唐 Tang · 诗 Poem
留别王侍御维
Parting from Censor Wang Wei
寂寂竟何待,朝朝空自归。
欲寻芳草去,惜与故人违。
当路谁相假,知音世所稀。
只应守索寞,还掩故园扉。
Day after day I return empty.
I would seek the fragrant grass and go,
Yet grieve to part from my old friend.
Among those in power, who will help me?
Those who know my heart are rare in the world.
I should only keep to my lonely solitude,
And close again the gate of my native garden.
Meaning
A poem written around the seventeenth year of Kaiyuan (729), when Meng Haoran, having failed the jinshi examination in Chang'an, left the capital and returned home, parting from Wang Wei. 'In silence, what am I waiting for? Day after day I return empty' writes the coldness of being unknown in the capital; 'I would seek the fragrant grass and go, yet grieve to part from my old friend' the conflict of the resolve to return and the grief of parting; 'among those in power, who will help me? Those who know my heart are rare in the world' strikes directly at the fickleness of the world, the only one who knew his heart being Wang Wei; and 'I should only keep to my lonely solitude, and close again the gate of my native garden' the resolve to return and keep to the solitude. Meng Haoran never held office after this and returned to live in reclusion; the poem may be seen as the end of his thought of office and the beginning of his resolve for reclusion.
我这样寂寞地守在这里,究竟还等待什么呢?天天早晨都空自归来,一无所获。想要去寻找芳草归隐而去,却惋惜要与老朋友离别。当权的显贵有谁肯提携帮助我呢?知音的人在世上实在稀少。我只应该守着这份寂寞,回到故园,掩上那扇柴门。
Appreciation
The art of the poem is famed for 'the heart spoken directly, the depth in the plain.' The first couplet, 'in silence, what am I waiting for? Day after day I return empty,' uses two groups of reduplicated words, 'silence' writing the coldness of the mood and 'day after day' the empty waste of the days, 'what am I waiting for' a question and 'return empty' a sigh, writing the full disappointment of lingering in the capital without help, the opening setting the lonely tone of the whole. The second couplet, 'I would seek the fragrant grass and go, yet grieve to part from my old friend,' turns to the conflict of the going and the staying: 'seek the fragrant grass' the resolve to return already fixed, 'grieve to part from my old friend' the parting feeling hard to give up, one 'would' and one 'grieve,' the tangle of office and reclusion, feeling and resolve written with the finest strokes. The third couplet, 'among those in power, who will help me? Those who know my heart are rare in the world,' is the peak of the poem's feeling, the heart spoken directly, the disappointment of the self and the coldness of the world in one stroke. And the close, 'I should only keep to my lonely solitude, and close again the gate of my native garden,' settles in the resolve of the return, the whole poem from the disappointment to the grief to the resolve, layer after layer, the words flowing from the depth of the heart.
【白话串讲】 孟浩然考不中,离开长安,写诗告别王维:“寂寂竟何待,朝朝空自归”——长安再等也没用。“当路谁相假,知音世所稀”——“只应守索寞,还掩故园扉”——他决定回乡。 【意象与手法】 全诗以「寂寂」「朝朝」叠字起兴,写尽落第后无人援引的冷清;「芳草」喻归隐,「故园扉」写归隐之所,意象清雅;「当路谁相假,知音世所稀」直抒胸臆,怨而不怒。 【情感与主旨】 孟浩然应试落第,将离京归乡,此诗留别王维,倾诉知音难觅、无人援引的失意,又惜别故人,最终归于「守索寞」的淡泊,情感真挚深沉。 【名句点睛】 常考「当路谁相假,知音世所稀」直抒知音难遇之慨,以及「只应守索寞,还掩故园扉」以淡语写深情的手法。
Background
Meng Haoran (689–740) was a native of Xiangyang, a famous poet of the High Tang who lived in reclusion at Lumen Mountain in his early years and did not seek office until he was forty. Around the seventeenth year of Kaiyuan (729), he went to Chang'an at forty to take the jinshi examination, failed, and lingered in the capital in disappointment, during which he associated with Wang Wei, Wang Changling, and other poets; Wang Wei, then a high official, thought highly of Meng Haoran. This poem was written when Meng Haoran, after failing the examination, left the capital and returned home, parting from Wang Wei; the 'Censor' of the title refers to Wang Wei's having served as Censor. Meng Haoran, born with the ambition of 'serving the world' but without a boat to ferry him across, entered the capital yet failed for lack of a patron, and his mood was extremely lonely. 'In silence, what am I waiting for? Day after day I return empty' writes the coldness of being unknown in the capital; 'among those in power, who will help me? Those who know my heart are rare in the world' strikes directly at the fickleness of the world, the only one who knew his heart being Wang Wei, who was unable to recommend him. Meng Haoran never held office after this and returned to live in reclusion; this poem may be seen as the end of his thought of office and the beginning of his resolve for reclusion.
《留别王侍御维》作于开元十七年(729)前后。孟浩然四十岁赴长安应进士举,落第失意,滞留京师,期间与王维、王昌龄等诗人交游,王维时任尚书右丞,对孟浩然颇为赏识。此诗即孟浩然落第后离京归乡、临别赠王维之作,题中「侍御」指王维曾官监察御史。孟浩然是襄阳人,早年隐居鹿门山,四十岁才出游求仕,本怀着「欲济无舟楫」的用世之心入京,却因无人援引而落第,心情极为落寞。「寂寂竟何待,朝朝空自归」写尽了在京无人问津的冷清;「当路谁相假,知音世所稀」更是直刺世态炎凉,知音唯王维一人,而王维亦无力举荐。孟浩然此后终生未仕,归隐故乡,此诗可视为他仕进之念的终结与归隐之志的起点,在诗人一生中具有转折意义。诗中「欲寻芳草去」的归隐之志与「惜与故人违」的惜别之情交织,真挚动人,是孟浩然赠别诗中的名篇。后世论者多以此诗为孟浩然由求仕转向归隐的标志,其淡泊襟怀于此可见一斑。
Art
The art is 'the heart spoken directly, the depth in the plain.' The first couplet uses two groups of reduplicated words, writing the coldness of the mood and the empty waste of the days, the question and the sigh setting the lonely tone. The second couplet turns to the conflict of the going and the staying, the resolve to return and the grief of parting, the tangle of office and reclusion written with the finest strokes. The third couplet is the peak of the feeling, the heart spoken directly. And the close settles in the resolve of the return, the whole poem from the disappointment to the grief to the resolve, layer after layer, the words flowing from the depth of the heart.
此诗艺术上以「直抒胸臆、淡中见深」见长。首联「寂寂竟何待,朝朝空自归」连用两组叠字,「寂寂」写心境之冷清,「朝朝」写时日之空耗,「竟何待」「空自归」一问一叹,写尽滞留京华、无人援引的失意,起笔即定下全诗落寞的基调。颔联「欲寻芳草去,惜与故人违」转写去留的矛盾:「欲寻芳草」写归隐之志已决,「惜与故人违」写别友之情难舍,一「欲」一「惜」,把仕与隐、情与志的纠结写得细腻入微。颈联「当路谁相假,知音世所稀」是全诗情感的顶峰,直抒胸臆,将一己之失意上升为对世态炎凉的普遍感叹,「谁相假」「世所稀」两个反问与陈述,愤激而不失温厚。尾联「只应守索寞,还掩故园扉」以「只应」「还掩」两个虚字收束,归于守寂归隐的平静,由愤激转入淡泊,余味悠长。全诗语言质朴自然,不用典故堆砌,情感层层递进又层层化解,恰如孟浩然「语淡而味终不薄」的一贯风格。全诗八句一气流转,由失望而依恋,由愤激而淡泊,情感的弧度完整而自然。
Allusions
The allusions are few and apt, all fitting the poet's situation. The 'silence' of 'in silence, what am I waiting for' carries the solitude of the Nine Arguments of the Elegies of Chu, 'lonely in a strange land without friend or companion'; 'day after day I return empty' covertly uses the image of Han Xin's staying at the home of the pavilion chief in the Records of the Grand Historian, writing the embarrassment of living on another's charity and returning empty every day. 'The fragrant grass' of 'I would seek the fragrant grass and go' comes from the tradition of the Elegies of Chu's fragrant plants for purity; 'the fragrant grass' for the return to the pure reclusion, and the parting from the friend who understands the heart, the two intertwined.
此诗用典少而精,皆切合诗人处境。「寂寂竟何待」之「寂寂」暗含《楚辞·九辩》「廓落兮羁旅而无友生」的孤寂传统,写羁旅无友之境;「朝朝空自归」则暗用《史记·淮阴侯列传》韩信寄食南昌亭长家「亭长妻患之,乃晨炊蓐食」的典故意象,写寄人篱下、日日空归的难堪。「欲寻芳草去」之「芳草」本自《楚辞》以香草喻高洁的传统,屈原「何昔日之芳草兮,今直为此萧艾也」,孟浩然以「寻芳草」喻归隐,谓将追随高洁的隐逸生活而去,芳草既是实景又是象征。「知音世所稀」用伯牙子期之典,《列子·汤问》载伯牙鼓琴,钟子期善听,子期死,伯牙破琴绝弦,「知音」即由此而来,孟浩然以此写王维是为数不多的知己,暗含知音既失、鼓琴何用的悲慨。「当路」一词本自《孟子》「夫子当路于齐」,指当权执政之人,孟浩然以「当路谁相假」写权贵无人援引,用典自然贴切,与全诗质朴的语言浑然一体。「朝朝空自归」之「归」暗含「客居无归」的双关,谓京华虽居而心无所归,与尾联「还掩故园扉」的归乡之「归」遥遥相映,首尾关合,针线细密。
Commentary
'Parting from Censor Wang Wei' is a famous piece of Meng Haoran's parting poems, highly rated by the critics of every age. They mostly admire its 'plain words, deep feeling': the whole poem has no astonishing word, no gorgeous diction, yet writes the disappointment of the failure, the grief of the rare knowing heart, the conflict of the going and the staying, and the resolve of the return to the solitude, layer after layer, every word flowing from the depth of the heart. The Qing Shen Deqian, in his Selection of Tang Poetry, praised Meng Haoran's poems as 'the words plain yet the flavor never thin,' and this poem is the best example.
《留别王侍御维》是孟浩然赠别诗中的名篇,历来评价甚高。前人论此诗,多赏其「语淡情深」:全诗没有惊人的字句,没有华丽的辞藻,却把落第后的失意、知音难觅的悲慨、去留两难的矛盾、归隐守寂的决绝,层层写来,字字从肺腑中流出。清人沈德潜《唐诗别裁》评孟浩然诗「语淡而味终不薄」,此诗正是最好的注脚。诗中「当路谁相假,知音世所稀」一联,更以其对世态炎凉的深刻揭示而广为传诵,成为千古失意士人的共同心声。此诗的价值还在于其史料意义:它真实记录了盛唐文人求仕的艰难与王孟之间的深厚交谊,王维后来亦有《送别》等诗与之呼应。在孟浩然全部诗作中,此诗以其真挚深沉的情感、质朴自然的语言,被视为其「以诗代柬」的杰作,也是研究盛唐文人干谒与归隐心态的重要文本,历来入选唐诗选本。千载之下,诗中那份「知音世所稀」的慨叹,仍能唤起天下失意者的共鸣,足见其情感力量的恒久。
Prosody
Line by line
寂寂竟何待,朝朝空自归。
In silence, what am I waiting for? Day after day I return empty. (The first couplet: the reduplicated 'silence' and 'day after day,' the question and the sigh, writing the full disappointment of lingering in the capital without help, the lonely tone of the whole.)
我这样寂寞地守在这里,究竟还等待什么呢?天天早晨都空自归来,一无所获。
Lonely as this, what am I still waiting for? Morning after morning I return in vain.
起联连用「寂寂」「朝朝」两组叠字,写尽落第后滞留京华的冷清与空耗。「寂寂」从心境着笔,写无人问津的孤寂;「朝朝」从时间着笔,写日复一日的空守。两句一问一叹:「竟何待」是自问,问自己还在等待什么机缘;「空自归」是自叹,叹每天应酬奔走却一无所获。「空」字是全联的诗眼,写尽了徒劳无功的怅惘——求仕之路既已断绝,等待便成了无望的消耗。这两句是孟浩然落第生活的真实写照,也暗含对世态炎凉的隐约怨愤:京城虽大,却无一人援引。起笔如此落寞,为全诗定下低回的基调,也与尾联「守索寞」的归隐归宿遥相呼应。
The opening couplet uses the two doubled words 'lonely' and 'morning after morning' to write the cold emptiness of lingering in the capital after failing the exam. 'Lonely' from the mood, the solitude of one no one asks after; 'morning after morning' from time, the day-after-day waiting. One question, one sigh: 'what am I still waiting for?' the self-question, asking what chance he still awaits; 'return in vain' the self-sigh, grieving that daily social calls bring nothing. The word 'in vain' is the couplet's eye, writing to the full the fruitless disappointment — the road to office closed, and waiting become a hopeless drain. These two lines are the true portrait of Meng Haoran's failed-exam life, secretly holding the faint resentment at the world's coldness: the capital is great, yet not one man to recommend him. The opening so desolate tunes the low, lingering tone, echoing the closing couplet's 'keep to my solitude'.
欲寻芳草去,惜与故人违。
I would seek the fragrant grass and go, yet grieve to part from my old friend. (The second couplet: the conflict of the going and the staying, the resolve to return and the grief of parting, one 'would' and one 'grieve,' the tangle of feeling and resolve.)
想要去寻找芳草归隐而去,却惋惜要与老朋友离别。
I would go, seeking fragrant grass; I grieve to part from an old friend.
此联写去留两难的矛盾,是诗人内心的真实挣扎。「欲寻芳草去」写归隐之志已决,「芳草」既指现实的芳草地,又喻高洁的隐逸生活,承《楚辞》香草传统,见出诗人自视清高、不愿同流合污的心志;「惜与故人违」却陡然一转,「惜」字写别友之情的难舍,「违」即离别,谓归隐虽好,却要离开知己王维,情与志在此冲突。一「欲」一「惜」,把仕进无望后的退隐与知己难逢的依恋写得曲折动人。此联还暗含一层深意:归隐本可自得,但因王维这位「知音」尚在京城,归隐便成了与故人的诀别,故惜别之情愈深,可见二人交谊之厚,也为下联「知音世所稀」作了铺垫。两句对仗工整而情致婉转,是情志交织的佳句。
This couplet writes the dilemma of staying or going, the poet's true inward struggle. 'I would go, seeking fragrant grass' — the resolve to retire is taken, 'fragrant grass' both the real meadow and the metaphor for the pure recluse life, carrying on the Verses of Chu's tradition of fragrant plants, showing the poet's lofty self-regard and refusal to follow the vulgar; 'I grieve to part from an old friend' turns abruptly, the word 'grieve' writing the hard-to-release feeling at parting, 'part' the separation — though retirement is good, it means leaving the kindred spirit Wang Wei, feeling and will in conflict here. One 'would', one 'grieve', writing with winding tenderness the retirement after official hope fails, and the attachment to a friend rarely found. The hidden depth: retirement might be self-sufficient, yet because the 'kindred spirit' Wang Wei is still in the capital, retirement becomes a farewell to the old friend, so the grief the deeper, showing the thickness of the friendship, and preparing the next line 'kindred spirits are rare'.
当路谁相假,知音世所稀。
Among those in power, who will help me? Those who know my heart are rare in the world. (The third couplet, the peak of the feeling: the heart spoken directly, the disappointment of the self and the coldness of the world, the only one who knew his heart being Wang Wei.)
当权的显贵有谁肯提携帮助我呢?知音的人在世上实在稀少。
Who among the powerful will lend me a hand? Kindred spirits are rare in the world.
此联是全诗情感的顶峰,直抒胸臆,愤激深沉。「当路谁相假」以反问出之,写尽权贵无一人援引的失望——「当路」指当权执政者,诗人求仕无门,正是因为这班「当路」者不肯相助,一个「谁」字,愤激之中见出对世态的清醒认识;「知音世所稀」转以陈述,写知音难觅的孤独——在诗人看来,满朝显贵皆非知音,唯有王维一人能懂自己,而这位知音又无法改变自己的命运。两句一愤一悲,从权贵说到知音,由普遍世态回到个人遭际,层层递进,把落第士人的失意写得入木三分。此联语言质朴而情感浓烈,不假雕饰而自具力量,是孟浩然诗中少见的直抒之作,也是千古失意文人的共同心声,故能引起广泛的共鸣。
This couplet is the emotional peak, direct utterance, impassioned and deep. 'Who among the powerful will lend me a hand?' in the form of a counter-question, writing to the full the disappointment that none of the great will help — 'the powerful' those in authority, the poet's road to office closed precisely because these 'powerful' will not assist, the one word 'who' showing, within the indignation, the clear-eyed reading of the world's ways. 'Kindred spirits are rare in the world' turns to statement, writing the loneliness of the rare soul-mate — in the poet's view, all the court's grandees are no kindred spirits, only Wang Wei understands him, and that kindred spirit cannot change his fate. One line indignation, one grief, from the powerful to the kindred spirit, from the general world to personal lot, layer on layer, writing the failed scholar's disappointment to the marrow. The language plain, the feeling intense, no ornamentation, yet forceful of itself, the rare direct utterance in Meng Haoran's verse, and the common voice of disappointed scholars through the ages.
只应守索寞,还掩故园扉。
I should only keep to my lonely solitude, and close again the gate of my native garden. (The close: the resolve of the return, to keep to the solitude and close the gate of the native garden, the end of the thought of office and the beginning of the resolve for reclusion.)
我只应该守着这份寂寞,回到故园,掩上那扇柴门。
I ought only to keep to my solitude, go home, and shut the garden gate.
尾联以淡语收束,由愤激归于平静,是「以淡写深」的典范。「只应」二字写退无可退之后的清醒抉择:既然当路无人相助、知音世间稀有,那么唯一的路便是归隐守寂,「只应」是经过绝望后的必然,语气平静而坚定;「守索寞」写甘守寂寞的自觉,化被动为主动,从「寂寂竟何待」的被动等待,转为「守索寞」的主动安守,心态完成了一个蜕变;「还掩故园扉」以「掩扉」这一细节收束,「还」字写回归故园,「掩」字轻轻掩上柴门,把外面的世界关在门外,也把求仕的幻梦关在门外。两句不着一字悲愤,而深沉的失意尽在掩门一瞬的动作之中,余味悠长,恰见孟浩然「语淡而味终不薄」的风格。
The closing couplet ends in plain words, turning from indignation to calm, the model of 'writing depth through plainness'. 'I ought only to' the clear choice after no retreat: since none in power will help, and kindred spirits are rare, the only road is retirement and solitude, 'ought only' the necessity after despair, the tone calm and firm; 'keep to my solitude' the willed embracing of loneliness, turning the passive into the active, from the passive waiting of 'lonely as this, what am I still waiting for?' to the active keeping of 'keep to my solitude', the mind completing a transformation; 'go home, and shut the garden gate' ends in the detail of 'shutting the gate', the word 'home' the return to the garden, 'shut' the light closing of the wicket, shutting the outside world out, and shutting out the dream of office. Not one word of grief or anger, yet the deep disappointment is all in the instant of shutting the gate, the aftertaste long, precisely showing Meng Haoran's style of 'plain in speech yet never thin in savor'.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
王维《送别》「下马饮君酒,问君何所之。君言不得意,归卧南山陲」与孟浩然《留别王侍御维》正可互为唱和:孟诗是离京前留别王维,王诗是送友人归隐,两诗合观,恰是这场离别的一赠一答。孟诗重在写「不得意」的具体况味——寂寂空归、当路无人、知音稀少,把失意写得真切沉重;王诗则重在写送者的理解与宽慰——「但去莫复问,白云无尽时」,以白云无尽喻归隐生活的自在,豁达超然。一写被送者的失意,一写送者的超脱;一沉郁,一旷达。两诗并读,可见王孟交谊之深,也可见盛唐文人对待仕隐矛盾的不同姿态,是研究王孟关系的珍贵材料。
岁暮归南山 At Year's End, Returning to South Mountain 孟浩然 · 同为孟浩然落第归隐之作,姊妹篇 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
《岁暮归南山》「北阙休上书,南山归敝庐。不才明主弃,多病故人疏」与《留别王侍御维》同为孟浩然落第后归隐之作,可视为姊妹篇。差异在于:赠王维之作重在惜别知己,情感集中于「知音世所稀」的孤独与「惜与故人违」的依恋,怨而不怒,温厚真挚;《岁暮归南山》则重在自伤身世,「不才明主弃,多病故人疏」以自嘲的口吻写明主之弃、故人之疏,愤激中含讥刺,情绪更为复杂。一为赠人,故情意恳切;一为自伤,故感慨深沉。两诗合观,可见孟浩然落第后心境的两个侧面:对知己的深情与对世态的怨愤,也可见同一题材在不同场合的不同写法,是研究孟浩然其人其诗的珍贵对照。
赠汪伦 To Wang Lun 李白 · 同为留别赠友,一淡一豪 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
李白《赠汪伦》「桃花潭水深千尺,不及汪伦送我情」与孟浩然《留别王侍御维》同为唐代留别赠友的名篇,而风格迥异。李白之作以夸张的比喻直写情谊之深,桃花潭水深千尺,仍不及汪伦送别之情,情感奔放,想象奇崛,是豪放浪漫的典型;孟浩然之作则以朴素的叙述细写失意之悲,寂寂空归、知音稀少、掩扉守寂,情感内敛,语言平淡,是清淡恬静的典型。一以情之深胜,一以情之真胜;一豪放,一淡远,恰见李孟二人性格与诗风之别。两诗并读,可见唐诗送别题材的丰富性:同是临别赠友,可以写得如此热烈,也可以写得如此含蓄,正体现盛唐诗歌百花齐放的盛况。