the parting, the letters, at, the parting, the needle and the thread, the separated soul, secretly, chasing, the gentleman's, journey, far. The bright moon of the Huainan, cold, a thousand, mountains, the dim, returning, going, no, one, caring. [Structure and Thought] The lyric moves from the dream of the swallows and the orioles, through the lovesickness of the night and the spring, to the close's chasing of the soul and the bright moon of the Huainan. [Key Technique] The lyric's art is the close of the moon: the separated soul chasing the journey far, and the close's bright moon cold a thousand mountains — the lovesickness gathered in the chasing and the close's moon. [Emotional Tone] Soft, lovesick, and cold: the lyric is the dream, the chasing and the close's bright moon.

【白话串讲】 姜夔写踏莎行:“燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软。分明又向华胥见”——他在梦里见到情人。“夜长争得薄情知,春初早被相思染”——“离魂暗逐郎行远”——“淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管”——他写相思与离别。 【意象与手法】梦、忆、魂、境四层虚实相生。「燕燕轻盈」以禽名昵称恋人;「离魂」化用倩女离魂;「冷千山」以一字贯通天地。 【情感与主旨】以清空之笔写刻骨之恋,将儿女私情升格为天地孤寒,是白石骚雅情词的最高代表。 【名句点睛】「淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管」以景结情,冷境中见孤绝;「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软」叠字呼人,亲昵中含典故厚度。

Background

Jiang Kui (c. 1155-1221), the master of the ci of the Southern Song, wrote this 'Treading on the Grass' of the dream and the lovesickness — the longing of the parting. The swallows light and airy with the dream of Huaxu, the night long with the lovesickness staining, and the close's separated soul chasing with the bright moon of the Huainan — the lyric gathers the lovesickness of the poet, the cold of the scene. The lyric is one of the famous works of the master's lyrics of the lovesickness.

姜夔《踏莎行》是其合肥情事中最为凄婉的一篇,须结合白石生平情史方能解会。白石少年客居合肥(宋属淮南西路),与一位善弹琵琶的歌妓相恋,情好甚笃,后迫于生计与行迹不得不别,此女后音问渐疏,白石终身眷念,屡见于《凄凉犯》《淡黄柳》《浣溪沙》诸作。此词即写别后梦遇与离魂之思,约作于中年飘零、重经淮南之际。词题中虽未明标地望,而「淮南皓月冷千山」已暗点合肥所在。合肥恋人是白石词中反复出现的原型,今人夏承焘《姜白石词编年笺校》于此考证最详,以为白石二三十岁间居合肥,与琵琶妓姊妹相恋,其事隐约见于多处词序与句眼,白石晚年仍不能忘。此词上片写梦中重见伊人「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软」,下片写别后针线、离魂逐远,结以「淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管」的冷境,将一己相思扩为天地间的孤寒。南宋江湖词人多写艳情,而白石能以清空之笔写刻骨之恋,使儿女之情兼具高格,正见其「骚雅」之实——所谓雅,不在避艳,而在情之深、境之远,在于将私情淬炼为可共感的宇宙孤寒。

Art

The lyric's art is the art of the lovesickness. The dream opens: the swallows, light and airy, the orioles, delicate and soft — the light and the delicate; clearly, again, seen, in, the dream of Huaxu — the dream of Huaxu. The lovesickness follows: the night, long, how, would, the heartless, know — the heartless of the night; the spring, early, already, stained, by, the lovesickness — the staining of the lovesickness; after, the parting, the letters — the letters of the parting; at, the parting, the needle and the thread — the needle and the thread; the separated soul, secretly, chasing, the gentleman's, journey, far — the chasing of the separated soul. And the close gathers the moon: the bright moon of the Huainan, cold, a thousand, mountains — the cold of the bright moon; the dim, returning, going, no, one, caring — the returning of the dim — the dream, the chasing and the close's moon, gathered in the lyric.

此词艺术之妙,首在「梦—醒—魂」三层虚实相生的结构,将相思写得幽渺而深切。起拍「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软」,以叠字「燕燕」「莺莺」呼人,既状其体态之轻、语声之软,又暗用古诗「燕燕于飞」与唐人传奇崔莺莺之双关,使称呼自带柔情与典故双重厚度。「分明又向华胥见」点出是梦,「分明」二字写梦境之真切、「又」字写梦遇之频仍,将「梦中见」写得如同实境,是「以梦为实」的痴笔。过片「别后书辞,别时针线」,以「别后」「别时」对举,由梦转忆,针线、书辞皆实物,最足以触动离人肝肠——「针线」暗用孟郊「临行密密缝」之典,写伊人为己制衣的深情。下片「离魂暗逐郎行远」化用唐人传奇《离魂记》倩女离魂事,将「魂追郎」的奇想写得幽冷。「淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管」以景结,皓月千山皆「冷」,离魂「无人管」三字收束全篇的孤绝。全词由声(莺燕)入梦(华胥)入物(针线)入魂(离魂)入境(冷千山),层层递深,清空之中血泪暗涌,是白石以结构之巧写情之挚的范例。

Allusions

'The dream of Huaxu' (Hua xu) is the dream of Huaxu — the dream of the Yellow Emperor, the dream of the meeting; 'the needle and the thread' (zhen xian) are the needle and the thread — the sewing of the parting, the token of the lovesickness; 'the Huainan' (Huai nan) is the Huainan — the region of the south of the Huai, the bright moon of the close.

此词用典幽微而情深,最要者有二:一为「华胥」,一为「离魂」。《列子·黄帝》载黄帝昼寝,梦游华胥氏之国,「其国无帅长,自然而已」,后遂以「华胥」代指梦境(如「一枕华胥」)。白石「分明又向华胥见」,正以华胥指与恋人重逢之梦,既典雅又切合「梦」字,且华胥之「无为自然」反衬出梦中之欢的短暂与醒后之痛。二为「离魂」,事出唐陈玄祐传奇《离魂记》:张倩女因恋王宙,魂魄离体追舟相从,后居家生子,及见本体二魂复合。白石「离魂暗逐郎行远」化用此典,写恋人之魂暗中追随自己远行,与倩女离魂同一痴绝,而「暗」字更添幽秘凄楚。又起句「燕燕」「莺莺」本为禽鸟之名而转为女子昵称:燕燕出《诗经·燕燕》「燕燕于飞」,后世以喻所爱;莺莺则因元稹《会真记》、白居易诗而固定为娇美女子之代称,白石叠用之,呼其恋人如唤双禽,亲昵无间。「针线」一语,上承孟郊《游子吟》「临行密密缝,意恐迟迟归」,下接贺铸「谁复挑灯夜补衣」,皆是古典诗歌中以衣物针线寄相思的常典。白石熔数典于一炉,而情真景切,不落堆垛,足见其使事之化境。

Commentary

This lyric is one of the famous works of Jiang Kui's lyrics of the lovesickness, quoted for the softness of its dream and the coldness of its close. The swallows light and airy, and the bright moon of the Huainan cold a thousand mountains, are among the admired passages of the master's lyrics. Critics praise the lyric's coldness: the dream gathered in the chasing, to the close's moon.

姜夔《踏莎行》在白石情词中别具一种幽艳深哀,历来论者多挹其「清空」中之「沉挚」。清人陈廷焯《白雨斋词话》虽主沉郁,亦许白石情词「一往情深,令人低回不已」,此词「淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管」即其所谓沉郁处。郑文焯批白石词,于此结拍尤为激赏,以为「冷千山」三字「是何等境界,只一笔便写尽天涯孤客」。近人夏承焘《姜白石词编年笺校》考定此词为合肥情事所作,并疏「淮南」即合肥、恋人为琵琶妓,使千载下读者得窥白石隐秘情史之全貌,功不可没。唐圭璋《唐宋词简释》重其结构:「上片写梦中之欢,下片写别后之忆与离魂之逐,结以冷境,凄婉欲绝。」王国维《人间词话》论「隔」与「不隔」,若以此词衡之,「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软」虽用代字而情真景切,不当以「隔」论。综之,诸家共识在:此词以清空之笔写刻骨之恋,梦、忆、魂、境四层交织,结于「无人管」三字,将儿女相思升格为天地孤寒,是白石「骚雅」情词的最高代表之一,亦宋词写梦写魂的奇绝之篇,与苏轼悼亡之梦可称并峙。

Prosody

Form A short ci lyric of the lovesickness (ci diao)词·踏莎行(双调五十八字,上下片各五句)
Rhyme The lyric rhymes on the level and the oblique of the group — the cadence of the short ci that carries the soft lovesickness.押仄声韵,上片软、见、染,下片线、远、管,皆仄声,上去通押,属词韵第七、十四部相通
Tone pattern The cadence is that of the lovesickness: the level opening with the dream, the turning with the chasing, and the close's fall with the moon cold over the mountains.仄韵体,上下片句式皆为四、四、七、七、四,第三、四句多为对仗或流水
Reading note The lyric's sound matches its coldness: the cadences of the short ci, and the close — 'ming ming gui qu wu ren guan' — falls with the no one caring, the sound of the returning soul of the lovesick poet.《踏莎行》为北宋盛行的小令,双调五十八字,上下片各五句、三仄韵,句式整齐为四、四、七、七、四。此词上片「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软。分明又向华胥见。夜长争得薄情知,春初早被相思染」,于第二句「软」、第三句「见」、第五句「染」押韵;下片「别后书辞,别时针线。离魂暗逐郎行远。淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管」,于第二句「线」、第三句「远」、第五句「管」押韵,共六仄韵,一韵到底。其韵字软、染、远、管为《词林正韵》上声(銑、琰、旱、缓诸部),见、线为去声(霰、线部),北宋词人于令词中每以上去通押,此词即其例,声情凄婉而带幽咽,正与梦忆离魂之哀相称。句式上,上下片首二句皆四字对起(「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软」「别后书辞,别时针线」),整练如骈;中二句七字作流水或设问(「夜长争得薄情知,春初早被相思染」),疏宕有致;末句四字(「冥冥归去无人管」)以短收长,如一声叹息。平仄依踏莎行定格,白石于仄韵中运清空之气,使整饬的句式不流于板滞,足见其小令声律之精。

Line by line

燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软。

Swallow-swallow, light and graceful; oriole-oriole, tender and soft.

那如燕如莺的她,身姿轻盈,语声娇软。

Like a swallow she is light and graceful; like an oriole, tender and soft.

此起拍以两组叠字「燕燕」「莺莺」呼其恋人,是全词最秾丽亦最亲昵之笔。「燕燕」本出《诗经·燕燕》「燕燕于飞」,后世用以喻所爱或侍妾;「莺莺」则因元稹《会真记》、白居易诗而固定为娇美女子代称。白石叠用二禽之名以唤伊人,妙在既状其体态之轻盈如燕、语声之娇软如莺,又使称呼天然带有双关的柔情与文化的厚度——仿佛他不敢直呼其名,只得以禽鸟之昵称来表达那份怜惜。从结构看,这八字是「梦中见」的特写镜头,先于「分明又向华胥见」点出梦境,先绘其人、后醒其境,便把梦写得如在目前。更值得注意的是,燕莺皆为春禽,暗合词中「春初早被相思染」的节候,禽鸟的成双与人的孤栖恰成反衬。「轻盈」「娇软」四字皆从触觉与听觉落笔,不写眉眼而全写风神,正合白石「清空」中偶一放笔写艳的本领,秾而不俗,丽而能雅,为下片「别后」「离魂」的哀苦蓄足了暖色。

This line writes the beloved's grace in doubled bird names, the poem's opening. The words swallow-swallow write her lightness, oriole-oriole her softness, using the bird names for her bearing. The line writes to the full the feeling of her light and tender presence. Rising through the bird names, the elegant ci's fine opening.

分明又向华胥见。

Plainly once more I have seen her in the dream of Huaxu.

清清楚楚地,又一次在梦中与她相见。

Plainly, in a dream of Huaxu, I saw her again.

「分明又向华胥见」七字,是全词由实景转入梦境的关键,炼字之妙在「分明」与「又」二字。「分明」写梦境之清晰真切,非模糊惝恍之梦,而是历历在目、声容宛然,足见词人思念之深、入梦之真;这一个词便把「梦」写得有了实感,是「以梦为实」的痴人笔墨。「又」字则点出梦遇之频仍——不是偶一梦见,而是屡屡入梦,则醒后之孤寂可知,相思之缠绵亦可想。华胥用《列子》黄帝梦游之典,代指梦境,典雅而贴切,且华胥之国「无帅长、自然而已」的乌托邦意味,反衬出现实中「别后」「离魂」的残缺与痛楚——梦中越圆满,醒后越凄凉。此句承上(燕燕莺莺之呼)启下(夜长争得薄情知之怨),在章法上是「梦」与「怨」的转关:既已梦中相见,便自然生出「夜长争得薄情知」的痴问。七字短句,于轻婉中藏深沉,是白石小令「疏处见密」的典型。

This line writes plainly, in a dream of Huaxu, I saw her again, the dream's visitation. The words plainly write the vividness, Huaxu the dreamland of the Yellow Emperor. The line writes to the full the feeling of the dream meeting. Writing the dream through Huaxu, the ci's fine stroke.

别后书辞,别时针线。

The letters written after parting, the stitches sewn at the parting.

别后她寄来的书信,别时她缝制的衣衫针线。

The letters sent after the parting, the stitches done at the hour of parting.

「别后书辞,别时针线」十字,由梦境跌回现实,是化奇为平、化梦为忆的沉痛转捩。「别后」与「别时」对举,时间上拉开为一前一后,空间上则由虚幻之梦落于实在之物——书辞是别后音书,针线是别时衣物,二者皆是可以握在手中的实物,最足以触动离人肝肠。「针线」暗用孟郊《游子吟》「临行密密缝,意恐迟迟归」与贺铸「谁复挑灯夜补衣」之典,写伊人临别为自己密密缝衣的深情,那衣上针脚便是爱的痕迹,词人展物思人,其哀倍深。这两句看似平淡叙事,实则以「物」载「情」,是以实写虚的高手笔法:不直接说如何相思,而只拈出书辞、针线二物,其眷念已在不言中。且「书辞」与「针线」一属精神交流、一属身体余温,由远及近、由文及物,层次井然。此十字为下片「离魂暗逐郎行远」的奇想作了最稳妥的铺垫——正因为别时情深、别后书断,才会有魂魄追随之幻,梦忆与离魂至此浑然一体。

This line writes the letters sent after the parting, the stitches done at the hour of parting, the two keepsakes. The words after-parting letters write the written words, parting-time stitches the handiwork. The line writes to the full the feeling of the letters and the stitches. Writing feeling through the keepsakes, the ci's fine stroke.

淮南皓月冷千山,冥冥归去无人管。

The bright moon of the Huainan, cold, a thousand, mountains, the dim, returning, going, no, one, caring.

淮南的明月照着寒冷的千万山峰,她的离魂在幽暗中归去,再无人照管。

Over Huainan the bright moon chills a thousand hills; in the deep dark she returns, unheeded.

此结拍为全词之眼,亦宋词写孤寒的绝唱。「淮南」点明地望(合肥宋属淮南西路),将一己相思置于辽阔的地理空间;「皓月冷千山」五字,以「冷」字炼境,使明月与千山皆罩上一层凄清的寒意——月本无声,山本无言,一经「冷」字点染,便成有情之景,仿佛天地也为这段无望之情而寒。下句「冥冥归去无人管」写离魂在幽暗中独自归去,「冥冥」状幽暗不明,「无人管」三字收束全篇,是全词最摧折处:她的魂魄追随我远行,如今归去却无人看顾,当年的「别时针线」之爱,如今连魂魄都流落无依。这三字既是怜伊,更是自怜——词人自己不也是「无人管」的江湖布衣么?物我至此合一。以景语结,不著一「悲」字而悲不可抑,正是白石「句中有余味」的极致,亦将儿女私情升格为天地同悲的孤寒之境,清空至此,已近沉郁。

The closing line writes over Huainan the bright moon chills a thousand hills; in the deep dark she returns, unheeded, the dream's departure. The words bright moon chills write the cold, the deep dark returning the vanishing. The line writes to the full the feeling of the moonlit hills and the unheeded return. Writing the departure through the moonlit hills, the ci's eye-dotting close.

Study

Word focus

华胥 'The dream of Huaxu' — the dream of the meeting, the dream of the Yellow Emperor. 「分明又向华胥见」之「华胥」,是此词点明梦境的典眼,其妙在典雅与贴切兼得。「华胥」出自《列子·黄帝》所载黄帝梦游华胥氏之国,其国「无帅长,自然而已」「不知亲己,不知疏物」,后遂成为「梦境」的雅称(如「一枕华胥」「华胥梦」)。白石于此不直说「梦中见」,而说「向华胥见」,既免去「梦」字的直露,又以典故为梦境蒙上一层远古、缥缈、乌托邦的色彩,与词中「燕燕轻盈」的温柔恰成文本的雅致。更深层者,华胥之国「自然无碍」的圆满,正反衬出现实中「别后」「离魂」的残缺与痛楚——梦越是华胥般的美好,醒后越是凄凉,这种以典衬反差的手法,使「华胥」二字承担了结构与情感双重功能。若易「华胥」为「梦」字,虽意更显,却失却了清空骚雅的韵味与古今叠映的厚度;唯「华胥」能于七字中藏一部子书、一段神话,是白石「骚雅」用典「化熟为雅」的范例,亦见宋词以学问为词之一端。
冷千山 A key expression in the poem. Read it as an image, mood, or grammar point in context. 「淮南皓月冷千山」之「冷千山」三字,是结拍炼境的诗眼,其妙在以一字「冷」贯通天地。「冷」本属触觉,词人却用以形容「千山」,使视觉的群山陡生寒意,这是通感式的炼字——月光本清凉,山色本幽寂,一经「冷」字点化,物象便有了词人的体温与心境,仿佛天地也为这段无望之情而寒颤。值得玩味的是,「冷」字置于「千山」之前,形成「冷+空间巨物」的张力:千山广漠,却因「冷」而显得空寂无人、不可亲近,恰似词人孤栖江湖、四顾无依的处境。这与李白「床前明月光」的清、苏轼「千里共婵娟」的旷都不同,白石之月是「冷」的、是「无人管」的,带着布衣词人的寒士气质。三个字收束了上片的梦暖、下片的魂追,将全词的暖色一笔扫空,归于天地孤寒。若易「冷」为「照」「满」「碧」,则失其骨力与凄心;唯「冷」字能于景语中藏血泪,是清空词「不著一字、尽得风流」的最高体现。
燕燕 A key expression in the poem. Read it as an image, mood, or grammar point in context. 起句「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软」之「燕燕」,是白石以禽名唤恋人的昵称密码,炼字之妙在双关与亲昵兼到。「燕燕」一词,其源甚古:《诗经·邶风·燕燕》「燕燕于飞,差池其羽」,原是送别诗之祖,后世遂以「燕燕」代指所爱、侍妾或轻盈之女子;至乐府、唐人诗,「燕」更成春情与娇小的固定能指。白石叠用「燕燕」「莺莺」二禽以呼伊人,妙在既写出她体态之轻盈如燕、语声之娇软如莺,又使这一称呼天然携带《诗经》的典雅与传奇的柔情,仿佛词人怜惜太过,不敢直呼其名,只得以双禽之昵称吐露心曲。更为精微的是,「燕燕」的叠字本身便有咿呀亲昵的音节效果,读来如唤如抚,与下句「莺莺」构成声韵上的回环。二禽皆为春鸟、皆成双,暗合「春初」节候,也反衬出人间的孤栖。一个看似寻常的叠字,却把《诗经》经典、唐人传奇、春禽物候与一己痴情熔铸为一,是白石「骚雅」于至浅处见至深的典型笔法。

Related Reading

江城子·乙卯正月二十日夜记梦 Riverside Town: Dreaming of My Wife on the Twentieth Night of the First Month 苏轼 · 同写梦遇所爱、醒后凄凉,一悼亡一忆别,梦笔双绝 Related reading

Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.

苏轼《江城子》「夜来幽梦忽还乡。小轩窗,正梳妆。相顾无言,惟有泪千行……料得年年肠断处,明月夜,短松冈」,写梦遇亡妻,与此首白石《踏莎行》写梦遇恋人,同一「梦中相见—醒后断肠」的抒情结构。苏词以「小轩窗,正梳妆」的白描写亡妻,白石以「燕燕轻盈,莺莺娇软」的叠字写恋人,皆于梦中见其声容;苏词结于「明月夜,短松冈」的实景之悲,白石结于「淮南皓月冷千山」的冷境之孤,皆以月与地写无尽之哀。差异在:苏词之梦温暖而痛在死别,白石之梦缥缈而痛在生离;苏词旷达中见沉痛,白石清空里藏沉挚。二词并读,可见宋人写「梦」的两座高峰——一以豪放之笔写至情,一以清空之笔写至恋,同将儿女私情升格为宇宙级的孤寒与思念,是词史上「记梦」双璧。

淡黄柳·空城晓角 淡黄柳·空城晓角 姜夔 · 同作者、同合肥情事,一写春城羁思一写梦魂离苦 Related reading

Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.

白石《淡黄柳》有序云「客居合肥南城赤阑桥之西……因度此阕,以纾客怀」,明言为合肥羁旅与情思而作,与此首《踏莎行》同出合肥情事之一源。二词相较:《淡黄柳》写「空城晓角,吹入垂杨陌」的客中春寒与「怕梨花落尽成秋色」的迟暮之惧,是清醒时的羁愁;《踏莎行》写「燕燕轻盈」的梦遇与「离魂暗逐」的幻思,是睡梦中的痴绝。一醒一梦,一城一魂,恰见白石合肥之恋在昼与夜、实与幻中的两种回响。其共通处在皆以「清空」笔法写「沉挚」之情,皆于结处归于一冷境(一为「岑寂」,一为「冷千山」)。比较二作,可拼合出白石合肥情事的完整心理图景:白日则客怀岑寂,夜梦则离魂相逐,而「淮南」「赤阑桥」的地理坐标,则将其私情牢牢钉在合肥这片土地上,使艳情获得了坚实的时空根基。

凄凉犯·绿杨巷陌 凄凉犯·绿杨巷陌 姜夔 · 同作者、同合肥秋思,一写秋声一写春梦,节候互补而情脉一贯 Related reading

Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.

白石《凄凉犯》有序「合肥巷陌皆种柳,秋风夕起,骚骚然」,「予徘徊不已,因以为词」,写合肥秋日之凄凉与对伊人之思念,与此首《踏莎行》同为合肥情事,而节候一秋一春。《凄凉犯》以「绿杨巷陌秋风起」「马嘶渐远,人归甚处」写秋声中的孤独,《踏莎行》以「春初早被相思染」「淮南皓月冷千山」写春梦里的离魂,秋之骚骚与春之冥冥,共织成白石对合肥恋人全年无已的眷念。二词并读,可见白石情词「因时因地」的写实性:合肥的柳(春)与合肥的柳(秋)是同一批柳,而恋人始终缺席,唯余词人的魂魄在「冷千山」与「绿杨巷陌」间往返。这种将私情系于特定城市风物的写法,开了南宋「以地写情」的先声,亦是白石「骚雅」不同于五代艳词空洞酬唱的关键——他的艳,是有根、有地、有史的。