唐 Tang · 诗 Poem
横江词六首·其一
Hengjiang Song, No. 1
人道横江好,侬道横江恶。
一风三日吹倒山,白浪高于瓦官阁。
I say the Heng River is rough.
One wind for three days can blow down mountains,
White waves rise above Waguan Tower.
Meaning
Others praise the Hengjiang as calm and pleasant, but the speaker insists it is treacherous. A single wind lasts three days and can blow down mountains; the white waves are even higher than Waguan Pavilion in Jinling.
别人说横江风平浪好,我说横江风恶浪险。一阵风连刮三日能吹倒山岳,白色的浪头高过了瓦官阁。
Appreciation
This poem should be read alongside Li Bai's other five 'Hengjiang Ci' and 'Shu Dao Nan' as works that use hyperbole to convey danger. The opening sets 'others say' against 'I say' in a folk-song dialogue, rustic and vivid, continuing the Wu-song flavor of 'Changgan Xing'. The last two lines employ extreme exaggeration—'blow down mountains' and 'higher than Waguan Pavilion'—to depict the fury of wind and waves with extraordinary imagination, pioneering a bold style in landscape poetry. Compare with Cen Shen's 'White Snow Song' or Du Fu's 'Climbing High' to distinguish between the 'grotesque' and the 'restrained' currents in High Tang quatrains and appreciate Li Bai's unique romantic power.
【白话串讲】 “人道横江好,侬道横江恶”——李白写横江词:人家说横江好,我说横江凶险。“一风三日吹倒山,白浪高于瓦官阁”——风能吹倒山,白浪高过瓦官阁。李白写风浪,写得夸张。 【意象与手法】 开篇“人道横江好,侬道横江恶”以“人道”与“侬道”对举,民歌式对话立骨;后二句“一风三日吹倒山,白浪高于瓦官阁”以极度夸饰状风浪之恶。想像奇肆,开后来豪放写景之先声。 【情感与主旨】 以夸张写险峻之作,化清商民歌入七绝而自成豪宕,与《蜀道难》同属以夸张写险,可与岑参《白雪歌》的夸饰、杜甫《登高》写风的沉郁对照,辨盛唐七绝中“险怪”与“平正”两途。 【名句点睛】 常考“一风三日吹倒山,白浪高于瓦官阁”以吹倒山写风浪之恶;“人道横江好,侬道横江恶”以民歌对话写横江之险。
Background
Hengjiang, located southeast of present-day He County in Anhui, was a ferry crossing on the Yangtze River, historically notorious for its treacherous winds and waves. Li Bai traveled frequently between Jinling, Dangtu, and Liyang, and Hengjiang Ford was a necessary crossing. This is the first of the six 'Hengjiang Ci', likely written during the Tianbao era when the poet roamed the south and journeyed between Jinling and other places. By then Li Bai had already made his name in the capital but had not yet found an opportunity to realize his ambitions. He often drifted along rivers, expressing his feelings through the boat and the waves. His journey across Hengjiang was itself intended to cross the river, but the fury of the wind and waves exceeded all expectation; thus, in a folk-song tone, he wrote this series that seems playful yet carries deep heroic sentiment. The first line, beginning with 'people say', is a common dialogue form in Jiangnan Wu songs; 'nong' (I) is a Wu dialect pronoun, showing the poem's roots in local speech and yuefu folk tradition. Li Bai loved imitating folk songs; he had already displayed Wu-region sentiment in 'Changgan Xing' and 'Midnight Wu Songs'. This Hengjiang poem uses rustic language to describe perilous scenery, realizing his principle of 'pure water yielding lotus—natural beauty without carving' in seven-character quatrains. To read this poem properly, one must place it back into the context of the poet's middle-age wanderings, high-spirited yet unfulfilled, to appreciate the romantic boldness behind the exaggeration of 'blowing down mountains' and 'higher than Waguan Pavilion'.
横江,在今安徽和县东南,为长江津渡,自古风涛险恶。李白一生多次往来于金陵、当涂、历阳之间,横江浦是他横渡长江的必经之地。此首为《横江词六首》的第一首,约作于天宝年间诗人漫游江南、往来金陵之时。彼时李白已名动京师,却未得真正施展抱负的机缘,常泛游江湖,于舟楫风浪之中借景抒怀。横江之行本为渡江,风浪之恶却远超意料,诗人遂以民歌口吻,写下这组看似游戏、实含豪情的篇章。首句以「人道」起笔,乃是江南吴歌常见的对话体;「侬」为吴语自称,足见此诗扎根于当地方言与乐府民歌的传统。李白素爱拟作民间歌曲,此前《长干行》《子夜吴歌》已显吴地情调,此组横江词更以俚俗之语写惊险之景,正是他「清水出芙蓉,天然去雕饰」主张在七言绝句里的落实。读此诗,须把它放回诗人壮年漫游、意气风发而壮志未酬的语境里,方能体会「吹倒山」「高于瓦官阁」的夸饰背后,那一份睥睨风浪、傲视天地的浪漫气魄。
Art
The most striking artistic feature of this poem is its opening with a folk-song contrast that establishes the backbone. The first two lines, 'People say the Heng River is fine, / I say the Heng River is rough,' set two subjects and two judgments against each other, like a ferryman's dialogue, vivid and colloquial, devoid of the stale air of literati poetry. This introduction of dialogue gives the entire poem a dramatic quality: the calm that others praise is seen as a raging evil by the speaker. The word 'nong' positions the speaker as a Jiangnan boatman who has experienced the waves, and the tone is exact, inheriting the Southern Dynasty Qing Shang songs. The last two lines suddenly turn to extreme hyperbolic description. 'One wind for three days can blow down mountains' and 'white waves rise above Waguan Tower' are both irrational amplifications. Li Bai's romantic force lies precisely here: he does not depict with fine brushwork but lets imagination transcend reality, pushing the danger of Hengjiang to its extreme with almost fairy-tale exaggeration. Waguan Pavilion, a famed building in Jiankang, already stands on high ground; if waves rise above its eaves, their height is clear. This method of using the unreal to express the real and exaggeration instead of description opened the 'bold and startling' path in High Tang quatrains, entirely different from Wang Wei's placidness or Wang Changling's mellow completeness. The whole poem, with its first two lines of dialogue and last two of hyperbolic scene, is extremely simple in structure yet full of tension. The language is entirely colloquial, unpolished, yet magnificent because of the fantastical imagination. This is the greatest charm of Li Bai's quatrains: it seems casually written, yet fuses the vitality of folk songs with the grandeur of High Tang.
此诗最醒目的艺术特色,是以民歌对举开篇,立一篇之骨。前二句「人道横江好,侬道横江恶」,以「人道」与「侬道」两个主体、两种判断相对,如舟中乡人问答,鲜活俚俗,毫无文人诗的酸腐气。这种对话体的引入,使全诗自带戏剧性:别人赞叹的风平浪静,在「我」眼中却是恶浪滔天。一个「侬」字,把说话人定位为亲历风浪的江南舟子,口吻毕肖,与南朝清商曲辞一脉相承。后二句陡然转向极度夸饰的写景。「一风三日吹倒山,白浪高于瓦官阁」,以「吹倒山」写风之狂暴,以「高于瓦官阁」写浪之高昂,皆是不合常理的放大。李白的浪漫笔力正在于此:他不以工笔摹状,而以想象凌跨真实,用近乎童话般的夸张,把横江的险恶推到极致。瓦官阁为建康名刹,地势本高,浪头高过阁檐,则其势可知。这种以虚写实、以夸饰代铺叙的手法,开了盛唐七绝「豪宕奇肆」一路,与王维的冲淡、王昌龄的浑成截然异趣。全诗四句,前二叙事对话,后二夸饰写景,结构极简却张力十足。语言全用口语,不事雕琢,却因想象奇绝而气象宏阔。这正是李白七绝最迷人的地方:看似随手写来,实则把乐府民歌的鲜活与盛唐气象的豪宕熔于一炉。
Allusions
This poem uses very few classical allusions, but it is full of traces of folk songs; the most notable are the folk tradition behind the word 'nong' and the geographical reference of Waguan Pavilion. 'Nong' appears in Six Dynasties Wu songs as a self-designation of the speaker, often a woman, such as 'I am the North Star, unchanged for a thousand years' in 'Midnight Songs'—exactly the tone of Jiangnan boys and girls. By using 'nong', Li Bai sets the poem's voice firmly in Wu folk culture, connecting 'Hengjiang Ci' with the Wu-song flavor of 'Changgan Xing' ('Living in Changgan Village, two young children without suspicion'), a conscious inheritance of the Southern Dynasty Qing Shang music. Waguan Pavilion is a different matter. The pavilion, in present-day Nanjing, was first built in the Eastern Jin and was a famous Jiangnan monastery. Li Bai's other verses in the series, such as 'Sea gods come and evil winds turn back; waves strike the stone walls of Tianmen,' show his familiarity with the geography. Using Waguan Pavilion as a measure of height gives the hyperbole a concrete anchor, making 'white waves higher than Waguan Pavilion' both a real reference and a flight of imagination. This technique of grounding exaggeration in something visible before the eyes is the same as in 'Shu Dao Nan' (peaks within a foot of heaven): first set a familiar object, then push it beyond reason. Moreover, the very form of the poem, imitating folk songs, is itself a kind of allusion—it alludes to the Yuefu tradition of collecting songs, dialogue, and persona. Li Bai borrows not the classics but the 'classic' of folk song, which sets this poem apart among High Tang quatrains. Later poets such as Su Shi and Yang Wanli wrote of wind and waves with clever phrases, yet rarely matched the rough vitality born from Wu song soil.
此诗用典极少,却处处可见乐府民歌的影子,最值得注意的是「侬」字的民歌传统与瓦官阁的地理指涉。「侬」在六朝吴歌中是女子或说话人的自称,如《子夜歌》「侬作北辰星,千年无转移」,正是江南儿女的口吻。李白取「侬」入诗,等于把整首诗的发声位置安放在吴地民间,使「横江词」与《长干行》「同居长干里,两小无嫌猜」的吴歌风味相呼应,是对南朝清商乐「侬」语的自觉继承。瓦官阁则当另说。阁在今南京,始建于东晋,为江南名刹,李白另有《横江词》「海神来过恶风回,浪打天门石壁开」诸句,可见他对这一带地理熟稔。以瓦官阁为高度标尺,是用实地名胜作夸饰的支点,使「白浪高于瓦官阁」既有真实坐标,又见想象飞腾。这种以眼前实有之物为夸张依据的写法,与《蜀道难》「连峰去天不盈尺」同出一理:先立一个读者熟悉的实体,再把它推过常理的边界。此外,组诗拟民歌而作的体例本身,也是「用典」的一种——它暗用的是《乐府》那一套采风、对话、代言之传统。李白不搬经史典故,而搬民歌之「典」,使此诗在盛唐七绝中独标一格。后世苏轼、杨万里写风浪,虽各有奇语,却少有这种从吴歌土壤里长出来的粗粝生气。
Commentary
Although this poem is short, critiques often appear in broader discussions of Li Bai's seven-character quatrains. The Ming critic Hu Yinglin, in his 'Shisou', remarked that Li Bai's quatrains are 'spoken casually, unintentionally skillful and yet perfectly skillful'—which fits 'Hengjiang Ci' perfectly: the first two lines are like a boatman's dialogue, and the last two are like an exclamation from the mouth, with no trace of carving. In the Qing dynasty, Wang Qi's annotations to the 'Complete Works of Li Bai' clarify the geography of the Hengjiang series, noting that both Hengjiang Ford and Waguan Pavilion are real places, proving that Li Bai's hyperbole is not fabricated but has a basis. Shen Deqian, in 'Tangshi Biecai', praised Li Bai and Wang Changling as masters of the quatrain, saying their language is 'close to everyday speech yet distant in feeling, contained yet implied.' In this poem, the contrast between 'people say' and 'I say' is precisely the 'close language,' while the evil of the wind and waves is revealed only through 'blow down mountains' and 'higher than the pavilion,' leaving ample aftertaste—this is the 'distant feeling.' Wang Shizhen also included this poem in his 'Selected Ten Thousand Tang Quatrains', placing it among works of Jiangnan customs. Modern discussions of Li Bai often emphasize the folk-song spirit in his quatrains. Guo Moruo, in 'Li Bai and Du Fu', enthusiastically praised Li Bai's learning from folk songs; this Hengjiang poem, beginning with 'nong', shows exactly that liveliness. Contemporary readers often pair this poem with 'Shu Dao Nan' as both using hyperbole to describe danger; but one is a long narrative song, the other a seven-character miniature, different in form and atmosphere. Yet the romantic exaggeration and proud backbone shared by both are indeed the constant foundation of Li Bai's life. Among the six poems in the series, this first one establishes the debate between 'good' and 'bad' and the shock of the wind and waves, like the prelude of a piece, setting the stage for the other five.
此诗虽短,历代评点却多见于李白七绝的整体论述中。明人胡应麟《诗薮》论太白七绝,称其「信口而成,无意于工而无不工」,《横江词》正可作证:前二句如舟人问答,后二句如脱口惊叹,全无斧凿痕。清人王琦注《李太白全集》,于横江词一组考明地理,指出横江浦、瓦官阁皆实有之地,足见李白夸张并非向壁虚构,而是有所依凭。沈德潜《唐诗别裁》论七绝,推李白与王昌龄为巨擘,谓其「语近情遥,含吐不露」。以此诗观之,「人道」「侬道」之对举,正是「语近」;而风浪之恶只以「吹倒山」「高于瓦官阁」二语点出,余味留白,正是「情遥」。王士禛《唐人万首绝句选》亦收录此诗,视其入江南风土诸作之林。近人论李,尤重其七绝中的民歌精神。郭沫若《李白与杜甫》盛赞李白向民歌学习,此组横江词以「侬」字发端,正见其活泼。今人读此诗,常把它与《蜀道难》并提,以为同属夸饰写险;实则一为长篇歌行,一为七绝小品,体既不同,气象亦异。然二者共有的浪漫夸张与傲岸气骨,确是李白贯于一生的底色。比较六首组诗,此首居首,立「好恶」之辩与「风浪」之惊,如乐章之引子,为后五首张本。
Prosody
Line by line
人道横江好,
Others say the Hengjiang is fine. The opening introduces a speaker opposite to 'I', setting up a dialogue stage within four lines. In others' eyes, the river is calm and good for boats; this 'good' is a common experience and a deliberately placed 'antagonist.' Li Bai does not directly describe danger; first he presents a universal, safe impression to leave room for the later startling words. This method comes from the dialogue and contrast of folk songs, such as 'Moshang Sang' first describing Luo Fu's beauty, then confirming it through bystanders' words. The word '人道' (people say) is ordinary but shifts the lyric subject from 'I alone speak' to 'people argue with me,' giving the poem dramatic tension. The reader is drawn into a debate about the Hengjiang, waiting for 'my' answer.
别人说横江风平浪好,
Men say the Heng River is good.
开篇以「人道」二字,引入一个与「我」相对的说话者,等于在四句小诗里搭起一座对话的舞台。别人眼中的横江是「好」的,风平浪静,宜于舟楫;这「好」字是常人的经验判断,也是诗人刻意安置的「反方」。李白不正面写险,先让一个普遍的、安全的印象出场,正是为了给后文的惊人之语留出对比的空间。此法源于乐府民歌的设问与对举,如《陌上桑》先言罗敷之美,再借旁观者之口坐实。「人道」二字看似平常,却把抒情主体的位置从「我一个人说」变成「众人与我争辩」,诗歌由此带上戏剧张力。读到这里,读者已被悄悄带进一场关于横江的评价之争,等待「侬」的回答。
The opening introduces, through 'men say', a speaker set against 'I', building a stage of dispute in four short lines. To others the Heng River is 'good' — calm, fit for boats; this 'good' is common experience, the 'opposing side' the poet deliberately places. Li Bai does not write the danger directly first, but lets a safe, general impression appear, leaving room for the startling line to come. The words 'men say' shift the lyric position from 'I alone say' to 'all men argue with me', giving the poem dramatic tension.
侬道横江恶。
'I say the Hengjiang is treacherous.' 'Nong' is a Wu colloquialism for 'I,' from Southern Dynasty Jiangnan folk songs. Using it rather than 'wu' or 'yu' instantly turns the speaker into a local boatman with a Wu accent, vivid in tone. 'E' (bad) directly opposes the previous 'hao' (good), flipping all expectations with one word. The debate is not about the scenery itself but about standpoint and experience—ordinary people only see the ferry's name, while one who has experienced it knows the danger of wind and waves. By adopting 'nong,' Li Bai uses a folk perspective to recount his own experience, turning the literati's fear of crossing into a boatman's blunt complaint. The two words 'hao' and 'e' stand side by side, establishing the poem's conflict and tension, and setting the stage for the exaggerated description of 'bad.'
我说横江风恶浪险。
I say the Heng River is evil.
「侬」是吴语自称,相当于「我」,本出自六朝江南民歌,李白用它而非「吾」「余」,瞬间把发声者变成一位操吴音的当地舟子,口吻鲜活如闻其声。「恶」与上一句的「好」针锋相对,一个字翻转全部预期。值得玩味的是,诗题写「横江」,别人说好,我说恶,这分歧不在风景本身,而在立场与体验——常人只见津渡之名,亲历者方知风涛之险。李白以「侬」自居,其实是借民间视角重述亲身所历,把文人渡江的惊惧化作舟子直白的抱怨。二字相对,「好」「恶」并列,全诗的矛盾与张力在此一句立定,也为后文以夸饰状「恶」埋下伏笔。
'I' is a Wu dialect first-person, from the southern folk song; Li Bai uses it instead of the formal 'I', and the voice becomes a local boatman's, vivid as if heard. 'Evil' answers 'good' word for word, overturning all expectation. The disagreement is not about the scenery itself but about standpoint and experience — common folk see only the crossing's name, those who have crossed know the storm. Li Bai assumes the boatman's voice to retell his own terror, two words setting the poem's conflict.
一风三日吹倒山,
This line describes the fury of the wind with extreme hyperbole. 'One wind for three days' emphasizes its duration, while 'blowing down mountains' is a physical impossibility—yet this irrational stroke pushes the terror of Hengjiang's waves to a mythical dimension. Li Bai's romantic style never fears exaggeration. In 'Shu Dao Nan,' he writes mountains as nearly touching the sky; in 'Qiupu Song,' he compares his sorrow to a long thread. The verb 'blow down' ends with great force, as if one could hear the crash of a mountain. It turns the abstract 'bad' into a thrilling audio-visual picture, allowing readers to move from 'hearing about danger' to 'seeing danger.'
一阵风连刮三日能吹倒山岳,
One wind, three days long, could blow down the mountains.
此句以极度夸张写风之暴烈。「一风三日」言其持续时间之长,「吹倒山」则是违背物理的放大:风再狂,岂能吹倒山岳?然而正是这不合常理的一笔,把横江风浪的恐怖推到神话般的维度。李白的浪漫笔法,向来不怕「过」——过则惊人,过则成奇。《蜀道难》写山高用「连峰去天不盈尺」,《秋浦歌》写愁用「缘愁似个长」,与此同一机杼。更为巧妙的是,「吹倒山」三字以动词收束,力道十足,仿佛真能听见山崩的轰响。它把前句抽象的「恶」字,落实为一幅惊心动魄的视听画面,使读者从「听说险」转入「看见险」。夸饰至此,已非写实,而是写气、写势、写诗人胸中那股不服羁勒的豪气。
This line uses extreme exaggeration for the wind's fury. 'One wind, three days' writes its duration; 'could blow down the mountains' is a physically impossible magnification: wind, however fierce, cannot topple mountains, yet it is exactly this breach that pushes the Heng River's terror to mythic scale. Li Bai's romantic way never fears excess — excess astonishes, excess becomes wonder. It makes the abstract 'evil' above into a heart-stopping sight, the reader moving from 'heard of danger' to 'seeing danger'.
白浪高于瓦官阁。
This line uses a real landmark as the fulcrum of exaggeration, making the height of the waves tangible. Waguan Pavilion is in Jinling and sits on high ground, a familiar landmark for Jiangnan people. Using it as a measure, saying the white waves are higher than its eaves gives a concrete reference, so the hyperbole has an anchor. Li Bai employs this method well: he first takes a shared entity, then pushes it beyond common sense, so the astonishing phrase does not seem empty. Unlike the previous line's auditory shock, this one emphasizes visual height, a horizontal and vertical sweep filling the space with the river's fury. The 'white waves' show color, conveying the density of spray and the breadth of the river, contrasting nature with human architecture. The closing line does not argue or emote; it simply presents the wave higher than the pavilion, leaving the aftertaste in the image—the very skill of High Tang quatrains.
白色的浪头高过了瓦官阁。
White waves rise higher than the Guanguan Pavilion.
此句以实地名胜为夸张的支点,把浪头之高写得确凿可感。瓦官阁在金陵,地势本高,是江南人熟悉的标志性建筑;以它为标尺,说白浪高过阁檐,读者立刻有了具体的高度参照,夸张便有了落点。李白善用此法:先取一个众所共知的实体,再把它推过常理边界,使奇语不流于虚浮。与前句「吹倒山」的听觉震撼不同,此句侧重视觉的高度,一横一纵,风浪之恶被写满整个空间。更妙在「白浪」二字,以颜色状浪,既见浪花之密,又显江面之阔,与「瓦官阁」的人间建筑形成自然与人事的对照。结句收束全篇,不议论、不抒情,只把那高过楼阁的浪头亮给读者看,余味全在画面之外,正是盛唐七绝「语尽意不尽」的本领。
This line takes a real landmark as the fulcrum of exaggeration, making the waves' height concrete. The Guanguan Pavilion in Jinling stands on high ground, a familiar landmark; using it as the measure, saying white waves top the eave, the reader has an immediate height, the exaggeration landing. Unlike the auditory shock of 'blow down the mountains', this line is visual height, horizontal against vertical, the storm filling all space. The closing offers no argument, no feeling, only shows the wave topping the pavilion, the aftertaste beyond the picture.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
二者是李白浪漫夸张的一体两面。《蜀道难》以长篇歌行写蜀道之高峻,「连峰去天不盈尺」「扪参历井仰胁息」,铺张扬厉,惊心动魄;此七绝则以「吹倒山」「高于瓦官阁」二语,于方寸之间收同样的气势。区别在于体:歌行可以反复渲染、层层加码,绝句却须一字千金、戛然而止。正因如此,绝句中的夸饰更见凝练——它不容铺垫,必须一击中的。《蜀道难》让人「听」险,《横江词》让人「看」险。并读二作,可见李白无论长篇短制,浪漫笔力同一源头:以想象凌跨真实,以奇语傲视天地。而绝句之难,正难在把歌行里挥霍的豪气,压缩成四句里的一声惊呼。
长干行 Song of Changgan 李白 · 同取吴地民歌「侬」语与江南风土 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
《长干行》写长干里儿女「同居长干里,两小无嫌猜」,以吴地商妇口吻叙事,是李白拟乐府、学吴歌的力作;此首横江词以「侬道」开篇,同样把发声者安在江南民间,语体毕肖。二者相隔体裁(一为长篇叙事,一为七绝小品),却共享同一套民歌基因:以「侬」自称、以对话立骨、以口语为美。区别在情调——《长干行》缠绵,《横江词》豪宕。将二诗并读,可清晰看见李白如何把六朝清商曲辞的营养,分别转化为儿女之情与江山之险,证明他「清水出芙蓉」的审美,根基正在民间。
白雪歌送武判官归京 Song of White Snow in Farewell to Secretary Wu Returning to the Capital 岑参 · 同写奇景,盛唐夸张写景之并峙 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
岑参此诗写边塞风雪,「忽如一夜春风来,千树万树梨花开」,以奇喻写雪,与李白「吹倒山」「高于瓦官阁」同属盛唐夸张写景一脉。二者皆不以工笔描摹,而借想象的飞跃制造惊叹:岑参把雪比作春花,是视觉的翻新;李白把浪写得高过楼阁,是尺度的突破。不同的是,岑诗夸张中仍带温柔的譬喻与送别的温情,李诗则纯以豪气直撼,不加修饰。并读可见盛唐诗人共有的「以奇为美」取向,以及各人笔下或柔或刚的不同质感。