All poems

唐 Tang · 诗 Poem

塞下曲四首 一

Frontier Song: Four Poems, No. 1

王昌龄

Wang Changling

蝉鸣空桑林八月萧关道出塞入塞寒处处黄芦草从来幽并客皆共尘沙老莫学游侠儿矜夸紫骝好

Cicadas cry in the empty mulberry grove — the eighth month on the Xiaoguan road.
Out beyond the pass, back within the pass, everywhere cold; everywhere yellow reeds and withered grass.
Men of You and Bing since olden days have all grown old amid dust and sand.
Do not imitate the roaming gallants who boast of their fine purple steeds.
Listen

Meaning

A bleak frontier autumn opens the poem: cicadas in a bare mulberry grove, the eighth month on the Xiaoguan road, cold wind through the passes, yellow reeds everywhere. From this desolation the poet turns to the fate of the men of You and Bing, whose lives are ground away in sand and dust. He closes with a bitter warning against the romantic gallantry that glorifies fine horses and reckless heroism — frontier glamour set against the reality of a lifetime wasted in garrison dust.

蝉鸣于空桑之林,八月行于萧关之道。出塞入塞皆寒,处处黄芦衰草。从来幽并之客,皆共尘沙而老。莫学那游侠儿,矜夸紫骝之好。

Appreciation

[Plain Paraphrase] Cicadas cry in the empty mulberry woods; it is the eighth month on the road to Xiaoguan. In and out of the passes it is cold; everywhere yellow reeds and withered grass. The men of You and Bing have all grown old in the sand. Do not imitate the roaming gallants boasting of their fine horses. [Structure and Technique] The poem is built in two halves: four lines of autumn desolation, then four of reflection and warning. The desolation is not decoration but premise — the empty grove and yellow reeds are the lifespan of the men of You and Bing written in landscape. The turn to do not imitate is the poem's sting: against the frontier tradition that glorifies horses and heroism, Wang Changling pits the soldier's slow erasure in dust.

【白话串讲】 王昌龄写《塞下曲四首其一》:“蝉鸣空桑林,八月萧关道”——“出塞入塞寒,处处黄芦草”——“从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老”——“莫学游侠儿,矜夸紫骝好”——他写塞下——皆共尘沙老。 【意象与手法】 前四句写边塞秋景:蝉鸣空桑、八月萧关、出塞入塞寒、处处黄芦草;后四句写征戍感慨:幽并客共尘沙老、莫学游侠儿矜夸紫骝。苍凉警世。 【情感与主旨】 王昌龄写边塞秋色与征戍的感慨,以“从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老”写征戍之苦,是边塞诗的名篇。 【名句点睛】 常考“蝉鸣空桑林,八月萧关道”写边塞秋色;“从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老”写征戍之苦。

Background

Wang Changling (ca. 698-ca. 756) was a leading High Tang frontier poet, called the Sage of the Seven-character Quatrain, whose frontier poems are celebrated for heroic desolation. 'Frontier Song' was an old yuefu title for garrison and campaign themes. Writing in the Kaiyuan era, when Tang armies held and pushed the northwestern frontiers, Wang Changling gave the genre its double face: martial glory and human cost. This poem belongs to the latter strain — autumn, dust, and old age instead of victory.

此诗为盛唐诗人王昌龄的《塞下曲四首》其一之作,是边塞诗的名篇。王昌龄(约698—约756),字少伯,京兆长安(今陕西西安)人,盛唐诗人,开元十五年(727)进士,以七绝名世,人称「七绝圣手」,其边塞诗雄浑苍凉,与高适、岑参并为盛唐边塞诗的代表。塞下曲为乐府旧题,写边塞征戍之事。此诗写边塞秋色与征戍的感慨:「蝉鸣空桑林」,写蝉鸣于空桑之林——秋蝉鸣于空桑林,正是边塞的秋色;「八月萧关道」,写八月行于萧关之道——萧关为关中要地(今宁夏固原东南),八月行于萧关道,正是边塞的行旅;「出塞入塞寒」,写出塞入塞皆寒——出塞入塞,处处皆寒,正是边塞的苦寒;「处处黄芦草」,写处处黄芦衰草——黄芦草写边塞的衰草,正是秋色;「从来幽并客」,写从来幽并之客——幽并为幽州、并州(今河北、山西一带),自古多慷慨悲歌之士,「幽并客」写幽并的征人;「皆共尘沙老」,写皆共尘沙而老——那幽并之客,皆共尘沙而老,正是征戍的命运;「莫学游侠儿」,写莫学那游侠儿——游侠儿写任侠之人,正是讽世的告诫;「矜夸紫骝好」,写矜夸紫骝之好——紫骝写紫红色的骏马,「矜夸紫骝好」写夸耀骏马之好。全诗以边塞秋色写征戍的感慨,那幽并客共尘沙老的命运,那莫学游侠儿矜夸的告诫,苍凉而警世,是边塞诗「写征戍感慨」的代表作。

Art

The craft rests on progression and reversal. The first four lines layer sound (cicadas), season (eighth month), place (Xiaoguan road), sensation (cold in and out of the passes), and color (yellow reeds) — a complete frontier autumn assembled from pure sensation, with empty, cold, and yellow as its bleak triad. The second half pivots from scene to judgment: the men of You and Bing growing old amid dust and sand compresses a lifetime of garrison service into one slow verb, grown old. Then the closing couplet turns satire against the frontier romance of gallants and their purple steeds — the glamour exposed as ignorance of what service actually costs.

此诗艺术上以「秋色为衬」与「讽世为骨」为特色,在边塞秋色的描绘中写尽征戍的感慨。前四句写边塞秋色:蝉鸣空桑林——那是秋蝉之声;八月萧关道——那是八月之行;出塞入塞寒——那是边塞之寒;处处黄芦草——那是衰草之色。四句之中,蝉鸣、萧关、黄芦草,写尽边塞的秋色,那「空」「寒」「黄」,正是秋色的苍凉。而后四句写征戍感慨:从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老——那幽并的征人,皆共尘沙而老,正是征戍的命运;莫学游侠儿,矜夸紫骝好——莫学那游侠儿,夸耀骏马之好,正是讽世的告诫。这前后对照,是全诗的关键:那前四句的秋色,正是「幽并客共尘沙老」的铺垫——黄芦衰草之中,正是征人老于尘沙的命运;那「莫学游侠儿」的告诫,正是对「矜夸紫骝」的讽世。全诗由秋色写起,经幽并客的征戍命运,而归于「莫学游侠儿」的告诫,秋色为衬、讽世为骨,正是边塞诗「苍凉警世」的极致。细观其章法,前半写景,后半议论,写景为议论之铺垫,议论为写景之归结——那黄芦衰草的空桑萧关,正是「幽并客共尘沙老」的见证,那「莫学游侠儿」的告诫,正是从苍凉秋色中自然引出。

Allusions

Xiaoguan was one of the four great passes guarding Han-era Guanzhong, on the road beyond the wall — a name freighted with campaigns and exile. You and Bing (modern Hebei and Shanxi) were famous since Cao Zhi's 'Ode to the White Horse' — gallants of You and Bing — as lands of fierce, song-loving warriors; Wang Changling inherits that tradition only to darken it. The purple colt is a famous steed name from old yuefu, the emblem of the romantic knight-errant. By invoking all three — pass, land, and horse — the poem sets its bleak reality against a whole literature of frontier glamour.

此诗用典于关键处见深意。「空桑林」,写空寂的桑林——「空桑」写空寂的桑树之林,「蝉鸣空桑林」写秋蝉鸣于空桑林,正是边塞秋色的起笔。「萧关」,用「萧关」之典——萧关为关中要地(今宁夏固原东南),汉时关中四关之一,为通塞外的要道,「八月萧关道」写八月行于萧关道,正是边塞的行旅。「幽并」,写幽州、并州——幽并为古幽州、并州(今河北、山西一带),自古多慷慨悲歌之士,曹植《白马篇》「幽并游侠儿」正写幽并之士,「从来幽并客」写幽并的征人。「游侠儿」,写任侠之人——「游侠儿」写轻生重义的任侠之人,曹植《白马篇》正写「幽并游侠儿」。「紫骝」,写紫红色的骏马——「紫骝」为骏马名,古乐府《紫骝马》写骏马,「矜夸紫骝好」写夸耀骏马之好。值得注意的是,这数处用典,或出《白马篇》、或出乐府《紫骝马》,皆与幽并游侠之事相关——那「幽并客」「游侠儿」「紫骝」三事相连,正见曹植笔下「幽并游侠儿」的英姿,而王昌龄以「莫学」二字翻转之,正是对「游侠」之典的翻新。这些意象,或写萧关、或写幽并、或写游侠儿、或写紫骝,皆围绕边塞征戍与讽世这一核心,织成一张苍凉警世的情网,正是盛唐边塞诗「以典写意」的特点。

Commentary

This poem is prized as the bleak counterweight to Wang Changling's heroic frontier quatrains. Critics pair the men of You and Bing growing old amid dust and sand with the unbreakable resolve of we will not return until Loulan is broken from his 'Army Campaign Poems' to show his range: the same poet who wrote conquest also wrote the soldier's slow burial in sand. The closing warning against gallants boasting of fine horses is read as an unusually bitter anti-romantic gesture, refusing the frontier tradition's self-glorification. Its bleak, rhyme-driven music — oblique tones falling hard — is considered a peak of the five-character old-style frontier poem.

读此诗,最值得注意的是「从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老」与「莫学游侠儿,矜夸紫骝好」所写出的「征戍命运与讽世告诫」。前四句写边塞秋色:蝉鸣空桑林,八月萧关道,出塞入塞寒,处处黄芦草——那是苍凉的秋色,秋蝉、萧关、黄芦草,正是边塞的秋。而后四句写征戍感慨:「从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老」——那幽并的征人,皆共尘沙而老。这一「皆共尘沙老」,是全诗的骨:那幽并的慷慨之士,从军边塞,皆共尘沙而老——不是战死沙场,而是老于尘沙,正是征戍的命运。那黄芦衰草之中,正是征人老于尘沙的身影。而「莫学游侠儿,矜夸紫骝好」——莫学那游侠儿,夸耀骏马之好。这一告诫,是全诗的讽世:那游侠儿,只知夸耀骏马,却不知征戍之苦——王昌龄以此告诫,正是对「轻狂任侠」的讽世,也是对「征戍之老」的感慨。值得注意的是,那「幽并客」与「游侠儿」,本皆出幽并,一为征人而老于尘沙,一为游侠而矜夸骏马——同出幽并,命运迥异,正是「讽世」的深意。王昌龄的边塞诗,雄浑苍凉,那「皆共尘沙老」的征戍命运,那「莫学游侠儿」的讽世告诫,正是边塞诗「苍凉警世」的深衷。

Prosody

Form Five-character ancient-style poem (wu yan gu shi) on the yuefu theme 'Frontier Song'诗(五言古诗)
Rhyme Eight lines with rhyme falling on the even lines: dao (road), cao (grass), lao (old), and hao (fine) — all oblique-tone rhymes of the xiao-hao group. Their short, falling sounds give the poem its hard-cut, bleak music, fitting the autumn frontier.此诗为五言古诗,前半「林」「道」「草」等字押仄声韵,短促而苍凉,正合边塞秋色的声调;后半「老」「好」等字押仄声韵,由写景转入感慨,正是「征戍感慨」的声情。全诗由前半的秋色,到后半的感慨,仄声韵一以贯之,声调苍凉而警世,正是古体诗「以声写情」的特点,也是王昌龄边塞诗「苍凉雄浑」的体现。
Tone pattern The cadence is clipped and declarative. 'Chan ming kong sang lin, ba yue xiao guan dao' — a flat statement of scene; 'chu sai ru sai han, chu chu huang lu cao' — repetition (in, out; everywhere) grinds like cold wind; 'cong lai you bing ke, jie gong chen sha lao' — the line slows and sinks on old; 'mo xue you xia er, jin kua zi liu hao' — the warning lands sharp and short. Oblique rhymes throughout keep the voice unsentimental.句式上,此诗善用写景与议论:「蝉鸣空桑林,八月萧关道」,以「蝉鸣」「萧关」写秋色,句法凝练;「出塞入塞寒,处处黄芦草」,以「出塞入塞」「处处」写边塞之寒,叠字写意;「从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老」,以「从来」「皆共」写征戍命运,转折而见感慨;「莫学游侠儿,矜夸紫骝好」,以「莫学」写告诫,讽世而警醒。全诗由写景入感慨、由感慨入讽世,句式随之由凝练转苍凉,正是古体诗「苍凉警世」的节奏美学。
Reading note A five-character old-style frontier poem rhyming on oblique tones — a deliberate choice that keeps the music bleak and unlovely, refusing the sing-song of level-tone heroism. The first half is pure scene assembled from sensation, the second half reflection and warning; the pivot between them is the poem's hinge. Because it is old-style verse, parallelism is loose and the diction plain — plainness is the point: frontier life described without glamour. Read it slowly and low, letting the oblique rhymes fall like sand.作为盛唐五古,《塞下曲四首·其一》的声律之美,在于以苍凉的仄声韵与凝练的写景句式,写出边塞秋色与征戍感慨。全诗前半「蝉鸣空桑林,八月萧关道」以蝉鸣萧关写边塞秋色,苍凉而凝练;「出塞入塞寒,处处黄芦草」以出塞入塞、黄芦草写边塞之寒,叠字写意;后半「从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老」以幽并客、尘沙老写征戍命运,苍凉而感慨;「莫学游侠儿,矜夸紫骝好」以莫学游侠写讽世告诫,警醒而有力。全诗由写景入感慨、由感慨入讽世,层层递进而声情相谐,正是边塞诗「苍凉警世」的体现。就全诗而言,此诗以边塞秋色写征戍感慨,苍凉而警世,是边塞诗的名篇,与王昌龄《从军行七首·其二》「青海长云暗雪山」同为边塞之作,而一写「不破楼兰终不还」的壮志,一写「皆共尘沙老」的感慨,可见王昌龄边塞诗写征戍的两种笔法,也可见盛唐边塞诗中壮志与感慨的交织。

Line by line

八月萧关道

The eighth month on the Xiaoguan road.

八月行于萧关之道。

In the eighth month, on the road at Xiao Pass.

这一句写八月行于萧关道,是此诗行旅意象的核心。「八月」,写八月——八月正是边塞的初秋,「八月」写边塞的时令;「萧关道」,写萧关之道——「萧关」用萧关之典,萧关为关中要地(今宁夏固原东南),汉时关中四关之一,「萧关道」写萧关之道。以「八月萧关道」写行旅,比直写「边塞」更见时令与关塞——那八月,行于萧关之道,正是边塞的行旅;「萧关」二字,写关塞要地,正是「出塞入塞寒」的铺垫。这一句,是此诗行旅意象的核心,与「蝉鸣空桑林」相连,一写秋蝉,一写萧关,正是边塞秋色的行旅——那八月萧关道,正是征人之路。

This line writes 'in the eighth month, on the road at Xiao Pass', the core of the poem's journey imagery. 'The eighth month' the eighth month, the early autumn of the borderland, the season of the frontier; 'the road at Xiao Pass' — 'Xiao Pass' uses the Xiao Pass allusion, the key pass of the Guanzhong region (southeast of present-day Guyuan, Ningxia), one of the four great Han passes of Guanzhong, 'the road at Xiao Pass' the road itself. Writing the journey through 'the eighth month on the road at Xiao Pass', the season and the pass more present than a plain 'borderland'. This line is the core of the journey imagery, joined with 'the cicadas sing in the empty mulberry grove', one the autumn cicada, one the Xiao Pass, the travel of the frontier autumn — the road at Xiao Pass in the eighth month, the soldier's road.

从来幽并客

Men of You and Bing since olden days,

从来幽并之客。

Always, the travelers from You and Bing,

这一句写幽并之客,是此诗征戍意象的核心。「从来」,写从来——「从来」写向来如此,正是「幽并客」的一贯;「幽并客」,写幽并的征人——「幽并」写幽州、并州(今河北、山西一带),自古多慷慨悲歌之士,「幽并客」写幽并的征人。以「从来幽并客」写征人,比直写「征人」更见慷慨与出身——那幽并之客,正是慷慨悲歌之士;「从来」二字,写征戍之一贯,正是「皆共尘沙老」的铺垫。这一句,是此诗征戍意象的核心,与「皆共尘沙老」相连,一写出身,一写命运,正是征人的命运——那幽并之客,皆共尘沙而老。

This line writes 'always, the travelers from You and Bing', the core of the poem's garrison imagery. 'Always' — 'always' means from of old, precisely the constancy of the 'travelers from You and Bing'; 'the travelers from You and Bing' the garrison men of You and Bing — 'You and Bing' the regions of Youzhou and Bingzhou (roughly present-day Hebei and Shanxi), since old times the land of the generous, stern, grieved-and-singing men, 'the travelers from You and Bing' the garrison men themselves. Writing the garrison through 'always, the travelers from You and Bing', the generosity and the birthplace more present than a plain 'garrison man'. This line is the core of the garrison imagery, joined with 'all grow old together in the dust and sand', one the birthplace, one the fate, the fate of the garrison man — the men of You and Bing, all growing old together in the dust and sand.

皆共尘沙老

have all grown old amid dust and sand.

皆共尘沙而老。

all grow old together in the dust and sand.

这一句写幽并客共尘沙而老,是此诗征戍命运的核心。「皆共」,写皆共——「皆」写全都,「共」写共同,「皆共」写全都共同;「尘沙老」,写共尘沙而老——「尘沙」写边塞的风沙,「老」写老去,「共尘沙老」写共尘沙而老。以「皆共尘沙老」写征戍命运,比直写「战死」更见苍凉与无奈——那幽并之客,皆共尘沙而老,不是战死沙场,而是老于尘沙,正是征戍的命运;「尘沙老」三字,写老于尘沙,正是边塞的苍凉。这一句,是此诗征戍命运的核心,也是全诗的骨——那幽并客共尘沙老的命运,正是「莫学游侠儿」的铺垫。

This line writes 'all grow old together in the dust and sand', the core of the poem's garrison fate. 'All together' — 'all' means every one, 'together' means sharing, 'all together' every one sharing; 'grow old in the dust and sand' — 'dust and sand' the frontier's wind and sand, 'grow old' aging, 'grow old in the dust and sand' aging with the dust and sand. Writing the garrison fate through 'all grow old together in the dust and sand', the desolation and helplessness more present than a plain 'die in battle' — the men of You and Bing, all growing old in the dust and sand, not dying on the battlefield but aging in the sand, precisely the fate of the garrison. The words 'grow old in the dust and sand' the aging in the sand, the frontier's desolation. This line is the core of the garrison fate, and the bone of the poem — the fate of the men of You and Bing aging in the dust and sand, the groundwork for 'learn not from the swashbuckler'.

Study

Word focus

空桑 The empty mulberry grove — bare, withered mulberry trees; the word empty turns a grove into desolate frontier waste, and the cicadas' cry against that emptiness sets the poem's bleak key. 「蝉鸣空桑林」之「空桑」,写空寂的桑林,是此诗秋色意象的关键语。「空桑」即空寂的桑林——「空」写空寂,「桑」写桑树,「空桑」写空寂的桑树之林;「蝉鸣空桑林」,写秋蝉鸣于空桑林。以「空桑」写桑林,比直写「桑林」更见秋色与空寂——那空寂的桑林,正是边塞的秋色;「空」字,写桑林之空寂,正是「蝉鸣」的背景。这一词,是此诗秋色意象的关键,与「蝉鸣」相连,一写秋蝉,一写空桑,正是边塞的秋色——那空桑林中,秋蝉独鸣,正是「八月萧关道」的铺垫。
萧关 Xiaoguan Pass — one of the four great passes of Han-era Guanzhong (near present-day Guyuan, Ningxia), the gateway leading beyond the wall; its name carries centuries of campaigns and exile. 「八月萧关道」之「萧关」,用萧关之典,是此诗关塞意象的核心语。「萧关」为关中要地——萧关在今宁夏固原东南,汉时关中四关之一,为通塞外的要道,「八月萧关道」写八月行于萧关道。以「萧关」写关塞,比直写「边关」更见具体与古意——那萧关,正是通塞外的要道;「萧关」二字,写关塞要地,正是「出塞入塞寒」的铺垫。这一词,是此诗关塞意象的核心,与「八月」相连,一写时令,一写关塞,正是边塞的行旅——那八月萧关道,正是征人之路。
尘沙 Dust and sand — the frontier's grit; growing old in dust and sand means a lifetime buried in garrison hardship, not glorious death in battle. 「皆共尘沙老」之「尘沙」,写边塞的风沙,是此诗征戍意象的核心语。「尘沙」即风沙——「尘」写尘土,「沙」写沙土,「尘沙」写边塞的风沙;「皆共尘沙老」,写皆共尘沙而老。以「尘沙」写边塞,比直写「边疆」更见风沙与苍凉——那尘沙,正是边塞的写照;「尘沙老」三字,写老于尘沙,正是征戍的命运。这一词,是此诗征戍意象的核心,与「幽并客」相连,一写征人,一写尘沙,正是征人的命运——那幽并客,皆共尘沙而老,正是边塞的苍凉。

Related Reading

从军行七首·其二 Army Campaign Poems: Seven, No. 2 王昌龄 · 同为王昌龄边塞之作,一写黄沙百战穿金甲的壮志一写皆共尘沙老的感慨,边塞征戍互为映照 Two faces of Wang Changling's frontier writing — one unbreakable resolve, one a life ground down in sand

Long clouds of Qinghai darken the snow mountains; a lone city gazes toward Yumen Pass; through a hundred battles our armor is worn through; we will not return until Loulan is broken burns with unbreakable will. This poem's men of You and Bing growing old amid dust and sand shows the cost behind that will. Read together, they reveal the twin poles of High Tang frontier poetry: heroic resolve and human price.

王昌龄《从军行七首·其二》「青海长云暗雪山,孤城遥望玉门关。黄沙百战穿金甲,不破楼兰终不还」,写边塞将士的报国壮志,是王昌龄从军行的名篇;此诗「从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老」,同样为王昌龄边塞之作。一写「黄沙百战穿金甲」的壮志,一写「皆共尘沙老」的感慨;《从军行》是「不破楼兰终不还」的豪迈,此诗是「莫学游侠儿」的警世。并读两作,可见王昌龄边塞诗写征戍的两种笔法,也可见壮志与感慨在边塞诗中的交织。

从军行七首·其五 Army Campaign Poems: Seven, No. 5 王昌龄 · 同为王昌龄边塞之作,一写已报生擒吐谷浑的捷报一写皆共尘沙老的感慨,边塞胜败互为映照 The same frontier world in opposite registers — one a victory's report, one a lifetime's slow erosion

Desert wind dims the day's color; red flags half-furled sweep out the camp gates; the vanguard fought by night north of the Tao, and reports already of Tuyuhun taken alive races with the speed of victory. 'Frontier Song No. 1' moves at the speed of a lifetime wasted: cicadas, yellow reeds, men growing old in sand. One is the headline, the other the account books of service.

王昌龄《从军行七首·其五》「大漠风尘日色昏,红旗半卷出辕门。前军夜战洮河北,已报生擒吐谷浑」,写边塞破敌的捷报,是王昌龄从军行的名篇;此诗「出塞入塞寒,处处黄芦草」,同样为王昌龄边塞之作。一写「已报生擒吐谷浑」的捷报,一写「皆共尘沙老」的感慨;《从军行·其五》是边塞的豪迈捷报,此诗是边塞的苍凉秋色。并读两作,可见王昌龄边塞诗写胜捷与写命运的两种笔法,也可见边塞诗豪迈与苍凉的两面。

燕歌行 Song of Yan 高适 · 同为写边塞征戍之作,一写战士军前半死生的苦战一写皆共尘沙老的命运,边塞征戍互为映照 Both expose the cost of frontier service — one in the stark clash of battle, one in the slow erasure of old age

Gao Shi's the soldiers fight half-dead at the front while the beauty in the general's tent still sings and dances denounces the gap between command and sacrifice with boiling indignation. Wang Changling's men of You and Bing growing old amid dust and sand is quieter — no battle scene, just the slow fact of lives ground away. Gao Shi thunders; Wang Changling endures. Two registers of High Tang frontier conscience.

高适《燕歌行》「战士军前半死生,美人帐下犹歌舞。相看白刃血纷纷,死节从来岂顾勋」,写边塞征戍的苦战与悲壮,是边塞诗的名篇;王昌龄此诗「从来幽并客,皆共尘沙老」,同样写边塞征戍。一写「战士军前半死生」的苦战,一写「皆共尘沙老」的命运;高适是「死节从来岂顾勋」的悲壮,王昌龄是「莫学游侠儿」的警世。并读两作,可见盛唐边塞诗写征戍的两种深衷,也可见边塞将士在苦战与老去中的不同命运。