All poems

现代 现代 · 诗 Poem

灯

The Lamp

冯至

Feng Zhi

黑暗中你点起了一盏灯,像是为了天上的月亮。
那么你对着它默默无语,满怀着深深的思想。
月光照在你身上,你像一个幻影漂漾;
你怀中的那一缕光明,照彻了我心的昏茫。
我独立在夜半的街头,望着你的灯光向你凝眸;
这时候明月已经西沉,只留下你的灯影长留。

In the dark you light a lamp,
As if for the moon up there.
Then to it you say nothing at all,
But are filled with a deep thought.
The moonlight falls upon you,
And you drift like a shadow.
That thread of light you hold in your arms
Sheds daylight through my darkened heart.
I stand alone at the street corner of midnight,
Looking at your lamp, gazing at you.
By now the bright moon has sunk in the west,
And only your lamp's reflection lingers long.
Listen

Meaning

Someone in a dark room lights a lamp, seemingly for the moon; the light that falls on the person becomes a thread that enters the speaker's heart and clears its gloom. Standing alone at a street corner at midnight, the speaker watches the lamp while the moon is setting. The poem is a portrait of love as illumination: a distant, half-imagined person whose small light reaches across the dark and rearranges the speaker's interior.

在黑暗之中,你点起了一盏灯,仿佛是为了天上的月亮。那么你对着它默默无语,满怀着深深的思想。月光照在你的身上,你像一个幻影般漂荡;你怀中的那一缕光明,照彻了我内心的昏茫。我独立在夜半的街头,望着你的灯光向你凝眸;这时候明月已经西沉,只留下你的灯影长久地留存。

Appreciation

[Structure] The twelve lines fall into three movements, each built on one light: the lamp itself ('in the dark you light a lamp'), the moonlit person ('you drift like a shadow'), and the lamp's after-image ('only your lamp's reflection lingers'). The light moves from outside in - from the lamp, to the person, to the heart - and then from present to residue, as the moon sinks. [Imagery] Four objects carry the whole poem: lamp, moon, shadow, reflection. The moon is remote and setting; the lamp is near and will not go out; the shadow is the person as seen; the reflection is the person as kept. Every pair works by contrast - dark/light, far/near, present/lasting. The central move is 'that thread of light you hold in your arms sheds daylight through my darkened heart': the ordinary lamp becomes the object of an unusual tenderness. [Plain Paraphrase] Read plainly, the poem says that the speaker sees from the street a loved one inside a lit room and is changed by that single sight. The restraint is what makes it modern: no word of love, no grief, no complaint - only a lamp, a moon and a corner of a street at night.

【白话串讲】 冯至写《灯》:“黑暗中你点起了一盏灯,像是为了天上的月亮”——“月光照在你身上,你像一个幻影漂漾”——“你怀中的那一缕光明,照彻了我心的昏茫”——他写灯——照彻了我心的昏茫。 【意象与手法】 以“你”为倾诉对象,灯是月下的灯,你是灯下的人,而我独立街头凝眸——光与影、明与昏、近与远之间,弥漫着一层温柔而迷离的情思。语言清丽、意境幽渺。 【情感与主旨】 冯至写夜半街头凝望一盏灯的景象,于灯、月、影、光的交织中写尽深沉的思念与心灵的照亮,是现代爱情诗中的精品。 【名句点睛】 常考“黑暗中你点起了一盏灯,像是为了天上的月亮”写点灯;“你怀中的那一缕光明,照彻了我心的昏茫”写心灵照亮。

Background

Feng Zhi (1905-1993), born in Zhuozhou, Hebei, is the poet Lu Xun named 'China's most outstanding lyric poet'. These early lyric poems, written in the mid-to-late 1920s and collected in 'Yesterday's Songs' and 'Northward and Other Poems', show the influence of German Romanticism and of Rilke and Goethe, though the language is entirely Chinese. The poem belongs to the years of Feng Zhi's courtship and marriage to Shu Hong, the relationship that supplies the reticent, waiting quality of his best love verse. The figure of a person waiting in a lighted room while the speaker keeps watch outside recurs in his work of these years.

此诗为冯至早年的抒情诗,约作于1920年代,收于其诗集《昨日之歌》《北游及其他》等。冯至(1905—1993),河北涿州人,现代著名诗人、学者,被鲁迅誉为「中国最杰出的抒情诗人」。其早期诗作受德国浪漫主义与里尔克、歌德的影响,长于以清丽的语言写细腻幽深的感情,尤以爱情诗、咏物诗见长,情感含蓄而不失真挚。《灯》一诗,写夜半街头凝望一盏灯的情景:黑暗之中,有人点起一盏灯,像是为了天上的月亮;月光照在点灯人的身上,仿佛幻影漂漾;而灯下那一缕光明,竟「照彻了我心的昏茫」。诗中的「你」与「我」,一在灯下,一在街头,隔着一窗灯光相望,构成一幅温柔而迷离的画面。此诗写于诗人青年时代,正值其与恋人书鸿往来、情思萌动的时期,诗中那「为你点灯」「照彻心昏」的意象,正是这种既含蓄又深挚的情感的写照。全诗以灯为核心意象,把月光、人影、灯光织成一片,在现代爱情诗中独标一格。

Art

The poem's technique is the drama of a distance that never closes. Two figures are placed - you inside, I outside - and the only traffic between them is light, which is precisely the thing that cannot carry a message. Feng Zhi keeps the distances unresolved: I am not admitted, you are not aware, and the moon is fading. The word choice does the work quietly: 'drift' gives the person water-borne and unreal motion; the 'thread' reduces a whole lamp to a fibre held in arms, so that light becomes portable and intimate; 'lingers' refuses the closing of the scene. The syntax is studiously plain, so the unusual phrases ('sheds daylight through my darkened heart') land by contrast with the flat line around them.

此诗艺术上以「光与影」的层次为骨,在明暗交织中展开情思。全诗十二行,可分三层:第一层写点灯,「黑暗中你点起了一盏灯,像是为了天上的月亮」,以「黑暗」起笔,反衬灯之明亮;「像是为了天上的月亮」一句,把灯与月联系起来,赋予这盏灯一种为谁而燃的意味,又透出几分凄清的暗示。第二层写灯下之人,「月光照在你身上,你像一个幻影漂漾」,以月光照人、人影如幻,写灯下人的朦胧之美与飘忽之感;「你怀中的那一缕光明,照彻了我心的昏茫」,是全诗情感的核心——那一缕灯光,竟能照彻「我」心头的昏茫,光由外而内,由灯而心,相思之情于此点破。第三层写凝望,「我独立在夜半的街头,望着你的灯光向你凝眸」,写「我」在街头的独立与凝望,一远一近、一明一暗,构成画面的主体;「这时候明月已经西沉,只留下你的灯影长留」,以月的西沉反衬灯的常留,明月易逝而灯影长存,恰似那灯光下的身影与情思,在黑暗中将永驻心头。全诗由灯而人、由人而我、由我而影,层次分明而一气流转,光与影、明与昏、近与远之间,弥漫着一层温柔迷离的情思,是现代抒情诗中以光写情、以景传情的佳构。

Allusions

The poem uses no cited allusion, but it is thick with inherited images. The lamp-as-waiting is the classical Chinese convention: Li Shangyin's 'When shall we trim the west-window candle' turns a lamp into a promise of reunion, and Wen Tingyun's 'dripping until dawn' keeps a lamp burning through sorrow. The moon is the older repository of longing - Li Bai's 'I raise my cup to the bright moon' and Su Shi's 'may we live long' both use it for separation rather than company. Feng Zhi's novelty is to put lamp and moon side by side and let the moon lose: it sets, while the lamp stays. The 'shadow' also reaches back, to Li Bai's 'face-to-face with my shadow, the three of us', where a shadow is a companion; here the shadow is a figure one can only watch.

此诗为现代新诗,不事用典,而古典的意象与意境自在其中。「灯」在中国古典诗歌中,历来是「等待」「思念」「温暖」的象征:李商隐《夜雨寄北》有「何当共剪西窗烛」的灯下期待,杜牧《秋夕》有「银烛秋光冷画屏」的烛下清冷,温庭筠「空阶滴到明」写灯下彻夜的愁思,皆是灯与情思相伴的传统。冯至此诗「黑暗中你点起了一盏灯」,正是这一传统的现代延续——灯为谁而点,正如烛为谁而剪,皆是有所待、有所念。「明月」意象更是古典诗歌的常客,李白「举头望明月,低头思故乡」、苏轼「但愿人长久,千里共婵娟」,皆以明月写相思;此诗「像是为了天上的月亮」「月光照在你身上」「明月已经西沉」,把灯与月并置,月是远方的思念,灯是眼前的温暖,古典的明月在诗中被赋予了新的意味。「幻影漂漾」一词,则带有一种现代主义的飘忽感,可通于《庄子》「人生天地间,若白驹之过隙」的幻灭之思,也暗合晚唐温李的迷离之境。全诗虽不用一个典故,而「灯下待月、月下望人」的古典意境,如月光般弥漫于字里行间,使这首现代诗在骨子里承接着中国抒情诗千年的余韵。

Commentary

Feng Zhi's lyric of the 1920s is usually prized for exactly this restraint, and 'The Lamp' is often quoted as a short statement of his gift. Later readers have found in it a general model of the modern Chinese love poem: the feeling is placed in an object and left there, to be recovered by anyone who stands in the right light. The closing line is the one most often quoted, because it performs the poem's whole argument in four words - the lamp's reflection outlasts the moon, so what remains of a love is not the meeting but the light the meeting left behind. Critics of a more historicist bent note that the poem cages a social situation (a woman at home at night, a man unable to enter) inside a decoratively timeless lyric, and that this tension between constraint and longing is where the poem's real energy lies.

读此诗,最动人处在于「灯」与「我」之间那层说不尽的距离与亲近。灯在黑暗的屋里亮着,你在灯下,我在街头的夜半;月光照着你,我隔着窗望着你——分明近在咫尺,又仿佛远在天涯。诗中「你像一个幻影漂漾」,最是微妙:你不是真实的你,而是隔着光与影、隔着「我」的凝望而显现的幻影;正因为是幻影,才那样美丽,也那样不可触及。而全诗情感的核心,是那一句「你怀中的那一缕光明,照彻了我心的昏茫」——那一缕灯光,原是照在屋里的,竟能穿过夜色、穿过凝望,照进「我」的心底,把满心的昏茫照得透亮。这「照彻」二字,写尽爱情给人的照亮与救赎:昏茫的心,因为一盏灯、一个人,忽然有了光。然而月光西沉了,人也要隐入黑暗了,只留下灯影长留——这灯影,既是那人留下的最后痕迹,也是「我」心头那一缕被照亮的光,将长留不去。冯至的诗,向以含蓄节制见长,此诗写相思,不着一字「爱」字,而灯、月、影、光之间,处处是爱;不写一句「思念」,而街头凝眸、灯影长留之中,句句是思念。这种「以物写情、情在物中」的写法,正是冯至作为「中国最杰出的抒情诗人」的过人之处,也是此诗历久弥新的原因。

Prosody

Form Modern free verse, three-stanza lyric of twelve lines现代自由诗(分段体抒情短诗)
Rhyme There is no fixed scheme, but the poem rhymes loosely and audibly at the ends of lines, especially on the rounded -ang sound: 'a lamp', 'a thought' (near-rhymes), 'upon you'/'shadow', and above all 'darkened heart'... with 'lingers long'. The recurrence of the open -ang vowel across the three stanzas gives the poem its wide, unhurried sound, which is the acoustic equivalent of lamplight spreading.此诗为现代自由诗,押韵较自由而于关键处见匠心:全诗以「灯」「亮」「量」「漾」「茫」「眸」「沉」「留」等字在句尾构成松散的韵脚,尤以「漾」「茫」(下平七阳、去声二十三漾韵)、「眸」「留」等字的呼应,形成一种若有若无的韵律感。「茫」「漾」「亮」「长」等阳韵字的反复出现,使全诗在声音上弥漫着一层开阔而绵长的光感,正合灯光弥漫、情思悠长的意境,是现代自由诗「内在韵律」的体现。
Tone pattern Line lengths are irregular - nine characters, eight, seven, eight - so the verse breathes rather than marches. The rhythm tracks feeling: 'In the dark you light a lamp' opens decisive; 'But are filled with a deep thought' slows; 'I stand alone at the street corner of midnight' is the longest and most isolated line of the poem, matching the speaker's solitude; the final line 'And only your lamp's reflection lingers long' is drawn out and low.句式上,此诗以七言、九言、十言的长短句错落相间:「黑暗中你点起了一盏灯」九字起句,顿挫有力;「像是为了天上的月亮」八字舒展;「你像一个幻影漂漾」七字轻灵;「照彻了我心的昏茫」八字沉挚;「我独立在夜半的街头」九字孤峭;「只留下你的灯影长留」九字低回。全诗节奏由起灯的明快,到观人的迷离,到凝眸的专注,再到灯影长留的低回,声调起伏与情感流转相谐,是自由诗中以节奏驭情感的佳构。
Reading note The prosody of this poem is entirely internal. What sounds is the repetition of opening, rounded vowels and the roughly iambic fall of the English line, plus the deliberate flatness of the syntax. Read aloud, the poem should not be hurried: the value lies in the pauses after 'As if for the moon up there' and 'Looking at your lamp'. For a learner of Chinese poetry, this is a useful example of a twentieth-century poem whose rhythm is carried by meaning and pause rather than by tone pattern.作为现代自由诗,《灯》的声律之美,不在格律的束缚,而在分行的呼吸与句式的节奏。全诗十二行,可分为三个层次,每一层都以一个「光」的核心意象为中心:第一层写灯之光,第二层写月光与人影,第三层写灯影之留,光由远而近、由外而内、由明而长,构成了一个完整的意象序列。诗中「像是为了天上的月亮」「你像一个幻影漂漾」「只留下你的灯影长留」等句,句式舒缓而意象空灵,正合冯至抒情诗「于平淡处见深情」的风格。就全诗而言,此诗以最简净的语言写最幽深的相思,灯、月、影、光四个意象交织成一片温柔迷离的境界,既有德国浪漫主义的清丽,又带着中国古典抒情诗的含蓄,是现代爱情诗中最具代表性的篇章之一,也可见冯至作为「中国最杰出的抒情诗人」的卓越诗才。

Line by line

黑暗中你点起了一盏灯,

In the dark you light a lamp,

在无边无际的黑暗之中,你点起了一盏灯。

In the darkness you lit a lamp,

这一句是全诗的起笔,也是整个意境的起点。「黑暗中」三字,先铺开一片无边的黑暗——这黑暗既是夜色之实,也是心境之喻,是灯之所以为灯的背景;「你点起了一盏灯」,一个「点」字,写那光亮是从无到有、由暗而明地升起的,仿佛黑暗被轻轻撕开一个口子。以「黑暗」衬「灯」,灯的温暖与珍贵不言自明;而「你」点灯的动作,又为全诗定下了倾诉的基调——不是无主的灯,而是「你」亲手点起的灯,灯因人而有情,人因灯而可见。此句起笔极简而意境全出,黑暗与灯光的对比,为后文「月光照在你身上」「照彻了我心的昏茫」的光影层次作了铺垫,是全诗由暗入明的第一道门。

The opening is the starting point of the poem and of its whole mood. 'In the darkness' first spreads a boundless night—both literal dark and the image of a darkened heart, the background against which a lamp means anything. 'You lit a lamp': the single 'lit' writes the light rising from nothing, darkness torn open as if by a hand. Set against 'darkness,' the lamp's warmth and preciousness speak for themselves; and the 'you' makes the act personal—not an ownerless lamp but one you have lit with your own hand, the lamp becoming dear because of the person. The opening is spare, yet the whole scene is there, and the contrast of dark and light sets up the light-and-shadow layers of all that follows, the first door from darkness into brightness.

你怀中的那一缕光明,

That thread of light you hold in your arms,

你怀中捧着的、散发出来的那一缕光明,照彻了我内心的昏茫。

That thread of light from your embrace—it has shone through the blindness of my heart.

这一句是全诗情感的核心,也是「灯」的意象由外而内、由物而心的关键转折。「你怀中的那一缕光明」,把灯光写得仿佛是从你怀中捧出来的——灯不再只是窗内的一件物事,而是与「你」贴身相依、由「你」怀抱着的光明,灯与你合而为一;「那一缕」三字,写光的纤细与温柔,不是灼灼的烈焰,而是一缕清光。「照彻了我心的昏茫」,是全诗的警句:那一缕灯光,原是照在屋里的,竟能穿过夜色的重重阻隔,照进「我」的心底,把满心的昏茫照得透亮。「昏茫」写心之暗昧,「照彻」写光之透彻,一昏一明、一内一外,写尽一个人被另一个人的光芒所照亮的感动。以此写相思,不着一「爱」字,而深情自在,是现代爱情诗中最含蓄也最深刻的表达。

This line is the emotional center and the turning of the lamp-image from outward object to inward light. 'That thread of light from your embrace' pictures the lamp as if cupped in your arms—the lamp no longer a thing in the room but a light held close to your body, lamp and you made one. 'That thread' catches the light's slenderness and tenderness, no blazing flame but a single clear ray. 'It has shone through the blindness of my heart' is the poem's aphorism: the light that was meant for the room has, crossing the night, entered my heart and lit its dark through. 'Blindness' is the heart's gloom, 'shone through' the light's clarity, dark and bright, inner and outer, writing the emotion of being lit by another person's light. It writes love without naming 'love,' the most reserved and profound of modern love lyrics.

只留下你的灯影长留。

And only your lamp's reflection lingers long.

这时候明月已经西沉,只留下你的灯影,长久地留存。

the bright moon has already sunk westward; only your lamp-shadow remains, lingering on.

结句以月的西沉反衬灯影的常留,是全诗意境的收束与升华。「明月已经西沉」,写时间的流转与月光的消逝——明月本是远方的象征,此刻已经西沉,仿佛那遥远的光明也将随之而去;「只留下你的灯影长留」,以「只留下」写余下的唯一,以「长留」写留存之久,那灯下人的身影,竟在月沉之后仍长留不去。此句的妙处,在于以「月」的易逝反衬「灯影」的永恒:明月再美,也要西沉;而你的灯影,却在黑暗中将永驻心头。这「长留」的灯影,既是那人留下的最后痕迹,也是「我」心头被照亮的、永难磨灭的光。全诗由灯起、由影结,光与影、明与昏在此达成最后的平衡,余韵悠长,令人低回不已,是现代抒情诗中最含蓄隽永的结尾之一。

The closing line sets the sinking moon against the lingering lamp-shadow, the resolution and heightening of the poem. 'The moon has sunk westward' writes time's passage and the passing of the moon—the moon, long a symbol of distant light, now gone down, as if that far brightness were departing too. 'Only your lamp-shadow remains, lingering on': 'only' stresses what is left, 'lingering on' its long stay—the figure by the lamp outlasting the moon's setting. The art lies in setting the moon's fleetingness against the lamp-shadow's permanence: beautiful as the moon is, it must sink, yet your lamp-shadow stays, forever lit in the heart. This lingering shadow is both the last trace the person left and the unerasable light she kindled in me. The poem begins with the lamp and ends with its shadow, light and dark at last in balance, an ending of quiet depth among modern lyrics.

Study

Word focus

漂漾 'Piaoyang' means to float and undulate on water; here it describes the person under moonlight as if drifting on water, so that she is not solidly standing but moving like a reflection. It gives the figure both beauty and unreachability: what drifts can be watched but not held, and the word quietly anticipates the 'shadow' of the previous line. 「你像一个幻影漂漾」之「漂漾」,是此诗最具神韵的一词。「漂漾」本写水面上的浮动,诗人移以写月光下的人影,写出那人如在水波上浮动、荡漾的飘忽之感——月光如水,人影如幻,一者流荡,一者漂漾,物我皆在浮动之中。以「漂漾」写人,正见灯下人的朦胧之美与不可捉摸:她不是静止地立着,而是在月光与灯影间轻轻浮动,如幻如真,仿佛随时都会消散。此词既写光下之影的视觉之态,又暗含「幻影」所预示的不可触及——漂漾者,终将漂去,愈美愈令人怅惘。以「漂漾」二字写幻影,意象新鲜而情思缥缈,是此诗炼字的精妙处。
昏茫 'Hunmang', dark and vague - the state of the speaker's mind, not total night but a turbid, unlit confusion, as befits a man standing alone at midnight. It exists to be opposed: because the heart is 'darkened', the 'thread of light' has something to penetrate, and the whole effect of the lamp depends on this one adjective. 「照彻了我心的昏茫」之「昏茫」,是此诗情感落点处的一词之炼。「昏茫」者,昏暗而迷茫,写「我」心的状态:不是全然的黑暗,也不是明朗的光明,而是昏昏沉沉、茫茫然无所依的暗昧。以「昏茫」写心,既有夜色的浸染,又有情思的迷惘,暗合「我独立在夜半的街头」的孤寂处境。而正是这「昏茫」的心,被「那一缕光明」照彻——「照彻」与「昏茫」相对,一明一暗,写尽光之强烈与心之渴待:唯其心是昏茫的,那一缕光才那样珍贵;唯其光能照彻,那一点情才那样深挚。以「昏茫」衬「照彻」,是此诗以暗写明、以反衬正的经典笔法,二字的分量,正在于它让那一缕灯光有了照彻的对象与意义。
凝眸 'Ningmou', to fix the eyes in concentration - staring without blinking. The word is old, used in Tang verse of a woman's absorbed gaze, and Feng Zhi's use of it transfers that classical interior to a modern street scene. It marks the speaker's whole being as concentrated in the act of looking, which is why the lamp's after-image can take hold of him. 「望着你的灯光向你凝眸」之「凝眸」,写「我」凝神注视的姿态,是此诗情感的最直观表达。「凝」者,凝定、专注也,「眸」者,眼珠也,「凝眸」即目不转睛地注视,一个动作写尽「我」的全部深情与痴望。以「凝眸」写街头之望,比「注视」「望着」更见专注:他不是随意地看,而是把全部的注意力都凝定在那灯光、那人影之上,仿佛要用目光穿过夜色、穿过灯光,抵达那人的心底。此词古已有之,唐人诗中「凝眸」多用写女子的专注之态,冯至移以写「我」的凝望,更添一层现代的深情。以「凝眸」收束全诗的观望,正见「我」之情的深挚与专注,也为结句「灯影长留」的余韵作了情感的铺垫。

Related Reading

断章 A Fragment 卞之琳 · 同为现代诗的凝望与视角,一写桥上风景一写灯下之人,构思相映成趣 Both poems set two figures watching each other across a gap, and both make the gap itself the subject - the lamp poem keeps it, the fragment turns it into a relation

Bian Zhilin's famous 'A Fragment' says: 'You stand on the bridge looking at the scene; the one looking at the scene is in the tower above. The moon dress your window, you dress another's dream.' Both poems create a triangle of looks - I see you, you are inside your own light - and both refuse to resolve whether the feeling is returned. Where Bian Zhilin's intelligence turns the situation into a paradox, Feng Zhi's feeling turns it into a duration: the watching goes on after the moon is gone. The two together describe the central modernist concern with 'looking and being looked at' in twentieth-century Chinese poetry.

卞之琳《断章》「你站在桥上看风景,看风景的人在楼上看你。明月装饰了你的窗子,你装饰了别人的梦」,写「你」与「看风景的人」之间的相互凝望、互为风景,是现代诗写「视角」与「相对」的经典;冯至《灯》「我独立在夜半的街头,望着你的灯光向你凝眸」,同样写「我」隔窗凝望灯下之人,一在明处凝望、一在暗处被望,形成相望的格局。一以「桥上/楼上」的方位写相对,一以「街头/灯下」的距离写相思,两诗同写「凝望」而各极其致。并读之下,可见中国现代诗在1920—30年代对「看与被看」这一母题的共同兴趣,也可体会两位抒情诗人一智性一深情的不同风格。

月下独酌·其一 Drinking Alone Beneath the Moon, No. 1 李白 · 同为月下独处之作,一邀月共饮一望灯怀人,明月意象古今相映 Both are poems of a figure alone under a moon, and in both the moon is the illustrious witness; the difference is that Li Bai makes the moon a companion and Feng Zhi makes the lamp a message

Li Bai's poem takes a jar of wine in the flowers and invites the moon and his own shadow to make three, so that solitude becomes company by invention. Feng Zhi's speaker is also alone under a moon, but nothing is invented to keep him company; instead an interior light does the work, and the moon quietly leaves. The classical inheritance is clear in both: the moon as the shared medium of longing. The modernity is in the direction of the light - Li Bai drinks with the sky, Feng Zhi watches through a window.

李白《月下独酌》「花间一壶酒,独酌无相亲。举杯邀明月,对影成三人」,以月为友、以影为伴,写独处的旷达与浪漫,明月成了诗人排遣孤独的伴侣;冯至《灯》则写「黑暗中你点起了一盏灯,像是为了天上的月亮」「这时候明月已经西沉,只留下你的灯影长留」,明月同样是诗中重要的意象,却由独处的伴侣变为思念的见证——月沉而灯留,明月照人、灯光照心。一以月为友而自得其乐,一以灯寄情而凝望长留;同是月下之情,而一旷达一深婉。并读两诗,可见「明月」这一古典意象在现代诗中的承继与转化,也可见古今诗人借月写情而各具面目的姿态。

夜雨寄北 Written on a Rainy Night in Ba 李商隐 · 同为灯下夜思、以光寄情之作,一剪烛共话一望灯长留,相思一脉相承 Both are lamp poems written by a separated lover in the night; one waits for a future shared candle, the other watches a light that will not be shared

Li Shangyin asks 'When shall we trim the west-window candle, and speak of this Ba night of rain?' - the lamp belongs to a reunion still to come, and the candle is something both will trim. Feng Zhi's lamp is already lit by another for reasons the speaker never learns. The shared future is replaced by an unreturned present, yet the ending keeps something of the older poem's consolation: what remains, the lamp's reflection, is also the beginning of a memory. Along with Li Bai's moon, this is the poem's main line of descent in the Chinese lyric.

李商隐《夜雨寄北》「何当共剪西窗烛,却话巴山夜雨时」,以「共剪西窗烛」的想象写未来重逢的期待,烛光成为离人团聚的象征;冯至《灯》则写「黑暗中你点起了一盏灯」「只留下你的灯影长留」,灯光成为眼前思念的寄托。一以烛光写未来的相聚,一以灯影写当下的凝望;李商隐的烛是「共剪」的、要等到的,冯至的灯是「长留」的、永驻心头的。同是灯烛之下、同是别离相思,而一期待重逢、一沉溺凝望,情思一脉相承而时代风貌迥异。并读两诗,可见中国诗歌中「灯烛」意象从晚唐到现代的情思流转,也可见现代诗人对古典意象的深情回望。